5 ms·
Google did not fail at starting an ISP. They decided that the ROI for doing individual residential home FTTH was not worth it, considering the cost per house pa
by walrus01 9y ago
Google did not fail at starting an ISP. They decided that the ROI for doing individual residential home FTTH was not worth it, considering the cost per house passed. Then they went and bought Webpass, which has a totally different condo/apartment based business model, which has been wildly successful.
Starting a small ISP based out of extreme dissatisfaction with huge, evil incumbents is something that I encourage any plucky upstart to do. If you don't like Comcast, Charter, RCN, etc, if you have sufficient clue, go do it yourself. Just don't try to do it with $20,000 and some good wishes, because something with much deeper pockets like Webpass will come along and obliterate you.
The point that I am rather bluntly trying to get across to these folks is that if they're going to invest significant amounts of their personal time/engineering resources into it (unpaid labor?), that they should treat it like a serious business and not a nonprofit. Raise sufficient funds, somewhere in the $500,000+ range to start, to build a network that actually does meet five nines through sufficient diversity in topology and routing.
Compared to random YC companies that seem to raise $1m to $5m to do some vaguely defined web2.0 SAAS thing, the amount of money that a group of people need to raise to build the core of a serious ISP is not huge. Elsewhere in this thread I threw out a figure like $750,000 in beginning CapEx if they're serious. For some good reasons, however, it's easier to get $5m of series A funding from a VC for a pure software development business than a wholly-owned-facilities-based startup ISP.
Even if you completely ignore things like colocation costs, IP transit costs, IX/peering costs, office rental, office utilities and overhead, running a serious ISP with live, clued in humans watching the network takes a lot of money per year for salaries.
3 to 5 NOC persons for 24x7x365 NOC phone coverage. At a certain point if you peer with the big boy ASNs they will expect a live human to answer the phone at 3am when something unusual happens in traffic between your mutual networks. That live human needs to be somebody who has the equivalent of 'enable' on your peering router and sufficient clue to wield it.
2 network engineering/architecture positions, multiply by expected fully loaded yearly salary and benefits package for each person.
at least 2 field technicians
vehicles, vehicle insurance, tools for technicians
At NYC salaries? In a greenfield scenario, I could easily spend $900,000 a year in just payroll and benefits, just to begin to attempt to duplicate what some other serious ISPs already have in place for manpower.
And again that is before you spend one dollar on equipment.
- dzonga 9y agoAfrican Internet is really slow. Being a noob and knowing we can access the undersea cable. How would you go about building such a mesh network for an medium densely populate african city i.e 3+ million people ?
- jimktrains2 9y ago> Google did not fail at starting an ISP. They decided that the ROI for doing individual residential home FTTH was not worth it, considering the cost per house passed. ~Kind of sounds like it failed.~ Apparently Google Fiber is starting to expand again. I still think it serves as a good case against why the current climate makes it near-impossible for a "plucky upstart [with vc funding]" to start a large, traditional ISP. > Starting a small ISP based out of extreme dissatisfaction with huge, evil incumbents is something that I encourage any plucky upstart to do. ... Just don't try to do it with $20,000 and some good wishes, because something with much deeper pockets like Webpass will come along and obliterate you. You can't be a plucky upstart while simultaneously having pockets deep enough to fend against the current major ISP players. I'm not going to sit here and reply line-by-line to your post. The issue isn't that people want a free network. The issue is that people are fed up with the large ISPs and that the large ISPs have made it all-but-impossible to start an ISP. You seem to think that VC-sized money is the only thing people need to enter the market. You're entirely wrong. Entrenched players have made it next-to-impossible to compete in terms of capital and regulatory hurdles.
- rayiner 9y agoGoogle is just a terrible example. On net, Google got incredibly preferential regulatory treatment. https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2012/09/how-kansas-city-taxpayers-support-google-fiber/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2012/09/how-kansas-city-... They just realized it makes no sense for them to be in a low ROI industry: https://www.mckinsey.com/~/media/McKinsey/Business%20Functions/Strategy%20and%20Corporate%20Finance/Our%20Insights/A%20long%20term%20look%20at%20ROIC/SVGZ%20037_A_longterm_look_at_ROIC_Exh_2.ashx https://www.mckinsey.com/~/media/McKinsey/Business%20Functio...
- walrus01 9y ago> The issue is that people are fed up with the large ISPs and that the large ISPs have made it all-but-impossible to start an ISP. that's the thing, they haven't. Not in the service territory this new nonprofit is operating in. There's something like 14 different ISPs which overlap service area with them in their part of New York City, none of which are big nationwide Comcast or Centurylink sized entities. What they're trying to do on a shoestring is on super hard mode, they've picked the single most competitive market in the entire USA to try to compete with independent, non-LEC, non-major-telco companies that do have a few million dollars to throw at their own facilities-based network infrastructure.