10 ms·
Stephen Hawking's Final Paper Cuts the Multiverse Down to Size
- everdev 9y ago> this proposal implied something strange: that the multiverse is infinite, with endless, uncountable parallel universes existing alongside our own My biggest skepticism of the multiverse or even an infinite universe is the amount of energy required. Here on Earth energy is finite and cannot be recreated without using more energy in the process. For an infinite universe or multiverse with infinite mass, you'd need infinite energy, right? Infinity seems more like a concept than a physical property. It's easy to imagine an infinite number line, but harder to think about an infinite number of intelligent beings (which I suppose would be possible in an infinite universe).
- netzone 9y agoWhat if we only get precisely the amount of energy we require? Each universe won't need infinite energy.
- BlackFly 9y ago> For an infinite universe or multiverse with infinite mass, you'd need infinite energy, right? Given that the current best guess for the geometry of the universe is (conformally) flat, this universe already contains infinite energy. From what I recall, the normal definitions of total energy of a spacetime are not possible to formulate for non-asymptotically flat spacetimes. So it is a bit nonsensical to talk about the total mass/energy. The easiest skeptical take on multiverses is simply that there are no measurables defined by multiverse theories yet. I usually lump them in with anthropic theories, which a lot of GR theorists seem to love.
- evanpw 9y agoTalking about asymptotics already assumes that the universe is infinite. Any smooth, finite spacetime will have finite energy. The interesting thing about asymptotically flat spacetimes is that they can be infinite in volume but have finite energy.
- darkmighty 9y agoBut our universe is believed to be isotropic, and it has positive energy density everywhere, so it seems that should imply infinite total energy.
- wuliwong 9y agoWhy would this lead to infinite energy? Positive density summed over a finite volume does not equal infinity.
- ouid 9y agoThe "anthropic theories" aren't really something you can be skeptical about in the normal sense of skepticism, unless I'm misunderstanding your point.
- BlackFly 9y agoWell, indeed I disregard anthropic theories largely on the grounds of non-cognitivism, which I suppose is not an ordinary form of skepticism. I lump them both together in my own mind not because of how I rationalize ignoring them, but instead because I think the popularity of both of them is driven more out of spiritualism than science.
- YCode 9y ago"Some have posited that there are an infinite number of molecules outside of the one we call home. They vary in size and shape, according to multimolecule theory. In some of them it is said the hydrogen galaxy is in the outer section, some the exact center, and some have no hydrogen galaxy at all!" "My biggest skepticism of this theory is that it has been proven here in our molecule we cannot create or destroy atoms. Insofar as we know no atom has ever been added or removed from our molecule in the millions of plancks we have observed the known molecule for and none ever will." "And for there to be an infinite number of molecules beyond the confines of our own - each with their own strange and exotic configuration expanding and changing off into eternity - you would need an infinite amount of atoms and electron fields to properly bind the vast regions of atoms. And as it's been well proven, atoms in this molecule are finite and unchanging."
- consumer451 9y agoIf the zero-energy hypothesis[0] is correct, wouldn't the energy cost of infinite universes still be zero? [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zero-energy_universe https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zero-energy_universe
- darkmighty 9y agoMultiverse theories aside, as far as we know our current universe could, or should (depending on who you ask), be infinite. There is no evidence that its topology is closed (from estimates of curvature), so infinitely large is indeed the default assumption.
- liberte82 9y agoIs the theory that space-time is infinitely large, or also that there is an infinite amount of matter/energy within it?
- darkmighty 9y agoThe theory is that space-time is infinitely large, and there is an infinite amount of energy within it (afaik). Actually the theory (General Relativity)is that a closed universe should have measurable positive curvature, unless it has some weird topology that isn't "naturally" expected (although everything consistent is possible of course). We measure a curvature approximately 0, so that would imply the universe is in fact infinite. Since it is also expected to be isotropic (have approx. the same distribution properties everywhere and in any direction), then it also would have infinite energy. There's no proof of this infiniteness of course, it is only the most natural expectation (most natural of course is always controversial since some physicists probably don't like infinite universes). What we observe, and what can affect us in any way, is of course the 'Observable Universe', and up to its edge it appears boringly uniform (except for a minor anomaly[1]), arranging in a web of huge filaments[2] that extend across its entirety. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Axis_of_evil_(cosmology) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Axis_of_evil_(cosmology) [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Galaxy_filament https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Galaxy_filament
- kazinator 9y agoEnergy is just a concept in our particular universe. The idea behind the multiverse hypothesis is that everything is just "math all the way down". Other universes do not all have the pieces of math which underlie "conservation of energy", and so on. The equations of each universe determine whether or not it has any phenomenon resembling our energy.
- CuriouslyC 9y agoThe idea that the multiverse can continue to expand at the incredible rate that would be required based on the idea as stated always made it seem implausible to me. Furthermore, it bothers me that the idea discards the notion of probability inherent in quantum mechanics, since everything that can happen, does. A more sane model for me is to imagine the state of the universe as a quantized distribution over a set of set of states with finite measure. This is sort of like the multiverse in that the wavefunction doesn't "collapse" but instead reality "branches." Unlike the multiverse, branches are constantly being created and dying off, since the information content of the universe is conserved. This also preserves the probability derived from the wavefunction - states are kept or discard based on their probability.
- mikeash 9y agoI personally find the idea of finiteness much harder to accept. Infinity makes sense to me. It just means there’s no limit to stuff. Why should reality have a limit? A finite reality is just plain weird because it implies there’s a single actual number describing how much stuff there is. The universe contains X godzillion kilograms, or is Y billion light years across. Where did those numbers come from? What determined them? Why isn’t there more stuff, or less?
- klodolph 9y agoThis reminds me of the kind of magical thinking that people like Aristotle used. Why should the universe be easy or hard for you to accept? Why is it important that these numbers "come from somewhere" or be determined by something? Why doesn't the same thing apply to e.g. energy density? Fine structure constant? Gravitational constant? Why isn't the gravitational constant higher or lower?
- mikeash 9y agoWhere did I say the universe should be easy for me to accept? You seem to have inferred a “therefore that’s the way things really are” ending to my comment that I did not write nor intend to imply.
- Tyr42 9y agoI mean, it makes some sense if there was a big bang X years ago, that everything ends up withing X lightyears of each other. I find it easy enough to think of there being a beginning, since we know that stars age, and use up energy, so they can't have been running forever. Since we think the big bang was 13.7 billion years ago, we can put Y at about 2*13.7 billion light years across as a first guess. Though there's something funkey with the spacetime stretching or whatever. So maybe more.
- resource0x 9y agoStars cannot run forever, they explode eventually, and other stars can form from the debris: https://www.quora.com/What-is-a-third-generation-star?utm_medium=organic&utm_source=google_rich_qa&utm_campaign=google_rich_qa https://www.quora.com/What-is-a-third-generation-star?utm_me... For the Universe having certain age - I don't understand it, b/c whatever is 13 billion years for one, might be 1 sec for another, due to relativistic time dilation. I think of this number as a kind of metaphor :)
- sandworm101 9y ago>> For an infinite universe or multiverse with infinite mass, you'd need infinite energy, right? Except that under some theories the net energy in our universe is actually zero. Antimatter+matter = nothing. So the concept of unlimited energy can be acceptable under the rubric that energy in one area is mirrored by anti-energy in another.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> Antimatter+matter = nothing. Matter and antimatter both are forms in which energy (and not “anti-energy”) is bound up; matter + antimatter = energy, as is observable in particle / anti-particle interactions.
- spiralx 9y ago> Except that under some theories the net energy in our universe is actually zero. Antimatter+matter = nothing. So the concept of unlimited energy can be acceptable under the rubric that energy in one area is mirrored by anti-energy in another. No, anti-matter still has positive energy. It's the gravitational potential energy that balances out all of the other energy to leave a total of zero - every particle's energy is cancelled by its negative potential energy of its gravitational field.
- assblaster 9y agoWho/what created the multiverse? Do matter and energy simply exist without creation? Is proving the existence of the multiverse possible?
- jerf 9y ago"Is proving the existence of the multiverse possible?" It's proving it's nonexistence that is quite a challenge. Proving their existence could be demonstrated by, for instance, traveling to them. I personally see no reason to believe that is possible, but if somebody traveled to one and thereby disproved me, that would be that. That said, it might just about take that to prove one. Even if one produces theories that say a multiverse might be possible, I expect there will always be a simple transform for which the equations still work but there is only the one universe. For instance, taking well-established existing equations, while the QM field equations may imply that a quantum multiverse is possible, no matter how mathematically distasteful some people may find it the Copenhagen interpretation is still possibly the truth, and I'm not sure what possible experiment could disprove that. (The Universe may do as it damn well pleases.) I'm unsure what evidence we could collect other than concrete proof of existence that would somehow prove multiverses.
- maxfurman 9y ago> if somebody traveled to one and thereby disproved me That person would have to travel back as well, thereby making this proof doubly hard :-)
- assblaster 9y agoConscious thought requires a delicate interplay of neurons and chemicals, that if disturbed by visiting a permutation of the multiverse, would cease to function. Humans can not directly observe an alternative permutation, but even if they could, how would they be able to find their way back to their original permutation if there's an infinite number of permutations?
- 9y ago
- perpetualcrayon 9y agoIt still boggles my mind, but I honestly believe that there is something beyond our own universe. The other thing that trips me up but I can conceptualize is the idea that there may be things that had no beginning and will have no end. The human mind is very much suited to understand things to have beginnings and ends. Our own universe very clearly had a beginning and will certainly have an end. But that which exists beyond our own universe. Is it necessary that whatever is there did not exist at some point? I think it's entirely possible that whatever exists beyond our own universe may have been there always and will continue to be there forever. No beginning and no end.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- snissn 9y agoPascal's mugging is a really cool thought experiment. Similarly is the thought that what if instead of the entire universe being the size of the viewable universe it's 10^N power, so just another exponential leap in size. Then our little corner of the multi-verse becomes such a tiny speck.
- Retric 9y agoPascal's mugging is simple failure to recognize probabilities can be and grow arbitrarily small. If a mugger paying you 4,000 dollars is less than half as likely as them paying you 2,000 dollars and you repeat that as the numbers grow then there is no inflection point.
- deciplex 9y agoMultiverse and universe-outside-the-visible-universe are not the same thing.
- neolefty 9y agoWell explained! And I wonder: Does the existence of our universe require that something else "exist" outside of time? People claim it as a proof of "God" or a creator, and I used to be skeptical of that logic (albeit I am a theist, for other reasons) but the way you put it I find pretty convincing.
- toxicFork 9y agoWe can only comprehend matter that affects only the five senses that we use to perceive "the universe". What if there's a kind of matter that cannot be perceived by the five senses that we use, and does not interact in any way with the matter that can be sensed? Could we consider each of these kinds of matter to belong to another universe?
- SonOfLilit 9y agoAffects directly or indirectly. But indeed, anything that does not affect anything that affects anything [..] that could be perceived, can not be considered in any meaningful way to belong to our universe. Isn't that the meaning of "universe"? The set of all things closed under all possible physical interactions?
- harshulpandav 9y agoAgreed. Definition of matter should be relative. A radio wave doesn't see a wall like how we do. Also, Time seems to be one the biggest discovery of Humans even when we don't see it, feel it, smell it, hear it, taste it. Possibly there are other such things like time yet to be discovered in this universe.
- arbitrage 9y agoThere are more than five senses. http://www.bbc.com/future/story/20141118-how-many-senses-do-you-have http://www.bbc.com/future/story/20141118-how-many-senses-do-...
- zamalek 9y agoKeep in mind that only some multiverse hypotheses are extradimensional. Many would prohibit viewing other universes because they don't occupy the same "space" as us. For example, one hypothesis suggests that black holes are the creators of universes (where a star collapsing in our universe occurs simultaneously with a big bang within the singularity). We'd never be able to reach that universe and so could not perceive it, regardless of exotic senses.
- wuliwong 9y ago> "like a sphere without edges" That's a strange analogy. I would think of an infinite cube but then I guess I'm thinking in cartesian space. :)
- dmayle 9y agoI don't know... something that always bothered me about multiverse theory is that multiverses are supposed to be the explanation for why a lot of our quantum math works out so beautifully. Matter is continuous into other dimensions, and this is why things like the photon/wave duality can work, interaction with other realities. In our reality, however, our universe is so sparse as to be almost non-existent (density of the universe is something like 1 hydrogen atom for every 5k cubic meters). This has been measured, and means that our universe is flat (Euclidean). In my mind, in order to connect the density of the universe with the continuity of quantam behavior, than every reality must have the same density, and flow continuously from ours, which would mean that every reality is Euclidean. This is where it gets fuzzy for me, because it's my understanding that the multiverse is not Euclidean....
- deciplex 9y agoIsn't this post conflating multiverse hypotheses with the relative-state formulation of quantum mechanics?
- dmayle 9y agoTo be fair, isn't Everett's relative-state formulation the basis/beginning of all multiverse hypotheses?
- deciplex 9y agoIt seems like "multiverse" is used to describe a half-dozen mostly unrelated things or more (just based on the contents of this thread) including among them many-worlds. But, for example, eternal inflation has nothing directly to do with relative-state formulation, nor mathematical universe, nor the "multiverse" where you consider that portion of the universe outside our cosmological horizon to be a separate universe (I wouldn't agree that it is, but apparently that's a thing).
- spiralx 9y agoMax Tegmark has put these ideas into a hierarchy of multiverses, where universes outside of the boundary of the observable Universe are a Type I multiverse, and the many-worlds of the relative-state formulation form a Type III multiverse. http://space.mit.edu/home/tegmark/crazy.html http://space.mit.edu/home/tegmark/crazy.html
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoWhat is more mind boggling to me than this is the fact that Professor Hawking could accurately and properly collaborate on such complex topics with other researchers at this level given the limits to his communication. I had the privilege of attending a live speech Professor Hawking give back in 2002 or so, and the most impactful thing about it was that it wasn't pre-recorded. He would "speak" a sentence and then there would be between 10-45 seconds of silence and then another sentence. This continued for about an hour and a half and nobody lost interest. I have to assume that the typing, formatting etc... of this paper was handled by someone else, however even just communicating greek characters, algorithms and diagrams must have been a feat.