4 ms·
TLDR: Overhaul H1b L1 visas. Replace work restrictions with 6yr temp Green Cards equivalent EAD (work authorization). Here's how I think the offshoring model w
by calvinbhai 8y ago
TLDR: Overhaul H1b L1 visas. Replace work restrictions with 6yr temp Green Cards equivalent EAD (work authorization).
Here's how I think the offshoring model works with many of these companies:
1) US company wants to get rid of its aging workforce (benefits costs will be too high, due to rising insurnace costs)
2) US (IBM, Accenture, HP etc) and Indian (Infosys, TCS etc) outsourcing companies bid on a project, get trained as replacements, jobs get offshored.
3) Quality complaints and rising costs of offshoring/outsourcing makes the company end the contract, and start hiring younger employees.
4) Profit! Firing / Laying off older employees in the US companies is not easy. But taking this route, the employer gets to wash hands off from the rising costs issue.
This problem with tech workers paid low is because:
- Healthcare and Insurance is broken in the US (it works for those who are healthy and are in a company with younger workforce)
- H1b is basically a high tech indentured labor visa: If an employer is willing, the employee on H1b can be treated as such (no job mobility, no hikes, no option to even raise a voice against something going wrong). Fortunately, those on H1b visa as employees of actual companies (not outsourcing firms), they are treated much better, and it doesn't feel like indentured labor.
Solution?
Turn H1b, L1 and F1 OPT into time limited Green Card equivalents EADs:
- An international student graduating with a degree gets a 3 yr green card equivalent work authorization
- Once the student green card expires, give them a 6 yr green card (instead of an h1b). At the end of 6 yrs, if the employee has not been sponsored for an employment based permanent green card, he/she has to leave.
- No limits on the number of these green cards available.
- No H1b or L1 visa work restrictions. H1 and L1 dependents can work with a similar EAD.
How will this work?
- Giving true job mobility and freedom to switch jobs at any time, without giving the employer any hold in the immigration process, helps bump up the wages for the employees (US citizens or those on 3yr temp green card).
- Employee has no fear of job loss / retribution from employer.
- Employer has to pay at market or above market salaries. Or else employee will jump ship.
- This will automatically regulate the number of jobs that get outsourced to teams/companies that genuinely address the problem if inefficiencies, and immediately create a penalty for those companies that are body shops running on indentured labor.
- Having H1 and L1 dependents be able to work (with the new green card equivalent EAD), enables the primary visa holder to risk it and start a new venture.
About me: I came to the US on F1, worked on OPT, got H1. now sick of the US immigration system, I'm moving to Canada soon! :D