5 ms·
> such small & reasonable actions routinely ruffle feathers on the right. I'm not sure why you'd assume the person who left was on the right just because they
by naasking 9y ago
> such small & reasonable actions routinely ruffle feathers on the right.
I'm not sure why you'd assume the person who left was on the right just because they disagreed with the direction LLVM was taking. When I read the message, it seemed like he had grave concerns that technical merit was now taking a back seat to a political agenda. That seems like a legitimate concern for an open source project.
- danharaj 9y ago> I'm not sure why you'd assume the person who left was on the right just because they disagreed with the direction LLVM was taking. Bayesian priors.
- naasking 9y agoBayesian priors would also suggest that certain minorities are more likely to be criminals. Should we therefore treat people from such minorities as criminals? Bayesian priors don't guide all of our ethics. My Bayesian priors suggest that the OP wanted an easy way to dismiss the person's concerns without addressing them.
- danharaj 9y agoI think having an expectation about someone's further political beliefs based on information about some of their political beliefs is a little less unethical than presuming criminality, my friend. But you're right tho, I think it's easier to cut out the middle man and dismiss his concerns because I think his concerns are shit, regardless of his other politics.
- forgottenpass 9y ago>Bayesian priors. Is your point anything more than saying "political stereotyping" using verbiage that suggests you agree with the assessment? Even my attempt to find lay-person verbiage for your idea ("stereotyping") found words that carry a negative connotation.
- danharaj 9y agoI cannot parse your verbiage.
- forgottenpass 9y agoI'm implying your showy language classed up an idea that that people would be more likley to dismiss on it's face if described plainly. I've attempted an edit for clarity.
- danharaj 9y agoWell, my choice of words was tongue in cheek, haha only serious, but also knowing my crowd. Bayesian inference is a popular almost-meme on HN which I thought made my terse flippancy more amusing.
- annabellish 9y agoIn a vacuum, absolutely, but the reasons stated in the post don't really seem very ruffling. One intern with no indications that technical ability is unimportant, and a code of conduct that seems very inoffensive, is hardly worthy of "grave concerns that technical merit was now taking a back seat to a political agenda". It's possible that he's primarily talking about backroom conversations of which we are not privy to, but he doesn't mention this, and it does make the post look fairly unreasonable. IMO, it sounds _very_ much like the guy is just tired of working on the project on technical grounds, and is making the unfounded claim that those technical grounds are being caused by political actions he doesn't agree with.
- naasking 9y ago> It's possible that he's primarily talking about backroom conversations of which we are not privy to, but he doesn't mention this, and it does make the post look fairly unreasonable. Strange, I thought the opposite: his decision wasn't made in a vacuum. His argument may look unreasonable only if you had no idea of the wider efforts to push similar political agendas throughout the industry and open source communities, and how meritocratic concerns are pushed aside as a result. Discrimination of any kind is a fallacious argument, that someone doesn't need assistance simply because they belong to a particular group. It's just as fallacious as treating someone like a criminal simply because they belong to a particular group. I admit, I go back and forth myself on the ethics of group-specific programs, rather than a more inclusive approach helping underprivileged individuals without regard to any particular group to which they may belong. I too might have no problem with Outreachy if it weren't couched in such exclusive language, and if the wider movement in the industry hadn't already been so divisive. > IMO, it sounds _very_ much like the guy is just tired of working on the project on technical grounds, and is making the unfounded claim that those technical grounds are being caused by political actions he doesn't agree with. Open source contribution is entirely voluntary. He could walk away for literally any reason at any time. What possible reason could he have to raise a political shitstorm that would only hinder his chance at future career opportunities if he didn't believe what he wrote? It just sounds like you're looking for a narrative with ulterior motivations so you can easily dismiss his concerns.
- bachmeier 9y ago> technical merit was now taking a back seat to a political agenda I think we read different posts. AFAICT, the project is going to get the help of an intern at no or little cost, but he got emotional because he opposes attempts to get underrepresented groups involved. His post was purely political, with no concern for what is best for the project.
- naasking 9y agoYou can only read it that way if you ignore the fact that this same agenda is being pushed everywhere else. See my other post: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16994302 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16994302
- bachmeier 9y agoI have to judge the words I read at the link I click.
- naasking 9y agoWell if you're free to ignore all context, then you can cast anyone resisting the status quo as a bad actor.
- youdontknowtho 9y agoIs that really the case though or are the people "resisting the status quo" actually feigning offense over "discrimination" because they resent the fact that their position is widely accepted as immoral? (Racism or sexism.) They refuse to argue their actual point... minorities should not receive benefits because they do not deserve benefits for one reason or another...because those reasons are also considered unnacceptable to express by most people.
- naasking 9y agoWell if you're free to ignore the principle of charity, then you can ascribe any sort of unethical motives to your opponents. I could just as easily argue that such anti-discrimination efforts are really driven by white-people hate, and accuse them of refusing to address this point. And how you feel right now at that over the top statement is exactly how your opponents feel when you make the contrary claim. Absent some expressed inconsistency, you take people at their word. As I've explained elsewhere in this thread, there's nothing inconsistent with what the LLVM dev has said, and it's fully justifiable from ethical principles. Maybe he is being disingenuous, but that doesn't make the argument itself wrong.