5 ms·
During my career, other individual engineers interrupting me while I’m working has had a far greater impact on my time than scheduled meetings. What I’ve been d
by dahart 9y ago
During my career, other individual engineers interrupting me while I’m working has had a far greater impact on my time than scheduled meetings. What I’ve been dreaming of is an app for interrupting someone that delays requests and batches them up. No walking up to someone at any time and saying “just a quick question”, plan and expect to wait a few minutes.
- bachmeier 9y agoEmail?
- andonisus 9y agoNo, it's 2018, we need some new app to disrupt the tried-and-true method of message delivery.
- tonyarkles 9y ago> "I hate email. Sometimes I won't get an answer for a few hours, or sometimes until the next day" -- Coworker It's definitely a culture thing. I've worked with teams across the spectrum, and, personally, I definitely lean far towards async communication being the best most of the time. There's times when you can't beat a whiteboard session, but those are the exception for me.
- ryandrake 9y agoE-mail should be this tool but yes, it’s use is way too company culture dependent. Some places/people treat reading/answering email as optional. Some batch it up and “do Email” 1 day a week or so. I wish there were a better work communication tool with the response expectation of chat plus the asynchronousity of Email.
- 3pt14159 9y agoIf someone at my company routinely doesn't answer internal emails then they should be fired.
- aswanson 9y agoWhat if they're too busy doing work?
- 3pt14159 9y agoIf they're routinely dropping emails then they haven't communicated up and down that they're overloaded or they're in a shitty work environment. Either way, I've been on the other side of dropped emails and it's like sand in a motor. It's precisely why most large organizations have issues being agile.
- megaman22 9y agoWhat's routine mean? I've had people that go all Peter Potomus and start beating down the office door if you don't reply to their insane, rambling emails inside of five minutes, screeching "Did you get that THING I sent YA!" Email is a medium that should require a little bit of thought and deliberation, and if you're doing it, you can't do much else. Incoming-email-driven development is one of the more frustrating and wasteful processes I've suffered through. Ping ping ping, bouncing all around, not concentrating. It's also worth trying to cultivate some self-reliance in your coworkers, so they learn how to find information and solve problems on their own, without needing their hand held every step. It's sometimes overwhelmingly difficult not to send back a lmgtfy link to some questions.
- mstade 9y agoMost people I've ever worked with treat email as an immediate conversation. If you don't respond within 20 minutes (and typically within 5) they'll send another, try me over chat, or even call and immediately go "did you see my email?" I sometimes takes days to respond, unless something is truly urgent – which of course it almost never is. For whatever reason this pisses some people off, but they also learn that the best way to get an immediate answer out of me is to call (I work 100% remote.)
- wolco 9y agoI answer my emails immediately it stops the calls. I prefer this.
- dahart 9y agoNo. Email is not a scheduler, and it has never stopped someone from interrupting me. If email solved this, there wouldn't be a problem. I want something that forces people to try to answer their own questions for a few minutes, or at least expect to wait, before asking. When there's a small cost to asking the question, a high percentage of the time, the request will vanish on it's own. The asker will answer their own question or realize the question wasn't what they really wanted to ask. Part of the point of what I'm suggesting is to allow people to cancel their request. With my app suggestion, I'm hoping/expecting like half the interruptions (random made-up number) to just go away. Email doesn't do that, in fact it gets worse with email, you waste time reading the question and again reading the answer, or worse, answering the question only to find out the "nevermind" email was buried further down.
- zip1234 9y agoI think there is a problem with too many meetings though. I used to have morning and afternoon meetings every day. Certainly made my schedule full but also meant I got less done.
- tobyhinloopen 9y agoI just use Slack. I disabled notifications and around every block of productivity (20-90 minutes) I check my mail, slack, and random websites.
- kuwze 9y agoYou might be interested in Hey[0]. I haven't used it yet, keep meaning to. [0]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15795468 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15795468
- dchuk 9y agoI've actually been thinking about hacking something together for this! I can't stand slack interruptions all day, would love all requests to work with me queued up for certain designated response windows that I control so I can have longer blocks of uninterrupted time.
- sixstringtheory 9y agoDoesn’t email already solve this problem?
- frockington 9y agoNot when you can get funded to make an app that implements AI and ML to create a sorted message queue that increase business resiliency in agile environments. In all seriousness I'm looking forward for the announcement from a startup that boils down to "We made email again"
- dahart 9y agoNot at all. If people actually chose email over walking over to interrupt me, there wouldn't even be a problem. Email doesn't help me queue up or schedule micro-meetings with people. Email doesn't do anything to work around scheduled meetings. Email is a black hole from the sender's point of view, they don't get any feedback other than a reply, and they don't know when to expect a reply. People who want immediate help will send email and then walk over and interrupt after a few minutes anyway. Email is a communication channel. I'm not looking for a communication channel, I'm looking for a scheduler & queue for micro-meetings. Email could work, of course, if the company sets up rules & expectation. If people knew they were required to send email before interrupting someone, and if people could count on a reply within an hour for anything, then email might be adequate, but as it stands, we already have email and we still have an interruption problem, so it's clearly not solving the problem.
- sixstringtheory 9y agoI should've chosen my words more carefully for such a tacit response... in this case, I'd revise it to "couldn't email solve this problem?" I see where you're coming from though w.r.t. communication vs. scheduling. I found this on a quick search, which has a free tier that I might try: https://calendly.com https://calendly.com. Still, my worries are that: 1. it's not like email/calendaring/slack will go away, so now I have yet another tool to maintain (at least Calendly have calendar integrations) 2. like email, it could be abused, just in new ways I don't know about yet... what problems will arise that drive us towards more new tools to solve them? I'm not sure the marginal improvement over using email/slack/calendars, plus some sort of rules/expectations, would be worth adopting another tool, but I am curious to see how it works out.
- philbarr 9y agoIn a sprint review recently I brought up the issue of, "Hi Phil." This is where someone IMs you with just "Hi Phil" and then you have to sit there and look at the "X is typing", "X is not typing" for 5 minutes. I don't mind people asking a question, but just put it all on one line, "Hi Phil. This is the question..." That way I can sometimes just fire back a quick answer and it's not as distracting. It makes sense too - you wouldn't walk up to someone, tap them on the shoulder and then make them wait before asking a question.
- drewmate 9y agoI'm with you on this one, but I've recently decided that "Hi Phil" boils down to some fundamental personality split rather than a misunderstanding; I don't think either side will soon change. I believe "Hi Phil" people are really just trying to be polite and minimize interruptions (or at least their magnitude), waiting for permission to really bother you, so to speak. Whether that's true or not, I respond if I'm ready, or I ignore it and go on with my work if I'm in the middle of something, just like I would with a full question. The only difference is I'm not thinking about the question with my spare cycles in the mean time. If someone is trying to inform me of something urgent with "Hi Drew" I think it's reasonable to say that's their own fault.
- bluGill 9y agoNo, the real reason for the "Hi Phil" and then a pause is much worse. You might sometime in the future have to contact Phil about some detail on the plan to fire "Joe". By sending "Hi Phil" and a pause you give Phil enough time to respond "I'm busy" before you give away to Joe that he is going to be out the door in a couple days after legal finishes the paperwork. Because "Hi Phil" and then a 5 minute pause is standard when this situation happens Joe doesn't think anything of it and so Phil can secretly transfer that least important bit of knowledge without giving anything away.
- 3pt14159 9y agoI still don't understand why people use Slack for work for non-emergencies. For talking about bullshit (cool places to eat near the office) or for emergencies (@zach @sarah prod is down!) it's good, but for product planning it's terrible. Hard to keep up with, hard to reference later, encourages temporary / lazy fixes like quick questions over maintained wikis.
- squeaky-clean 9y agoMy pet peeve is when someone does the "Hi, I have a question/problem" message without actually sending the question. It's hard to get that out of your head after seeing it. And they always seem to send the question and immediately go to lunch or a long meeting. I explained to some people that it doesn't work well with my anxiety to see "Hey I think I found a bug in X" and then just get no further details for two hours. One person has actually listened and writes me up an email or whole long message now. Everyone else responded by saying it seemed too rude and inconsiderate to not ask about your day first so they continue to do that... You can still start your message with "How was your weekend?" but just type the rest of the message too without waiting for a response...
- gfunk911 9y agoYes yes yes. People are trying to be polite by not starting a conversation with a demand, but it has the opposite effect.
- daveFNbuck 9y agoIt sounds like you want to hold office hours. You don't need an app for that, you just need to respond to requests by telling people when your office hours are.
- dahart 9y agoI actually tried office hours. I hung a sign on my chair during non office hours. It totally didn't work. People would shake my chair or wave at me even when I had headphones on and the go-away sign, and say "just a quick question", as if that made the interruption during non office hours okay. Some people thought I was being a jerk too. This isn't something people can or should have to do on their own. For it to work, it needs to be a company wide expectation on a company wide schedule that immediate interruptions are off limits during certain times. I also generally agree with "you don't need an app for that" for pretty much everything... except that this app would need to integrate and work around online calendars. And I want it to queue people so I can answer them in order. And I don't necessarily want to have a specific time for interruptions, I really want people to try to answer their own question for 5-10 minutes before interrupting me. I'm happy to answer questions, but I get a lot of questions that people can easily answer on their own with 30 seconds of effort.
- daveFNbuck 9y agoI'm guessing you work in an open plan office like I do. It's hard to have a company-wide expectation that immediate interruptions are off-limits when that's how you sell the seating arrangement as a positive.
- dahart 9y agoYeah, absolutely. That's exactly right, the open floor plan is unfortunately intended to encourage interruption (aside from the obvious advantage of just being cheap.) The last open floor plan I worked in established that the meeting rooms were allowed to be used for engineer quiet time, and that someone in the meeting room was not to be interrupted. It was great for the first couple of months in the building, but eventually the meeting rooms were crowded with meetings and there just weren't enough for engineers to use for focus time very often. Headphones became the only means of staying sane. When I tried office hours, I was actually in shared offices. 4-6 people to a room. It was a game company, and I was supporting artists. The artists were the worst about not respecting office hours, most of the programmers left me alone because they also wanted to be left alone to concentrate. Ultimately I decided I was setting a bad example by trying to establish office hours for myself. The company wasn't that great at planning, and the interruptions I was getting were a symptom of not enough training and formal communication. What was needed was a little more communication, not less. (*But the right kind, of course.)
- vthallam 9y agoJust took a simple search "queue messages on slack" to find one - https://sv-qbot.herokuapp.com/ https://sv-qbot.herokuapp.com/ The description looks close to what you were expecting.