3 ms·
It's not clear to me that it's a bad comparison for several reasons. (a) I don't think it's typical to make direct contact with a cell phone for an hour at a t
by perl4ever 9y ago
It's not clear to me that it's a bad comparison for several reasons.
(a) I don't think it's typical to make direct contact with a cell phone for an hour at a time. Most calls I make are short and I don't actually hold it touching my ear. That does depend on the noise level though.
(b) Microwaves are much higher power.
(c) Microwaves may be constructed to looser tolerances regarding shielding.
Yes, microwaves are different, but the differences don't uniformly cut in one direction, so I think it's a little too glib to dismiss the hazard out of hand.
Edit: One could argue that in fact your ear holds your phone away from your head, providing an offset analogous to the distance one is observing a microwave from. But this is really a rhetorical answer to a rhetorical objection, when my point is more that only quantitative analysis could illuminate the accuracy of the comparison.
The prompting for my original post is that I was microwaving water to boiling and watching to make sure it didn't superheat - unlike on the stove, it can form a big bubble of steam suddenly. It seems to me that I do this nearly as often as I make a phone call (as opposed to texting and email).
- emodendroket 9y ago> I don't think it's typical to make direct contact with a cell phone for an hour at a time. Do you have any family who live more than 30 minutes away?
- perl4ever 9y agoThat's not how I meant it. I don't think it's typical of phone calls; it is certainly common among people who make phone calls. Also, both qualifications in that sentence are important - not only "an hour at a time", but "direct contact". I have been on long calls at work with a landline/VOIP phone and found my ear hurts after a while with the earpiece resting against my ear. So I know that when my ear does not hurt it is because I have not been holding the phone against it for a long time.
- emodendroket 9y agoI'd say long conversations are a pretty common thing for me if I'm actually bothering to make a phone call.
- icebraining 9y agoMicrowaves may be constructed to looser tolerances regarding shielding. How? A cellphone literally can't shield its radiation, otherwise it wouldn't really work.
- perl4ever 9y agoI'm not sure how this addresses the above statement. A cellphone must emit radiation to work, but surely it also manages EMI.
- kalleboo 9y agoCellphones are designed to shield your head from radiation, and instead direct transmissions outwards away from it. There are legal limits on the radiation absorbed by a human head while talking on the phone https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Specific_absorption_rate#Mobile_phone_SAR_testing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Specific_absorption_rate#Mobil... So basically yes, phones do have shielding (on the head side only)