3 ms·
This. Prop. 13 created incentives to never move out, and thus killed dynamism in CA. Young people need homes near work. Older people need cheaper homes and c
by cryptonector 9y ago
This. Prop. 13 created incentives to never move out, and thus killed dynamism in CA. Young people need homes near work. Older people need cheaper homes and can be further from city centers.
Homesteading tax breaks are one thing, but applying them to all property is absolutely insane. This is easily the worst thing about it, and it has to go.
As to homesteading, even for homesteading the property taxes need to be able to go up with housing inflation somewhat at least.
It would be quite different if it was only the actual percentage tax rate that was limited in growth. I'd want that for income taxes too.
A brake on one kind of tax will spill into another kind. Thus, e.g., in TX property taxes function as an income tax via the Robin Hood school funding plan. It would be better to have a proper income tax, but no one will vote for such a thing without a hard constitutional brake on rates.
- chrisseaton 9y ago> Older people need cheaper homes Why do older people need cheaper homes? Older people have paid off their mortgages and have 100% equity.
- barsonme 9y agoProperty taxes and home repairs on fixed incomes.
- simonsarris 9y agoOlder people are on average on fixed incomes, sure. They're also on average the wealthiest age demographic in the US.
- barsonme 9y ago> They're also on average the wealthiest age demographic in the US. That's true, but it's a bit misleading IMO. Older folks might have accrued more wealth than younger demographics, but they're not really adding to it each year. For example, the 65-69 age range has a median net worth of ~$194k[0]. However, somebody in that age range is likely retired and will be living off of that $194k for the remainder of their life. Conversely, somebody under 35 might only have a net worth of $6.6k but will likely be bringing in ~$4,000 each month. Were an individual in the 65-69 age range to withdraw $4,000 per month, they'd be out of money in 4 years. Realistically, most might withdraw around $2,000 per month (before or after Social Security). That's where my parents are at. They really have much less to spend even though they have a lot saved up. If you take into consideration home equity, it's more apparent why property taxes and such are a big deal to older folks: upwards of 80% of their assets are in their house[1]. [0]: http://www.businessinsider.com/heres-the-average-net-worth-of-americans-at-every-age-2017-6 http://www.businessinsider.com/heres-the-average-net-worth-o... [1]: https://amp.businessinsider.com/images/593580d679474c17018b6a04-640-343.png https://amp.businessinsider.com/images/593580d679474c17018b6...
- cryptonector 9y agoGreat explanation. Retirement starts to get scary when your parents are thinking about it. You start asking them just how much they have saved, and you start thinking about how much more income you'll need if you end up having to supplement theirs.
- cryptonector 9y agoIf you retire at 72 today you might well live twenty more years. That's a lot of time to live of fixed income. You'll get sicker as you get older, so you know your healthcare costs will go up. That expensive house with high property taxes (if you don't have prop 13 to have made them close to zero for you over 40 or 50 years) starts looking like a burden, and also a source of funds.
- manfredo 9y agoEasy solution is to make it such that Prop 13 only applies to primary residences of people that are on social security.
- DrScump 9y agoI think the premise is that "older people" don't "need" as much space (interior or exterior) as they did when they presumably were raising children in the home. Then again, few people "need" SUVs.
- cryptonector 9y agoThey need less space. Having too much space is a cost of opportunity, since presumably a big house is more valuable than a small one. Selling one's big house and buying a smaller house, then investing the difference, may well be better than holding on to the house -- for society as a whole that's almost certainly true since now someone who needs more space can use that particular house's extra space. And at some point many elderly people start needing to tap their equity. Sure, you can use a reverse mortgage to do that, but downsizing works too, so some do that. In any case, "we're retiring and moving to the middle of nowhere, where land and homes are cheap" is a common thing I see. Property taxes are a big reason for this, because even with senior homesteading property tax breaks, it can be a big savings to live farther out, and that's a big deal when your retirement savings aren't as big as you might have hoped.
- cryptonector 9y agoI like how right now, my comment has 13 upvotes. EDIT: And this one has zero. As usual HN dislikes OT comments, humor, ...
- Karishma1234 9y agoCalifornia's old people are already paying 10% income tax which they can easily avoid by moving to Oregon. Lower property taxes is a result of higher taxes. Also property taxes are not there to decide who leaves and who stays. The only reason why we have property taxes is to pay for Police, Public schools and other bare minimum public services.