3 ms·
Call me naive but I disagree with the points about Kubernetes. While they did make Kubernetes specifically for their GKE offering, it was before Docker Swarm ev
by jchw 9y ago
Call me naive but I disagree with the points about Kubernetes. While they did make Kubernetes specifically for their GKE offering, it was before Docker Swarm even existed, so it didn't directly compete with Docker. I doubt Swarm was doomed to failure; more, it felt like the priorities were off (it was simpler than Kubernetes at the cost of being less useful.)
Further, Google has been taking the Google bits out of Kubernetes. They declined to call their own offering "Google Kubernetes Engine" officially until the playing field was level and they had a certification program. Amazon, Azure, DigitalOcean and others are implementing their own managed Kubernetes solutions.
Google doesn't have to cheat here. Speaking as someone dealing with Google Cloud directly, they are mainly hitting on the point that Google Cloud offers better network and disk performance, in a more flexible manner, for significantly less money. And honest to God they're right. The CPU performance is worse in some cases, but we're saving money on workloads so far.
On the flip side, as long time AWS users, the Kubernetes experience has been pretty good since Kubernetes 1.3. New features typically support AWS pretty early in, with the main exception being Ingress controllers (for good reason: ALBs weren't even released when that became a thing.)
Google is one of those companies big enough to make it easy to feel like they have evil ulterior motives, but I'll be honest: in my dealings with them, I've felt that the opposite is true and generally the intentions are good.
- scarface74 9y agoI wouldn't trust my business to Google Cloud Platform because they have a habit of abandoning services that aren't related to their core business - search and ads. I have more confidence in Amazon and Microsoft.
- jchw 9y agoI'm sorry you feel that way, because Google Cloud is really nice and if nothing else, it provokes a lot of thought. It's worth evaluating in my opinion. I'm not saying it's better than other offerings - It's not all around - but the building blocks are really nice.
- scarface74 9y agoIt's not about being "better". It's about trusting Google to have the same focus as Amazon and Microsoft. Besides, no one ever got fired for choosing AWS....
- jchw 9y agoWhat I'm saying isn't "migrate a critical part of your workload to Google" - just suggesting that it's worth evaluating Google Cloud, merely for your own reference, even if you are sure you aren't going to use it. They offer a pretty good free trial to do so.
- scarface74 9y agoIf I were starting a business in 2018 or consulting with someone who was doing an infrastructure migration, I couldn't in good conscience tell them to go to GCP. The support infrastructure isn't as good - ie people who have experience. There is a lot to be said about choosing the default. I've been a .Net developer for over a decade, but when I started looking into Lambda for instance and saw that it looks like most people were using Node and to a lesser extent Python, I begrudgingly started learning Python. In hindsight, I'm glad I did. I'm actually starting to like Python and I usually hate scripting languages. Besides, for my own selfish reasons, why would I spend time on the cloud platform that is the least marketable? Companies are asking for AWS and to a lesser extent Azure experience. Very few are asking for GCP experience.
- bryanlarsen 9y agoKubernetes experience is very marketable, I believe.
- scarface74 9y agoKubernetes isn't tied to hosting on Google' cloud. Amazon offers EKS and Microsoft offers a hosted service.
- jacksmith21006 9y agoReally? Do not think they would walk away from over $4B of business a year. Google sticks with things that are core. Google reader was obviously not core. Glasses moved to enterprise and continue to be used in that setting.
- scarface74 9y agoIt's not about abandonment as much as it is about focusing on it. Take Apple as an example, the Mac is an $6 billion+ A quarter business for Apple but only 11% of their business. No one would say that Apple focuses on the Mac.
- jacksmith21006 9y agoGoogle is really focused on GCP and suspect they will continue to be. Constantly adding new capabilities.