11 ms·
I agree. The biggest gift CA can give to the other 49 would be to stop driving their own residents out. CA housing policy has hurt many places outside CA, Den
by dsfyu404ed 9y ago
I agree. The biggest gift CA can give to the other 49 would be to stop driving their own residents out.
CA housing policy has hurt many places outside CA, Denver for example.
- davidw 9y agoAs someone who considers myself a YIMBY, I welcome people from elsewhere, but I hope that they move to my town because of its merits, not simply because "WOW, CHEAP!".
- sandy23 9y agoEveryone has a limited budget and you can't ask people not to consider the rental prices while choosing the locality.
- eropple 9y agoI don't intend to speak for 'davidw, but communities imply a social contract and people picking where to live based primarily on rental prices seem quite a bit less likely to build a rapport with that community. I'm not blaming them for it--late capitalism, yo--but it is a thing and it's not unreasonable for an established, community-concerned member to be like "hey, there's more to us than where your apartment is."
- jjeaff 9y ago>cash out and live like a king That's increasingly the problem in CA. Current residents have spent so much on housing that their only chance for a decent retirement is of their home values keep going up. They've paid so much that they haven't contributed nearly enough to their retirement accounts. You can hardly blame a NIMBY if nearly 100% of their net worth is tied up in their home value and falling home values will result in them having 0 retirement and no ability to sell their home and move because they are so far underwater.
- eropple 9y agoThat depends on the definition of the word "blame" that you're using. If it's a moral castigation? No, of course not; they are being ground down by the shitty circumstances that entrap most of us and of course it's hard to hold as a moral failing the maximization of what little they have (and while it is a lot to people below them, yeah, it's little in the grand scheme of things). But if it is an identification of a problem? I think it is fair. The amount of misery that NIMBYs can spread through forced inaction significantly outweighs the amount received in the case of action, I think.
- jjeaff 9y agoThe first one. "You can hardly blame them" pretty much always denotes moral castigation rather than the technical attribution of fault.
- pascalxus 9y agoCheap is an excellent attribute to have, we should all be so lucky, especially when it comes to something as fundamental as housing. In growing cities, it's a sign that market economies are working and that supply is allowed to increase, the way it should. Despite what some may think, expensive housing doesn't benefit anyone, not even those who own the housing. Not, unless you're willing to leave the area, then you can cash out and live like a king.
- davidw 9y agoThe dynamic I'm talking about is that, say, a house in Palo Alto costs 2.5 million dollars, whereas one in Bend might cost 500,000 - and be completely unaffordable to many people here. It'd be nice, in an ideal world, if the person moving from Palo Alto came because they like Bend for what it is, rather than 'oh gosh I can buy a house and live on the rest', if that makes sense?
- pchristensen 9y agoBut ... that's one of the things they like about it!
- jdavis703 9y agoOr Denver and others could build more housing. This increasingly isn't just a California problem, even New Orleans is facing supply constraints causing measures of relative affordability to go in the wrong direction [0] 0: http://www.nola.com/katrina/index.ssf/2015/08/new_orleans_explores_affordabl.html http://www.nola.com/katrina/index.ssf/2015/08/new_orleans_ex...
- davidw 9y agoYep! There's a reason YIMBY groups are popping up all over the place.
- rconti 9y agoIt continues to boggle my mind that people say things about domestic migration that they'd never say about foreign migration. Let's get this straight: migration happens many places, and for many reasons. The population of California is increasing, not decreasing. The population of the entire country is increasing. Urban areas are growing at the expense of rural areas (and, to a lesser extent, suburban areas). There is no such thing as California "driving their own residents out". People moving from CA to other places may have been born here, or they may have only lived here for a few years. It's not a zero sum game. Populations are increasing. Migration is happening, everywhere. I moved to California from the Northwest, where I was born and raised. Where folks who have lived there for 10 years whine about Californians "ruining the place", but have never thanked me for leaving. The majority of people I know moved to CA from out of state, but we don't blame Michigan or Ohio for our problems. We have a strong economy, and we're trying to accommodate people. Demand drives up costs if supply doesn't keep up. They were blaming California when I lived in the Northwest in the 80s. They're blaming it now. I was listening to an NPR show just last night, about alleviating housing concerns. One pertinent quote was that, when you buy a house, you are not entitled for the view out your window to never change ever, for the traffic to never change ever. This is the YIMBY movement -- to accommodate additional people. This is exactly the opposite of what people like yourself are doing. It's pretty ironic that, in an article about trying to solve housing problems by accommodating people, you're being petty and negative and playing the blame game. All of the same things that lead to these exact same problems. Say what you want about California, but we're not blaming outsiders for our problems, unlike other populated regions in the west.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- loeg 9y ago> There is no such thing as California "driving their own residents out". This just isn't true? It's pretty easy to quantify in terms of net inflows or outflows. And it turns out, California is a net people exporter[0]: > Last year, California had 142,932 more residents exit to live in other states than arrive, according to an analysis of a new report from the U.S. Census Bureau, released Wednesday, Nov. 15. This “domestic net outmigration” was the second-largest outflow in the nation behind New York and just ahead of Illinois and New Jersey. And it was up 11 percent (13,699 net departures) vs. 2015. > California’s net outmigration has been ongoing for two-decades-plus. [0]: https://www.ocregister.com/2017/11/16/census-142932-more-people-left-california-than-moved-here-in-2016/ https://www.ocregister.com/2017/11/16/census-142932-more-peo...
- geebee 9y agoSo... California should pursue YIMBY policies to incorporate population growth so that the other 49 can keep population grown to a minimum (ie., can say No to YIMBY policies)?
- Decade 9y agoWhen people leave California, because there is not enough housing, and move to Texas, which sprawls into floodplains, they double or triple their greenhouse gas emissions. Even with all the greenhouse gases from super-commutes, I prefer to have people stay in California.
- geebee 9y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_U.S._states_by_carbon_dioxide_emissions https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_U.S._states_by_carbon_... Texas has very high per capita carbon emissions, but Oregon and Washington, which is where a lot of the complaining comes from, are pretty comparable to California. Now, city dwellers do evidently have lower carbon emissions per capita. As you can see from the chart, New York state and Washington DC have very low carbon emissions per capita, driven by large urban populations. https://www.iied.org/cities-produce-surprisingly-low-carbon-emissions-capita https://www.iied.org/cities-produce-surprisingly-low-carbon-.... California does have a favorable climate that keeps energy use and emissions down. But so does much of the Northwest, and urbanization clearly has a lot to do with per capita emissions. In short, if you're concerned about carbon emissions, you should probably support density everywhere, not just in California.
- Decade 9y agoYes, but supporting density is not YIMBY exactly. In Houston, the main problem is not NIMBY, but unsustainable development patterns. StrongTowns is a more universal message. https://www.strongtowns.org/journal/2018/5/1/the-living-city-vs-the-mechanical-city https://www.strongtowns.org/journal/2018/5/1/the-living-city... Many more people leave California to go to Arizona and Texas than to Oregon and Washington. https://www.ocregister.com/2017/11/16/census-142932-more-people-left-california-than-moved-here-in-2016/ https://www.ocregister.com/2017/11/16/census-142932-more-peo... http://idiosyncraticwhisk.blogspot.com/p/what-is-closed-access-city.html http://idiosyncraticwhisk.blogspot.com/p/what-is-closed-acce...