3 ms·
Performance is key. How many TLS handshakes can you complete per-second with a token/smartcard/TPM? The numbers for TPMs are abysmal (TPMs only need to perfor
by cryptonector 9y ago
Performance is key. How many TLS handshakes can you complete per-second with a token/smartcard/TPM? The numbers for TPMs are abysmal (TPMs only need to perform well enough that their work is not noticed by the user when booting). I suspect the numbers for smartcards are also abysmal, and for similar reasons.
- closeparen 9y agoThat’s why there’s a market for $10k+ rackmount versions of these devices (enterprise HSMs).
- kakwa_ 9y agoDon't expect them to be much faster than a regular Xeon CPU however. The main selling aspect is to avoid your private keys from being leaked to the world. For that there is all sort of tamper proofing on usually what is a PCIe card. They can also be sold as appliances. Also, they tend to be a bit crappy. I had a really bad experience with Safenet Luna SE at my last job. The thing was buggy as hell, performance tended to be random between devices and on the security side, it was a CentOS 6.0 (with no updates) and a custom kernel driver + some userland tools which strangely enough, creates devices under /dev that were world writable... The Luna SA seemed better, but their rackmount appliances where nothing to be proud of: cheap 1U chassis, with regular desktop parts (micro ATX motherboard, a cheap celeron, non ECC RAM). The one we opened with quite old however (Luna SA 4 IIRC). The Thales ones seemed better at least in term of finish. The base appliance seemed to be of overall far better quality (sturdier case). But I didn't play with it, so no opinions on overall performance and ease of use.
- equalunique 9y agoI have it on reliable intel that Thales has been employed successfully for heavy applications in datacenters used by CVS and the US Gov. Their products must be good.
- dozzie 9y agoMy smartcard can do about one, maybe two SSH authentications per second. I don't think it would be much faster with TLS, even with caching the sessions.
- cryptonector 9y agoWell, if you leave the session ticket decryption key off the token, resumption won't be slow. But 2/s is beyond abysmal for new sessions.