3 ms·
"As someone who has a PhD in biochemistry and has been coding since age 5, I find the headline rediculous. You won't be computing in biology.... principles fro
by jerf 9y ago
"As someone who has a PhD in biochemistry and has been coding since age 5, I find the headline rediculous. You won't be computing in biology.... principles from CS applied to biology which has some validity."
I think it may be worth reminding people that modern-day computing is only a subset of computation, and not even necessarily a very large one. Computing with biology has extremely different characteristics from computing with modern computers, and the field of Software Engineering may not have much to say about it except in the vaguest of terms, but Computer Science may still have quite a lot to say about the limits of computation on this new substrate, how to do error correction, and all sorts of other things.
A computational formalism can easily be applied to something like an anti-body, and of course, anything larger than that. The primary thing that stops us is the fact that we have such a poor picture of what is going on that we don't have the data to create the formalisms correctly, nor machines (biological or otherwise) to manipulate such formalisms. But that's a human limitation and in some sense an engineering limitation, not a limitation of Computer Science.
Whatever we are coding in biology will be radically, radically different. Entire classes of squabbles in our industry become irrelevant; you won't get a concurrency choice (it's just "yes, all the time and everywhere"), there will be no meaningful debate over mutability (again, "yes all the time and everywhere"), "structured programming" is just meaningless since the entire concept of "scope" will be out the window. I don't know what it will look like. But I do know that whatever it is, quite a bit of Computer Science will still apply to it. Biological computing will not be immune to information theory. It won't be immune to complexity theory, although a whole new suite of classes will probably have to arise, and there will be a lot more probability in it (but recall that complexity theory already extensively uses that, so it's not like that's a new thing). And even software engineering won't be entirely tossed out... for instance, "leaky abstractions" will be an even bigger problem than they are for us now.
- dnautics 9y agoComputing with biology would be more like the "movable feast" computing architecture videos on YouTube. Prepare to be out-neckbearded if you watch them. Not sure how useful it would be. You don't want your bank account running on such a machine. Part of what makes computing extremely useful is that it's a crutch that lets us do things our feeble human minds can't do. Logical purity, high numerical computation, immutable logging and provenance. At the edge we start to tolerate imprecision in some domains like hci and decision making when there's a premium attached to the process, that statistically (or if we're being cynical, projects the appearance of) yields an improvement, like being able to ingest high inhuman volumes of data, or where human interaction in the correction of erroneous processing is proximal and minimally effort inducing.
- shadowphex 9y agoIt will be different, but concurrency, mutability, structured programming, and scope are very relevant. Concurrency: Not all genes are run at all times. Gene regulation can look a lot like code. Ex: if(curr_temp > DANGER_TEMP){temperature_defense_gene.activate()}. Mutability & Scope: Cells that have the same genome can act very differently (all of your cells have ~the same DNA, but act very differently) and some cells in your body can change roles. Structured Programming: Biological pathways use a lot of control flows. [1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biological_pathway https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biological_pathway
- entee 9y agoWhile there's truth in the paradigm you advance, it's not anywhere near as binary or direct as you might me suggesting. There's a ton of leakage and noise at most stages in biological pathways. Biology actually spends enormous amounts of effort to reduce the noise and leakage, but it's really hard to eliminate entirely. Lets take the danger temp gene you use as an example. In bacteria that's mostly true, but even there what if we're low on nutrients? Or low on a particular nutrient? Or what if we start producing too much protein which is aggregating because the concentration is too high? Each cell is balancing all these concerns simultaneously, so even very simple biological circuits work/don't work in unexpected ways. What the OP is suggesting is that you're always concurrent with a huge number of different things going on that are far less isolated from your "process" than is traditionally the case in CS. I agree that concurrency, mutability, scope, all that is relevant, but I think the OP's point that we don't have the theory on how those will apply in a biological context is correct. Edit: for those interested, some papers on biological noise and the efforts cells use to reduce it: https://arxiv.org/pdf/1610.00820.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/1610.00820.pdf https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4006352/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4006352/ https://www.cell.com/molecular-cell/abstract/S1097-2765(12)00038-X https://www.cell.com/molecular-cell/abstract/S1097-2765(12)0...
- glenstein 9y ago>Whatever we are coding in biology will be radically, radically different. ... But I do know that whatever it is, quite a bit of Computer Science will still apply to it. Whenever there's an article about computation and the brain, or computation and biology, there's always someone showing up saying that the comparison is ridiculous because, hey, biology/computers are different. To me, that's always felt like it was missing a huge point and I think your comment is one of the better ways I've seen it expressed. I hope we're getting closer to a point where we can eventually turn the page on this, and the Hubert Dreyfus-style arguments/declarations about what "computers can't do."
- dnautics 9y agoit's not about what "computers can't do", it's about what "biology can't do". Or more, appropriately, "what you could maybe push biology's round peg into a square hole and force it to do but we should probably stop and think about whether it's worth the effort".