11 ms·
Lisp, Jazz, Aikido
- submeta 9y agoThe title reminds me of the book "Goedel, Escher, Bach" (Douglas Hofstadter).
- AllegedAlec 9y agoExcept that Goedel, Escher, Bach is not as pretentious...
- nabla9 9y agoPretentious just simple extension to CLOS (Common Lisp Object System) thanks to the power of Lisp and MOP (Meta Object Protocol). In any other language adding aspect oriented, context oriented or pretentious extensions requires writing a whole new language.
- JasonFruit 9y agoI found Goedel, Escher, Bach just as pretentious and ridiculous as this paper. As an undergrad, I wrote a paper that was almost that pretentious, and I'm embarrassed about it every time I think of it. How do these things make it past, in GED's case, editors, and in this case, both referees and editors? Someone has to point out the Emperor's unfortunate nudity.
- mathattack 9y agoGEB touches on the internal looping of G, E and B. There is a real idea underneath.
- chubot 9y agoPulling out my curmudgeon hat for the sake of argument... I read GEB in college and actually bought a copy about 10 years later, to see if it resonated more. But I ended up barely re-reading it. I don't remember anything that substantive about the connections. "Internal looping" seems like a vague connection. The Godel sentence is self-referential for sure. That's a concrete and specific property. All I remember about Escher is that there is the picture of the hands drawing each other. OK, it's a great picture, and a nice analogy. Is it profound? Did I miss something besides that trivial observation? I don't recall how Bach is supposed to figure in. How is Bach self-referential or how does it display "internal looping"? (And what does that even mean?) Computer science is full of better examples than Escher or Bach, IMO. For example, C compilers written in C, which lead to the Thompson "trusting trust" attack. Compilers are mentioned in GEB, but it's done in a way that I didn't find particularly helpful (probably because I already know something about the subject.) I also experienced this with my Python compiler written in Python [1]. There were some interesting cases where knowledge of the variable names used in the compiler "leaked" into the compiled output via, I believe via the string intern table of the Python VM. [1] http://www.oilshell.org/blog/2018/03/04.html http://www.oilshell.org/blog/2018/03/04.html
- mathattack 9y agoEscher paintings are circular and self referential. Staircases that perpetually go up. Bach’s music is circular in terms of scales. A up to G and back to A.
- chubot 9y agoBut circular != self-referential. Self-referential is a deeper property. If I have 2 mutually recursive functions, that's circular. For example, most parsers have mutually recursive functions. There's nothing self-referential about them though. On the other hand, a C compiler written in C is self-referential. It confuses subject and object, which leads to some interesting paradoxes like the number for the "tab" character never appearing in the source code, as Ken Thompson points out. The Godel sentence is self-referential. It makes a claim about itself. The movie Synecdoche NY and some of Lewis Carroll's works (which figure heavily in GEB as I recall) are self-referential. The person writing the work appears in the work. Charlie Kaufman does this a lot -- the movie Adaption also has these properties. But I don't see that Bach's music is self-referential. The music doesn't write more music, or have any awareness of itself. Escher's two hands is self-referential, because it's confusing subject and object. But the staircases aren't self-referential.
- floathub 9y agoG.E.B. did win the 1980 Pulitzer Prize winner for a work of general for non-fiction.
- JasonFruit 9y agoOh, well, if it won an award, it must be good. /s
- riku_iki 9y agoBut Pulitzer Prize committee likely don't have any experts in math, and can't verify some bold statements about math theory described in the book.
- wool_gather 9y agoYou're not wrong that GEB is grandiose and presumptuous in the material it takes on. But one important difference may be that LJA has started from one person's very particular choices* and tried to tie them up and cast them as universal. That often doesn't come off well: I think it tends to be more about the author than the reader. (Caveat: I say this only having skimmed the paper here, not read the whole thing. And having loved GEB.) GEB, on the other hand, mostly started from a bunch of universal ideas, and used the author's idiosyncrasies as a way to explore those ideas. I think it comes much closer to hitting its mark. There's no accounting for taste, though. If you don't like Hofstadter's way of thinking, you probably just won't enjoy his book. I'm sure some people find the Dialogues and their wide-eyed "discoveries" of analogies with the essays' material to be smarmy at best. Personally, I find the language of this paper to be overly flowery and too cooler-than-thou (yes, I've heard of Erik Satie; does it matter?) to enjoy. ---- * I mean, "By introspecting my personal aesthetic sensitivities, I eventually realized that my tastes in the scientific, artistic, and physical domains are all motivated by the same driving forces"...that basically says "I think you're going to love reading my diary".
- jrq 9y agoI certainly disagree that GEB was pretentious. For beings that can understand information, surely computation is the highest possible goal. To that end, a certain seriousness and prestige is available when referring to CS. We all have our opinions. Did you find GEB to be a helpful reference? What kind of science were you studying? Not to invade your privacy, I was just curious.
- JasonFruit 9y agoI didn't find GEB helpful. It presented its information in a way that, if you're being charitable, sounded like, "Check out this cool thing these interesting people have in common that will tweak your brain!" The problem for me was that it often lapsed into, "Check out how cool I am that I can understand these acknowledged deep thinkers, and impose this pattern on their thought even when it's only peripherally appropriate!". Some of that perception may have been from my assessment of the people I knew who talked about it too much, though, now that I think of it.
- jrq 9y agoThe language in GEB can be a bit much, but I find it to be a consistently effective took for opening someone's eyes to the vast universe of computer science. There should be a GEB for Hackers or something like that, though. Accessibility is an issue. Maybe not accessibility in the sense of grokking the content, but certainly in staying engaged to it throughout the text. It feels like a lot of work. Humility is important too. GEB could definitely use some more of that too. Thanks for your insight
- palimpsests 9y ago> For beings that can understand information, surely computation is the highest possible goal. That sounds almost like a statement of religion. I am a being that understands information; "computation" is not even remotely close to my highest goals.
- jrq 9y agoMaybe not as an individual, but as a society or as a species, there are few absolutes for us to pursue. History and Math are the only absolutes we really have. What I'm meaning to say is its a righteous goal compared to pursuing art or literature, because it's universal in nature. I think Turing will be remembered as one of the few people who changed the course of human thought in its entirety. I understand what you're saying, and sure, my goal right now this weekend is to get some plane tickets and an airbnb booked, there's no computing mysticism there. But as a whole, I think we humans have an objective to find four the most information possible and to do the most computing as possible. That's essentially what the singularity is about, a human creation coming to a point of autonomy. That's the next step for humans, I think, abandoning flesh and spreading autonomous machines throughout the cosmos. I guess it IS my religion.
- kazinator 9y agoShrug. I found that arithmoquinification of G's uncle stuff to be very helpful in terms of its explanatory power. Puffed up or not, Hofstadter made it accessible without dumbing it down. GED is a good overview of various issues and stimulates thinking. He kind of lost me when in one of his books, Le Ton beau de Marot, I came across a little diatribe against rock and roll. Fuc...king wanker! :)
- kazinator 9y agoHere is another piece of my personal experience with GEB. In GEB, I first encountered SHRDLU and the "blocks world". But, you see, I didn't think it was real; I somehow thought it was a use case document for such a system presented as a fantasy interactive session, haha! There are so many "fantasy fugue" type threads in GEB that you don't know what is real and what is fiction. Hofstadter doesn't go out of his way to make it clear. I don't remember seeing a clear clue that "hey, ignorant reader, this is a real session captured from a program someone actually wrote in Lisp in early 1970-something". At that time, there was no (residential) Internet and no search engine where you could just look up SHRDLU.
- CyberDildonics 9y agoThis seems like a contest for the most prententious paper ever written.
- carlesfe 9y agoI don't know why you are downvoted. This is an excerpt of the abstract: > By introspecting my personal aesthetic sensitivities, I eventually realized that my tastes in the scientific, artistic, and physical domains are all motivated by the same driving forces, hence unifying Lisp, Jazz, and Aikido as three expressions of a single essence, not so different after all. Lisp, Jazz, and Aikido are governed by a limited set of rules which remain simple and unobtrusive. Conforming to them is a pleasure. Because Lisp, Jazz, and Aikido are inherently introspective disciplines, they also invite you to transgress the rules in order to find your own. Breaking the rules is fun. Finally, if Lisp, Jazz, and Aikido unify so many paradigms, styles, or techniques, it is not by mere accumulation but because they live at the meta-level and let you reinvent them. Working at the meta-level is an enlightening experience I am hesitant to criticize the author, because I find the text so absurd that I must clearly be missing something. It looks like satire written for /r/iamverysmart. I'd honestly appreciate being given more context from fellow HNers which upvoted this story and found it interesting.
- vorpalhex 9y agoThis is a pretty par-for-course academic paper written on the philosophy of Aesthetics. The writer is using themselves as a subject via introspection, which is perfectly allowed, and attempting to highlight the aesthetic comparison between three of their favorite hobbies. This isn't supposed to be a hard sciences paper. Aesthetics can, validly, be introspected on a personal level. If reading the paper makes you feel insecure, then you should probably engage in some self-introspection as well.
- cjcole 9y agoAre implications of insecurity and obliviousness also par for the course in academia? (Wait, I know that one already.)
- toolslive 9y agoreminds me of: "How jazz musicians improvise" (P.N.Johnson-Laird) http://mentalmodels.princeton.edu/papers/2002improvisation.pdf http://mentalmodels.princeton.edu/papers/2002improvisation.p...
- tr0ut 9y agoAikido is that fantasy martial arts. The kind that only works when the opponents are in on the ruse. Blockchain is like the Aikido of technology.
- CyberDildonics 9y agoAikido is a fantasy, but 'a blockchain' or 'the blockchain' can be used to create a working currency obviously.
- RHSeeger 9y agoI'm curious as to your opinion of Aikido. While it's certainly purely defensive in nature, it's always seemed very effective at that goal to me.
- nabla9 9y agoHere is good Aikido in combat story from Terry Dobson who studied directly under the Morihei Ueshiba: "Aikido In Action - Doing combat with the essence of love" By Terry Dobson https://www.context.org/iclib/ic04/dobson/ https://www.context.org/iclib/ic04/dobson/
- MikkoFinell 9y agoThere is a reason why Aikido is not used in MMA: Because it's completely ineffectual in a real fight.
- rusk 9y agoIt's not great for entertainment value either. I mean it's an art that has at its very essence the eschewance of conflict. I can't speak for the efficacy of Aikido against an actual trained fighter in some other code, but if it worked the way it was meant to you'd pretty much be watching one guy dodging another guys attacks until eventually he pins him in an arm lock. Fight over.
- MikkoFinell 9y ago
- rusk 9y agoFrom the very start I have to object strongly to his definition of Art as being "what we don't understand", and science being "what we do". An "Artifice" is a subject of human creativity. Science is such an artifice. The actual effective practice of science is "an art" and one that many people simply don't get. Science is the art of developing a better understanding of that which we don't know by applying that which we do ...
- baldfat 9y agoMy personal definition (Coming from a more philosophy discipline. Art is aesthetics with elements of intellect - Science is an intellectual pursuit which can contain beauty. https://academic.oup.com/bjaesthetics/article-abstract/30/1/24/160514?redirectedFrom=PDF https://academic.oup.com/bjaesthetics/article-abstract/30/1/...
- rusk 9y agoFor me, science goes back to the root of the word. It originally goes back to the scalpel, which was used to divide living tissue from dead tissue. That which is objective vs that which is subjective. Also, I wouldn't confine art to the purely aesthetic. But that's just me!
- baldfat 9y ago> Art is aesthetics with elements of intellect
- rusk 9y agoThat's too narrow a definition for me, sorry.
- qbrass 9y ago>For me, science goes back to the root of the word. It originally goes back to the scalpel, which was used to divide living tissue from dead tissue. That which is objective vs that which is subjective. The word "shit" has the same origin, btw.
- M_Bakhtiari 9y ago> Resistance is futile. You will be jazzimilated. Thanks, but no thanks.
- pvaldes 9y agoIt is expression-based, provides extensive control structures, is machine-independent, can solve problems fast avoiding side effects and comes with a convenient boken system (Not to mention looping fabulous in elegant male skirts). But It lacks a decent debug system in real time. Your first grab failed, what do you want to do?: :R1 TRY AGAIN :R2 ABORT :R3 EXIT THE BAR AND RETURN TO YOUR DESKTOP
- kazinator 9y agoJazz has lots of parentheses: changing to another key, doing your little ii-V-I or whatever, then popping back to where you were.
- taylodl 9y agoInteresting. I program for a living, love Lisp and my hobbies are playing Jazz guitar and training in Tae Kwon Do (the art, not the sport) where I'm a 2nd Dan. I never considered the similarities between the three things. What's really interesting is the concept of transgression. In the end you don't learn Lisp, Jazz or Tae Kwon Do. You learn techniques and then learn how to create your own art. I've watched many students struggle with that concept through the years with Jazz and Tae Kwon Do. Never thought about that applying to Lisp as well.