4 ms·
> There are businesses that the public doesn't trust that could be disrupted by blockchain technology. Take a look at the studies on trust in casino and poker g
by geofft 9y ago
> There are businesses that the public doesn't trust that could be disrupted by blockchain technology. Take a look at the studies on trust in casino and poker games. The public is very skeptical.
Why is blockchain more useful here than a commitment scheme (e.g., the dealer publishes a salted hash of the order of cards, plays the game, then reveals the salt once all the cards are played)? The commitment scheme doesn't involve waiting for proof-of-work calculations or interacting with an existing global network / file.
It makes sense to use a stateful structure for a ledger of money, because the question of how much money I have depends on how much money was transfered to me since my account was opened. But how one poker game is played is not affected by how any previous poker game was played.
- dnautics 9y agobeautifully explained.
- atomical 9y agoWhere is the automated dispute resolution in the system you are describing? What is preventing the house from cheating?
- geofft 9y agoThe commitment scheme solves "cheating" in the sense of "dealing cards in a different order depending on how the game goes". There are other types of cheating, e.g., leaking the order to players and perhaps picking a non-random order in advance. Those will take longer than a parenthetical in a conversation about Bitcoin to address. Do you think that a blockchain is capable of solving any of these types of cheating more than some offline stateless scheme could?
- atomical 9y agoDoes the process you are referring to automatically give a refund to the player? It's hard for me to follow your logic because you mention Bitcoin which doesn't have a smart contract language like Ethereum. Check out the FunFair project. https://funfair.io/how-it-works/whitepapers/ https://funfair.io/how-it-works/whitepapers/
- geofft 9y agoOh, I was going off this thread being about Bitcoin. Ethereum is probably a better example, sure. If your constraint is "I want a transfer of money based entirely on the output of this algorithm on this data," then a blockchain platform is probably the right approach, sure. But I think you only need that for an internet gambling site... if you're trying to restore trust in a physical casino, the wagered money is right there on the table, it's clear who should get it. (The other participant trying to physically attack you to get money they don't deserve is out of the threat model, I think.) FunFair looks cool but I think it mostly follows this design: the actual game is off-chain and it's only settlement that happens in Ethereum itself, if I'm reading right. You're doing a commitment scheme on your shared RNG, you're just also adding in a smart contract that can verify the game (or a partial game, hopefully) and determine who should get what money. If all players trusted a third party to escrow the funds (where the third party could be an API or a table with a pile of money), then you could do the game with no blockchain at all.