4 ms·
Hi, I’m a project manager. I’m the guy who is likely scheduling most of those meetings. Nice to meet you! I think, by and large, we understand the cost of meet
by ryandrake 9y ago
Hi, I’m a project manager. I’m the guy who is likely scheduling most of those meetings. Nice to meet you!
I think, by and large, we understand the cost of meetings, and don’t casually organize them without going through the alternatives. It’s not rocket science. My thought process is generally:
0. Before anything, come up with a written agenda and goals for the communication. Don’t move past this step until done.
1. Does this communication even need to happen? Maybe there is an internal document already I can point people to.
2. If not, Can this be done async over E-mail?
3. If not, can it be done over chat?
4. If not, can it be done in a series of 1:1s between me and each attendee?
5. If not, then a meeting has to happen. What’s the true minimal list of required attendees? Who is optional? I am loathe to waste the time of a productive individual contributor if I don’t have to. If I can invite his/her manager instead, I will. Sorry, that’s the Faustian bargain you make when becoming a manager!
6. What’s the shortest possible productive duration?
7. Is there a time slot that is miraculously free for everyone, respecting time zones and working hours for people?
8. If not, is there a time slot that works for most people?
If, again by some great miracle, there are multiple time slots that work, I favor ones that are adjacent to other meetings in their calendars, so as to not break up a productive no-meeting block.
- pwg 9y agoGood job there with your checklist. Unfortunately, for every one of you who does the above checklist before pulling the "schedule meeting" trigger, there are 500 other project managers who's first reaction to everything is: "schedule a meeting".
- noir_lord 9y agoThen there is the "I can get what I need in a 2hr meeting at the cost of 16hrs of other peoples time" ones. I hate those ones. If your programmers are taking laptops to meetings to write code while you are holding the meeting, you should consider a career in yak-farming not project management. Also we need to schedule a meeting to find out why we are behind on our deliverables because of last weeks meeting taking most of the day putting everyone behind. That one made me giggle. Or as one of my friends at that place had as a wallpaper "The beatings will continue until morale improves".
- ryandrake 9y agoThere are lots of terrible meeting formats. There’s the “everyone talk about what they are not doing because they’re meeting to talk about it” aka Daily Standup. There’s the Bug Beatings, where 50 people gather to go through 200 open bugs, each one where 1 (different) person talks and the remaining 49 work on their laptops. There’s my least favorite: I call it “Executive Storytime” where multiple people put together a status update for a big-shot, and instead of big-shot reading it himself, we project it and read it to him. This is ok when the format is meant to be interactive but if it’s just a readout—yukk. Then there’s the Agendaless Sync, where the same people get together weekly because they always get together weekly and just talk about whatever. Ugggghh.
- noir_lord 9y agoThese days I'm the only programmer at a none-tech company and it's glorious, I answer directly to the MD. I set my own schedules, timelines, I prioritise bugs and maintenance and I handle buying anything we need as well having complete freedom in the technologies I choose to solve problems (currently moving to TypeScript for front end stuff for example) - his attitude is to hire good people across the business and then get out the way as much as possible. The boss sets overall goals and we agree together on what is achievable in a given time period. Honestly my job has made me remember what it was I loved about programming (solving real world problems that have a measurable impact). Even the fact I inherited the worst codebase I've ever seen doesn't get me down because my boss knows how bad it is (it's why he got rid of the outsourced company and hired a programmer in house) and I get to work on a bunch of cool problems (production scheduling in a varied environment, global logistics (we import from China and India), some C# stuff (production control), Android (inventory control, scanners)). I actually get to 5pm and want to keep working but the boss bollocks me if I stay late (even though he does most days). I'd have to be offered a spectacular pay rise to even consider working for a 'tech' company again.
- pwg 9y agoAnd the always wonderful - meeting that should have been an email. https://imgur.com/gallery/9yF0Vyo https://imgur.com/gallery/9yF0Vyo
- wolco 9y agoYou sound like a great pm any thoughts to transferring your system into a package for other pm's?
- lukethomas 9y agoThese would be great questions to answer when creating an event invite. Would make a pretty useful chrome extension.
- simsla 9y agoSounds like a good thought process, but that's not how I feel it happens in my department. The thought process there is more like "hey, this sounds like it's relevant for 'the team'. Let me check the calendar for the first open slot!"
- cbhl 9y agoThis is a great checklist! Do you have it posted in "blog post" format somewhere for posterity?
- commandlinefan 9y ago> and don’t casually organize them without going through the alternatives I'm routinely asked to join after-hours deployment calls that last hours and which my contribution is minimal, "just in case". You may not be casually organizing them, but there are plenty out there who are.
- orev 9y agoMaybe it’s old but you need to read manager vs maker schedule: http://paulgraham.com/makersschedule.html http://paulgraham.com/makersschedule.html It is the gold standard on why creative workers hate meetings. All those things you mentioned sound great, but you’re still destroying productivity if you’re scheduling meetings anywhere other than the immediate beginning or end of the day. For makers, there are only 2 time slots: before lunch and after lunch.