9 ms·
The Helium Factor and Hard Drive Failure Rates
- b11484 9y agoIn the article it states that the helium can typically reduce drag by 20%. How much of an effect does that have on the cost of powering the drive? I assume it would at least be less than a 20% improvement overall.
- atYevP 9y agoYev from Backblaze here -> You'd have to look at the entire cabinet to get a better sense of the power savings. Post author Andy explains a bit more here -> http://disq.us/p/1s8psup http://disq.us/p/1s8psup.
- ThePhysicist 9y agoMaybe this is a stupid question, but why don't manufacturers evacuate the drives (i.e. create a vacuum) instead of filling them with Helium?
- jarvist 9y agoIt's much easier physically to build something which can hold e.g. +0.1 atmosphere helium, than resist imploding against -1.0 atmosphere. Practically speaking, pumping down to vacuum is a slow process, whereas you can flush with an inert gas. Finally, hard-drive heads actually float on lamina of gas; this is one of the reasons that normal open-circuit hard drives have a maximum operating altitude.
- rconti 9y agoWait, if it's +0.1 atm helium (for example), what happens if it develops a slight leak, a leak from which helium molecules can escape but air molecules cannot? once the pressure reaches equilibrium, there would be no reason for additional helium to escape, and because air can't enter.... then what?
- downrightmike 9y agoHe states that they see one drive that is between 94-99%, but that may be a sensor issue. You'd lose the power savings.
- fulafel 9y agoNit: those are not percentages indicating how much helium left, just some undocumented SMART attribute "raw values", there is no direct way to find out their meaning. (This is what the article text implies too). The raw attribute values could be for example 100 = good 99 = moderate 98 = degraded, or a log scale similar to decibels etc. Or it could be a bitfield that has no meaning as a decimal number. etc
- rleigh 9y agoThat isn't how it works though--look up partial pressures of gases. Helium will continue to escape until its partial pressure is at equilibrium with the external environment, i.e. near to zero, and the external gases will enter until they are at equilibrium with the internal environment. At that point the partial pressure of each gas will be equal on both sides.
- ak217 9y agoWhat happens to these helium hard drives if you repeatedly cycle the pressure, like by taking the hard drive on an airplane?
- rleigh 9y agoSince the partial pressure of helium at ground level and flight level is essentially the same (≈0) there should be very little change, providing the seals are intact. Since they are very securely sealed to contain the helium, changes to the external pressure, unless extreme, should not have any significant effect.
- the_cat_kittles 9y agowould that still be a problem if you pulled a vacuum outside the drive as well? like put the whole thing in a chamber?
- atYevP 9y agoThat is definitely a question that a manufacturer should answer :-/ No idea!
- duskwuff 9y agoThe head flying height is controlled by air flow (or helium flow, I suppose) under the head. With no atmosphere, there's no way to regulate that gap reliably.
- ScottBurson 9y agoDuskwuff has it right: the air or other gas is a critical component of the system. The spinning platters pull the gas along with them, and the head assembly is designed so that its aerodynamics control the "flying height" [0], the distance between the head and the platter. In a vacuum, there would be no easy way to keep the head from coming into contact with the platter, which is what causes head crashes. (In the era of sealed drives, head crashes are quite rare, but they used to be much more common. In a head crash, the head rips the magnetic coating off the platter, destroying it.) [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flying_height https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flying_height
- mrb 9y agoYou are exactly right. WD explains the same in https://blog.westerndigital.com/rise-helium-drives/ https://blog.westerndigital.com/rise-helium-drives/ : «Without air, the heads will crash into the disk»
- djsumdog 9y agoPretty interesting. I like how the author talks about how it may be too early to get useful data yet since their non-helium drives have been online for much longer. It'd be interesting to look at the numbers again in two years and see if the guess is correct.
- atYevP 9y agoYev from Backblaze here -> we're going to keep an eye on them and follow up on the stats so that we can eventually get there!
- tux3 9y agoIf the AFR numbers follow some bathtub-shaped curve, would it make sense to use that curve to "normalize" the failure rates according to drive days? I always wonder if the rates we see for each drives are really comparable, since they all have different ages, and whether that's representative of the average lifetime AFR. That might be an interesting column to add to the reports!
- atYevP 9y agoThis might be interesting -> https://hackernoon.com/applying-medical-statistics-to-the-backblaze-hard-drive-stats-36227cfd5372 https://hackernoon.com/applying-medical-statistics-to-the-ba... it's more "time based" - a medical statistical model applied to our drive stats!
- jarvist 9y agoYou'd certainly expect the long-term failure for Helium filled to be lower. By displacing (moist) air, you've completely stopped any metal corrosion. Helium is also highly conductive to heat, so you will even out any hot spots. Does anyone know to what sort of pressure helium the drives are filled?
- Someone 9y agoMy thought when first hearing about them was that, having an extra point of failure (Helium leakage), they would have higher long-term failure rates.
- thatcat 9y agoIf that leakage only brings the probability of failure back to previous rates, then you've still lowered the failure rate overall.
- teilo 9y agoNo, that's not what would happen. Helium drives enable higher data density, because helium decreases the amount of drag, which in turn reduces turbulence, platter vibration, and heat. This enables more more platters per drive and more accurate head positioning. Helium leakage would make the drive substantially less reliable than air drives due to the higher data density.
- derefr 9y agoBut they're not comparing denser helium-filled drives to less-dense air-filled drives. They're comparing 12TB helium drives to 12TB air drives—equal density. (I have no idea how they're managing to make non-helium drives of that density, but apparently they can.) Of course, for a drive density that can only be achieved using helium, a helium leak will kill the drive. But right now, it seems that these drives might not actually need the helium, since equivalent drives exist without it.
- tlb 9y agoI might have expected the first-order effect to be that helium drives run cooler, and therefore last longer. Most failure mode rates have an eᵏᵀ term, doubling every 10-15 °C. But Google's large study didn't show much of that at reasonable temperatures (below 45 °C): https://static.googleusercontent.com/media/research.google.com/en//archive/disk_failures.pdf https://static.googleusercontent.com/media/research.google.c...
- ChuckMcM 9y agoI absolutely expect helium drives to run cooler simply because helium is a much better conductor of heat compared to air. As a result all heat generated in the drive cavity will be more effectively conducted to the containment vessel and leave the material inside consistently cooler.
- jacquesm 9y agoThat's a two way street though. If the ambient is higher it will carry the heat from the outside into places in the drive where it can do real damage.
- tlb 9y agoThe drive produces heat, so it will always be hotter than ambient (proportional to the heat generated times the thermal resistance).
- jacquesm 9y agoNot necessarily, the drive produces heat but something around it (other drives, cpu's) may be producing a lot more heat than the drive raising the temperature of the drive casing beyond where it would be if it were just the drive in isolation. Case design for lots of drives + a beefy CPU is very tricky if you want to really balance the airflow so that there are no large local variations in temperature.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoFor an excessively hot exterior sure, but I was thinking back to an experience at NetApp when thermal inside was the issue. When NetApp first started using SATA drives (rather than Fiber Channel) in their Nearstore appliance we discovered that the SATA drives were negatively effected by writing too much. Specifically, if write duty cycle was too high, the r/w head got too hot, and the heat caused it to change shape slightly and that shape change caused it to fly higher. Leading to something that was dubbed 'high fly writes' which splattered into adjacent tracks and could corrupt data. One fix was to keep track of the write duty cycle and to let the drive 'rest' for a bit to keep the overall duty cycle into something the drive could handle. I don't think that sort of failure can happen on a helium drive.
- outworlder 9y agoGiven the amount of engineering required for drives which are able to contain helium, one would expect that the required tolerances and materials would be much better. There may be reliability advantages for Helium, but I suspect greater care and QA during manufacturing will account for most of the improvement. Also, it would be very bad PR for a new type of drive if they performed significantly worse.
- lowestprimate 9y agoHelium also has higher viscosity than air and because of that the flying head in the drive is more stable than in air.
- 11chris11 9y agohave there been any drives designed with an array of fixed read / write heads i.e. one per track or a head that can access multiple tracks on a platter simultaniously?
- krallja 9y agoThere have been a few. Here’s an older article https://www.tomshardware.com/news/seagate-hdd-harddrive,8279.html https://www.tomshardware.com/news/seagate-hdd-harddrive,8279...
- the_cat_kittles 9y agoever tried pulling a vacuum on a normal drive? does that work?
- blackflame7000 9y agoAir is required for the heads to function. While the disk's internal environment is separate from the outside air to keep it clean, air exchange is permitted between the outside and inside of the drive to allow the drive to adjust to changes in air pressure caused by thermal expansion. A special "breather" filter is installed to prevent foreign matter from contaminating the drive.
- deelowe 9y agoThe arm of the drive is a tuned mass damper attached to a voice coil that utilizes ground effect to maintain the a precise distance between the head and the platter. Spinning disks wouldn't work in a vacuum using current technology, because there'd be no ground effect to lift the arm off the platter.
- tim333 9y agoI did some everesting and our organiser had tired regular laptops and they always packed up through disk crashes. I guess that would be at about 16 to 20,000 feet, or about half sea level pressure. That was in pre SSD days.
- mrtnmcc 9y agoIf you model drive failure as a Poisson Process (each drive flips a coin each day with probability of failure x), then the measurements imply air and helium drives both have about x=2.8e-5. But drive failure rate may not be constant over time, especially if the failure is wear/aging related. The author should consider fitting the data to a https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Weibull_distribution https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Weibull_distribution with k>1. In particular, k=2 is a model where failure rate increases linearly over time. To estimate the instrinsic drive failure rate for this model, we must look at the raw failure times (not enough info in blog's totals table) and compute the root-mean-square of time between failures. Then divide this by the total number of drives. Do this for the two classes (air vs helium) and see which is better.
- titzer 9y ago> If you model drive failure as a Poisson Process (each drive flips a coin each day with probability of failure x) IIRC the Poisson distribution applies when the rate is roughly constant per interval of time, which is not exactly the same as a probability of x per interval of time. (Failures are independent in the latter, not in the former).
- mrtnmcc 9y agoPlease see Poisson Process, which is different than Poisson distribution, http://www.randomservices.org/random/poisson/index.html http://www.randomservices.org/random/poisson/index.html .. failures are indeed independent.
- jammi 9y agoJust like in combustion engines, it seems like the best things are held to the last generations of hardware. I expect both to lose market share down to nil during the 2020s. BEVs replacing internal combustion engines and solid state storage replacing HDDs even in cost per storage unit.
- ableal 9y ago"Perfection is attained on the point of collapse" (I thought I had read that somewhere, but the closest I find now is C.N. Parkinson's formulation, which I did read years ago ...)