4 ms·
Eh. Cost of 'doing business'. I saw the analogy last time when the same author posted their last "I'm shutting this down because of GDPR" post - chefs still hav
by madeofpalk 9y ago
Eh. Cost of 'doing business'. I saw the analogy last time when the same author posted their last "I'm shutting this down because of GDPR" post - chefs still have to follow food safety regulations, even if they just want to cook food.
You want to write code? Deploy it to localhost:8000.
You want to launch something online and collect user data? Be responsible with it.
reply
- cbeach 9y ago> You want to launch something online and collect user data? Be responsible with it. You imply I should "be responsible" in return for the value I'm getting from the user data? If so, you're wrong about the value part. I don't see any value in data from users - I see it as a dangerous liability and something I'd rather was not stored on my servers. I code in order to provide a service, which I do because it's satisfying to use my skill to build something I'm proud of, and something that helps other people out. I do not code to collect user data. And, by the way, I am responsible with user data - probably more so than many large organisations with the legal capacity to defend against GDPR claims.
- madeofpalk 9y agoI'll stop the implications and be explicit: the moment you consciously put a form out on the internet and invite users to enter there personal information, and you store it, you must be responsible for it. Not "in return" for anything - you collected the data, so it's your responsibility. In the same way that if a chef who, for the love of their art, opens a street food stall and sells food, they are responsible for the food they're handing out. They have to make sure that they're following safe and healthy food preparation guidelines.
- cbeach 9y agoPerhaps you could stop the implications that I'm being irresponsible with data, or that I plan to be. The GDPR is a flawed, ambiguous law that will not turn all website creators into responsible actors overnight. Instead, the GDPR will just create more fodder for vexatious claims - more opportunities for a minority of unscrupulous lawyers to monetise the pain of creators.
- madeofpalk 9y agoBut there's already 'ambiguous laws' (laws have to be ambiguous btw if they want to remain relevant) that you could be fined over! I don't really get the new problem with GDPR specifically. > Perhaps you could stop the implications that I'm being irresponsible with data, or that I plan to be. Look, I don't think that you're irresponsible with data. In the same way that food safety regulations don't imply that restaurants are being unhygienic. Honestly, my gut feeling here is that these were just some minor side projects that you were rather ambivalent about before anyway and you decided that GDPR was enough to 'pull the plug' on a bunch of side projects that were already on life support.
- notadoc 9y ago> Eh. Cost of 'doing business'. For fun, let's say I visited one of your personal projects websites, say something like a tax estimator, and it uses Google Analytics, maybe some web fonts, and let's say you're serving ads on that website so that you can make it support its own web hosting fee. It's also hosted on your own server. Therefore you are storing and processing my data, for someone else, and perhaps for your own internal usage as well to determine if your tax estimator project is worth pursuing or keeping online. Unfortunately when I visited your theoretical side project, you did not inform me that you are storing or processing my personal information! What are you doing with my personal information, like my IP address? I'd like to request a copy of my personal information from your side project. I'd also like to update my personal information as stored on your side project, so that it is kept accurate. I'd also like to request a copy of my personal data be delivered to a third party of my choosing. Have you appointed at data protector officer for this side-project yet? Have you appointed a representative within the EU yet? Can I get a copy of all the contracts you have in place with data processors you may be using? Finally, I'd like to request my personal data from your personal project website, and I'd like you to delete it from your servers and all services that were accessed via your website. Sound good? How's your side project going? Is this onerous yet? This is just a "cost of doing business" with your side project, right?
- madeofpalk 9y agoHeh. Unsure if you got this on a fluke or you know me/looked me up - do you mean my site https://austax.money https://austax.money? I don't have ads though. Look - to be honest, that's probably something I need to think about some time soon. A very realistic probability might be that I can't be bothered looking too much in depth and I'll just shut it down, but I won't be too upset about that. Only think is that I won't go spreading some diatribe around the internet about how EU regulation is killing me. I will acknowledge that it was my own laziness that lead to me shutting down the hobby tool I built a few years ago and no longer have a need for.
- notadoc 9y agoHypothetically, though it looks like you also have side projects that are relevant to the topic. I would assume nearly everyone on HackerNews has or had side projects that are using similar third party data processing, analytics, ads, and perhaps even their own linode hosting such projects, all gathering what GPDR determines is "personal data" like IP addresses, or maybe email addresses and names for signups and so forth. Now do you see why this is a hassle? But really, how do you plan on complying with GPDR for your side projects? > I will acknowledge that it was my own laziness that lead to me shutting down the hobby tool I built a few years ago and no longer have a need for. What if that hobby was ramen profitable? Same decision?
- cft 9y agoHow about obtaining a "programmer license" if you want your server to be publicly available on the internet? Would that be a good next step?