5 ms·
What created math? I don't see how the essentially magical appearance of an incredibly complex set of axioms from nothing at all is a plausible answer to the '
by TheOtherHobbes 9y ago
What created math?
I don't see how the essentially magical appearance of an incredibly complex set of axioms from nothing at all is a plausible answer to the 'Why something instead of nothing?" question.
To be clear, I have absolutely no idea how to answer that question. I'm certainly not a closet theist. My best guess is that a useful answer is currently some way beyond our pay grade as a species.
So I don't find "Because math" to be any more convincing as an answer than suggesting god did it.
- kazinator 9y agoIt's not so "magical" if all conceivable sets of axioms are understood to exist. > any more convincing as an answer than suggesting god did it. Doesn't have the problem of 1) asserting that no other gods exist other than this specific god or group of gods and 2) the issue of who created god. We don't ask, who put pi about 14% of the way between 3 and 4; that's almost silly. :)
- mitchty 9y ago> What created math? You presume it was created. It might be as valid a question as "who created erosion", aka math is a natural extension of our universe.
- krapp 9y ago>aka math is a natural extension of our universe Or, more likely IMO, our universe is a natural extension of math.
- deciplex 9y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mathematical_universe_hypothesis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mathematical_universe_hypothes... I get it, but I can't quite wrap my head around a mathematical universe with no substrate. As though any internally consistent ontology with self-aware structures (and, it seems to me, also those without) just "exists" apropos of nothing. What's doing the math?
- kazinator 9y agoOnce you postulate a substrate, you then have to wrap your head around what is its substrate, and what is that substrate's substrate and so on. When you look at it that way, the no-substrate version looks better.
- tim333 9y agoWho invented all the digits of pi? They just are what they are without needing a substrate. It seems real because you are part of it like being in VR.
- deciplex 9y agoI said "what" is doing the math, not "who".
- whytaka 9y agoIt's an oft-repeated argument but I lean heavily towards Math, as notation and application, as something discovered not invented, while Math as that which is seemingly present in everything that ever happens, as the fundamental basis of our reality. It would make sense to me that reality, encapsulating all that exists, "is" because "it must be", like Math.
- discreteevent 9y agoI'm from the opposite side of the house: Reality is primary. Math is one of the tools we use to work with it.
- kazinator 9y agoAll of the rigorous descriptions of reality consist of math; the deeper we delve into it, the more math there is. So far, no non-math stuff been found. There is nothing to contradict a suspicion that it's just math all the way to the bottom (if there is a bottom) or else just math all the way.
- tim333 9y agoNo one created the math. Things like pi = 3.141... just are that way because they have to be that.