7 ms·
Hominin head-scratcher: who butchered this rhino 700k years ago?
- CoolGuySteve 9y agoI'm just some guy, but why would hominins settle so high in what are now the Philippines when a lower altitude would have given better access to water and game. Is it possible there are settlements, they're just under the ocean now, on what used to be large flat land bridges?
- rjsw 9y ago> Is it possible there are settlements, they're just under the ocean now, on what used to be large flat land bridges? Quite possible, evidence of settlements at lower levels have been found elsewhere [1]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doggerland https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doggerland
- piptastic 9y agoI don’t know, I have the same question for Floridians every summer.. Why don’t they just move! But seriously I think that’s why it’s called settling. Ok I’m tired of moving I’m going to stop here and build a life and that’s it. And then they actively ignore any evidence it’s a bad decision. I’m guessing people of yore were similar.
- xutopia 9y agoWith greater heights you have less problems with insects. It could very well be that there were humans everywhere but those who lived there did better.
- mabbo 9y agoThis is actually a really big problem for studying humans migration across the Bering Sea- most of the lane that was coastal at the time is now deeply under water. Beringia[0] was a huge land mass, possibly full of people and it existed for thousands of years. What we consider the coast now was much higher ground, probably less suitable for habitation, in part because the world was colder (ice age)- and thus, no signs of human habitation in those parts. All the answers, if any remain, are deeply under water. [0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beringia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beringia
- patrickg_zill 9y agoThere's a small carved figurine of a horse, dated to 32000 years ago, and we know nothing about that society either. It is fascinating and it is fun to speculate about...
- dogma1138 9y agoWasn’t that a lion? https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lion-man# https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lion-man# Or is it a different one?
- patrickg_zill 9y agoI didn't know about that one, so thanks! I was thinking of the horse figurine found in the Vogelherd cave: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vogelherd_Cave https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vogelherd_Cave
- dogma1138 9y agoI think what's more impressive is that if the dating is correct those artifacts span 10,000 years. This means that that ISS is closer to the great pyramids those are to each other.
- stevenwoo 9y agoWhat's really interesting to me is they had a second expedition after the first wholly within the sediment that the first archaelogical excavation put aside as waste.
- choxi 9y agoWhat's a good place to start if you were curious to read more about it? Especially the fun speculation parts
- EGreg 9y agoMaybe the dating is wrong??
- chx 9y agoMy gut instinct says they misdated the bones.
- robotmay 9y agoMy partner is an archaeologist and this is an entertainingly common occurrence with older digs. She reassessed a few as part of some old work in the past few years and found that some bones were from lunch on the dig-site :|
- ASalazarMX 9y agoHow can that be? Are buried ancient bones indistinguishable from buried recent bones?
- sten 9y agoCould be sea food. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radiocarbon_dating#Reservoir_effects https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radiocarbon_dating#Reservoir_e...
- Insanity 9y agoCould be I suppose - though before announcing something like this you'd think they'd check more frequently. In addition, I'm assuming the dating has a margin of error which was not stated in the article, so I'm curious what this margin is. (But even so, I doubt it's a large enough margin to get close to the 600k that was stated, which is already 'far out there')
- jvozza 9y agoThe article links to a description, i did some hunting but was unable to find any hard number for a margin of error. Electronic spin resonance: ESR, which measures trapped electrons using magnetic fields, is related to magnetic resonance imaging, the medical technique that allows doctors to look for tumors or peek inside your creaking knee. Because ESR essentially tracks the activity — the “spin” — of the electrons without freeing them, the sample can be subjected to repeated dating attempts. ESR also has a longer range — some researchers claim up to 1 million years — but it’s more complicated than other trapped charge methods, leaving it more susceptible to error.
- cowpig 9y agoWhy does it have to be a hominid? I saw some birds crack open bodes for the marrow on Planet Earth
- pavel_lishin 9y ago> Researchers working at a site in the northern part of the island of Luzon report the discovery of 57 stone tools found with more than 400 animal bones, including the mostly-complete remains of a rhino (the now-extinct Rhinoceros philippinensis, a poorly known subspecies… having a specimen that’s about 75 percent complete is an achievement in and of itself). > Using the electron-spin resonance method on its tooth enamel, the team established that the rhino was about 709,000 years old. Thirteen of its bones, according to the study’s authors, showed signs of butchering, including cuts and “percussion marks” on both humeri (forelimb bones), which is typical of smashing open a bone to access the marrow. Birds don't typically use stone tools heavy enough to split a rhino's bones.
- pvaldes 9y agoHyaenas can do also serious damage to big bones in a corpse (But are known to eat the bones also).
- cobbzilla 9y agoBrings up a good point: the article didn't mention how old the rhino was when it died; maybe the rhino was carrion and the hominins were opportunists on the scene? or has this been ruled out & we know the animal was hunted?
- pavel_lishin 9y agoI don't think that matters too much; the important thing is that the bones were split with what appeared to be human tools, whether it was hunted or found.
- 9y ago
- iio7 9y agoTime machine people, time machine! :)
- jessaustin 9y agoA time-traveling hunting guide operation will have to pay a big fine in another couple of centuries...
- noetic_techy 9y agoIsn't it true that anatomically modern homo sapiens date back 400,000 years? Go back further, and you probably have something close to a chimp. Chimps hunt in packs, so I'm not surprised some hominid group could bring down a Rhino 700,000 years ago.
- DougWebb 9y agoWe couldn't have jumped from "close to a chimp" to homo sapiens. Evolution is a gradual thing, and if we've been largely the same for 400k years, then someone 400k years ago could look back another 400k years and also see someone that's largely the same. So whoever butchered that rhino would be much more like us than like a chimp.
- radicaldreamer 9y agoEvolution isn't necessarily a gradual thing... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Punctuated_equilibrium https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Punctuated_equilibrium
- pvaldes 9y agoNot necessarily. Chimps eat carrion gladly when available. Some chimp (cultures?) populations in Côte d'Ivoire are also known to look actively for marrow in bones
- hyperpape 9y agoStone tools and fire were used more than 1 million years ago. The last common ancestor with chimps is estimated somewhere more than 4 million years ago, so it was probably not “something close to a chimp”. I’m not sure from the article or the limited bit I know whether the butchering was the surprising part, or just the presence of hominids in the Phillipines. It sounds a bit more like the latter.
- gnulinux 9y agoIt is the latter. In my understanding, if this were in Africa or closer parts of Eurasia, this wouldn't be that surprising, since earlier Hominids than Homo sapiens are known to hunt and butcher animals.
- pavel_lishin 9y ago> According to the conventional view in paleoanthropology, only our species, Homo sapiens, had the cognitive capacity to construct watercraft. And to reach the island where the rhino was found, well, like Chief Brody says, “you’re gonna need a bigger boat.” I think if you throw enough hominins in small boats at the ocean, at least a few of them are bound to survive the trip, right? I wonder how many island settlers in pre-history were just castaways who happened to hold on to a tree long enough to survive a monsoon-spurred ocean trip.
- cfadvan 9y agoI agree with your point about just a few on crude boats being needed for this outcome, but the log thing is probably a no-go. Even warm water below body temp will be enough to kill you from hypothermia before you can cross an ocean. Water conducts heat very well, so it would need to be a very quick trip. Crude boats or rafts though, or mats of vegetation could probably work given enough chances.
- goldenkey 9y agoI guess most people like me haven't thought about the necessity of a fire pit on wooden boats. Only other thing I could think of would be well fed exothermic animals onboard.
- TallGuyShort 9y agoWell-fed, well-clothed exothermic humans do just fine so long as they're staying dry - air doesn't conduct heat the way water does, even if it's adjacent to water.
- pavel_lishin 9y agoA fire pit is fine as long as your boat is fairly wet, I believe. You should pick up Kon-Tiki - those guys discovered a lot about ancient boating.
- tCfD 9y agoIn his Journal of Researches as well as the condensed recount found in The Voyage of the Beagle, a young Charles Darwin describes his considerable astonishment at the constitutional robustness of the indigenous peoples he encountered in Tierra del Fuego in the 1830s. At that time they were called Fuegians, though in more modern times they are referred to as Yaghans. Despite their homelands being situated among the harshest, most inhospitable climes on Earth, with year round temperatures frequently near or below freezing and constant powerful circumpolar winds from the 'furious fifties,' they were able to tolerate such extreme conditions despite their traditional attire consisting of little more than a loincloth and an occasional loosely draped shawl. They frequently went without protection on their upper body and lower extremities altogether. Darwin describes a vivid scene where a Fuegian mother is standing in a shallow boat that approaches the Beagle in order to conduct raid. She's wearing nothing but newborn nursing at her breast, and she and her child both seem indifferent to the the snowfall and freezing rain melting on their skin. They did not use permanent dwellings, and basically lived as gatherers using simple temporary makeshift huts with one side facing the wind and the other side open, and of course a fire, which gave the region its name. But it was not uncommon for them to spend days foraging for mussels, drenched in the frigid crashing breakers of the Southern Ocean. This is 30 years before he published the Origin of Species and long before he had developed an articulated concept of natural selection, but The experience did inspire him to remark how it made intuitive sense that as the population of mankind spread across the Earth, that it would have differentiated and adapted to different climates in accordance with whatever underlying principles had driven the same process he had observed this happening with other species. If curious, Google around for Jemmy Button and York Minster, these being too individuals who had been kidnapped from Tierra del Fuego and taken to England on a prior Beagle expedition, and returned on the one accompanied by Darwin.
- sempron64 9y agoThis might be a stupid question, but if the hominin needed a boat to get there, then didn't the rhino also need one?
- alejohausner 9y agoExactly my thought. Mammals without opposable thumbs or well-developed cerebella can cross large bodies of water, clinging to floating material. I don't see why a group of hungry and adventurous proto-humans didn't cross a channel from one island to another. No boat needed. The miracle is that rhino got there. How well can rhinos swim?
- amag 9y agoWell, it must've used a Rhino Boat[1]... [1] http://www.rhinoboat.com/boat-models http://www.rhinoboat.com/boat-models
- gus_massa 9y agoThe rhino didn't get there by boat, it got there walking. Actually, their ancestors got there walking when the island was connected by a land bridge to Asia, and they lived there happily for a few million years while the sea level changed and the position of the island changed. The rhino family evolved something like 20 million years ago. See more details in https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rhinoceros#Evolution https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rhinoceros#Evolution I still not sure how to read all the data in the table, but 20mya looks like an good approximation. In Google I got this two maps of the Earth 20mya. Notice the difference in the shape of the Philippine area. http://web.ics.purdue.edu/~braile/edumod/flipbook/flipbook.htm http://web.ics.purdue.edu/~braile/edumod/flipbook/flipbook.h... http://www.thearmchairexplorer.com/geology/neogene-period http://www.thearmchairexplorer.com/geology/neogene-period I'm not sure that the rhinos reached that place (the current island) 20 million years ago, but they had plenty of time and a lot of difference in the geography that makes a simple walk possible. <oversimplification warning. See an accurate version in https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homo#Evolution https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homo#Evolution > On the other hand, Homo Habilis evolved only 2mya and they lived only in Africa, they had tool but they were not very smart. I think that at that time the Philippines were already isolated from Asia. Homo Erectus evolved 1.5mya. They were quite smart and hd more tools! They went outside Africa to Europe and Asia, but they never crossed some big sea, and never reached America or Australia. They neither crossed some smaller extensions of water to reach some island that were not too close to the continens. So ... the conclusion is that they didn't have good enough boats. Homo Sapiens evolved 0.3mya. (I was going to write 0.1mya, the number changes too often.) They could cross to some places no Erectus has gone before, so the conclusion is that they have some kind of boats even in ancient times. So if the rhino was butchered 0.7mya then it must have be killed by some variant of Homo Erectus that have never been found in an island that is not very close to a continent because they didn't have good enough boats because they were smart but not smart enough. So the lack of boats is a problem for the hominin.
- ecounysis 9y agovisitors from another planet