3 ms·
Sorry, Ares was Michael Griffin's folly, using Shuttle technology but not the actual, well understood and qualified components (e.g. the SRBs are wider and the
by hga 16y ago
Sorry, Ares was Michael Griffin's folly, using Shuttle technology but not the actual, well understood and qualified components (e.g. the SRBs are wider and the Ares I stack has 5 segments instead of the normal 4, all leading to extreme $$$ and safety problems).
Direct really looks good, assuming NASA hasn't yet destroyed enough of the existing Shuttle infrastructure. With one exception it uses actual Shuttle components (the one issue is what do you use for a man-rated restartable in space rocket engine, which is a problem you need to solve anyway, I think) and it's modular so that you don't need both Ares I and the heavy lift version of it, a massive and needless duplication of work (which is entirely appropriate when you notice that post-Apollo NASA is more a public works project than anything else).
I think you can blame NASA-the-agency: they (Griffin) wanted to do this themselves (the higher levels of design and management of the program) and they simply weren't willing to listen to bad news or draw the obvious conclusions from a program that was slipping a year every year is was in development.
That said, Jerry Pournelle does agree with you, in that we, the US, have lost enough rocket science ability that we can't at the moment build a 600,000 lb [ forget the term, but it's a 100% reusable, quick turnaround single stage to orbit and back vehicle concept that he and others have been pushing for years ]. We'd have to rebuild the talent and teams, starting with smaller projects.