4 ms·
> into thinking paying ~$450 / month per adult for basic health insurance with high deductibles is a bargain because it "saves" them from $100,000+ hospital bil
by ajross 9y ago
> into thinking paying ~$450 / month per adult for basic health insurance with high deductibles is a bargain because it "saves" them from $100,000+ hospital bills in an emergency scenario
It is, though. Insurance is expensive, but it's not a scam. That money tends to go mostly for care, overall. Someone has to pay it.
It's true that on the whole, the US tends to overpay for care and that other systems tend to get similar results for less cost. But that's a constant factor on the insurance payment.
Obviously many of us think making this an individual burden is a bad idea: obviously it's regressive and burdensome for the bottom of the income distribution, and more subtly it's a moral hazard for the healthy, who are tempted to forego insurance figuring that they don't need it and thus pushing the cost of providing care disproportionately onto the sick and the elderly.
But again, someone has to pay it. There's no magic wand here that makes health care cheap or free. Health care is expensive, someone's got to write that check.
> In 2017 I had to spend thousands of dollars in tax penalties for not having insurance. Welcome to the US!
Because someone has to pay it, and you didn't!
- Bjartr 9y agoHealth care has a cost, sure. But you haven't explained why that cost is so much higher in the US if outcomes aren't proportionally better.
- Keverw 9y agoI wonder if everyone wanting to sue in America and high malpractice insurance costs might be a reason we pay more with less quality of care in America? I mean sure if you get hurt, you want some sort of recourse but I wonder if that's why American medicine is so high. A lot of the full time RV community parks and walks over to Los Algodones, Mexico for eye care/glasses, dental and some medicines that aren't a certain schedule they can get and are allowed to take back a certain amount. They pay cash directly, no insurance is needed. I guess they don't drive because of needing a separate auto insurance policy for Mexico. I believe most US policies cover only Canada, but not Mexico for trips across the border. Plus it might be quicker to just walk back and forth for a day trip. There's a official border crossing back and forth on foot for pedestrians, compared to cars which has a lot longer line. However I'm not too sure what kind of recourse you have if a dentist or some other doctor messes up. Haven't researched it too much personally. There's some YouTube videos about it though, they have like a entire block of just dental offices back to back. Kinda amazing, but it's a popular area for medical tourism. A lot of them even speak English in that town, accepts US dollars and everything. Some people just visit for lunch and check out the town.
- briandear 9y agoWhen an OB doc pays 6 figures a year in malpractice insurance — that’s why. The party on the left who complain the loudest about health cost are incidentally heavily supported by the plaintiffs lawyers. Look at who opposed tort reform in Texas — it wasn’t Republicans, they are the ones that proposed it; it was plaintiff lawyers and the candidates they purchase. Literally billions a year is paid in malpractice claims and punitive damages in the 7 figures is common. Who pays those awards? We do. Try suing the NHS. Or in the case of Alfie, try even having someone else willing to pay to leave the hospital — not happening. There is also cross-subsidation as well. When an uninsured “undocumented” person visits the ER for a sore throat — that money is almost never collected, hence the $100 bed pan. When services are effectively shoplifted, everyone else covers the loss. For data on this, look at the finances of south Texas hospitals compared to a hospital in Wyoming. Or better yet, go work in a hospital billing department. Those that disagree with this have never worked in an ER. Ironically, in Mexico, if you need an emergency surgery, you better have proof of funds or they will literally let you die in the waiting room. Even the “beloved” NHS will deny care to non-citizens: https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/pregnant-british-woman-emma-szewczak-harris-nhs-treatment-addenbrookes-hospital-polish-uk-a8012846.html https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/pregnant-bri... But the US? Pregnant woman walks in to any US hospital, they’ll be treated regardless of ability to pay or citizenship — which is a good thing, but then we can’t be surprised when we get to pay for that when we visit the ER.
- nickjj 9y ago> It is, though. Insurance is expensive, but it's not a scam. That money tends to go mostly for care, overall. Someone has to pay it. Yes but the govt already takes a bit over 40% of my income (I run my own business). I'm certainly paying my share. It's not my fault that the govt would rather use those funds on non-healthcare related things. I'm all for a true universal health care for everyone, but if you're already taxing me so hard, I shouldn't have even more taken away from me. That's unreasonable. > Because someone has to pay it, and you didn't! I would bet anything the amount I paid in penalties is more than what most people pay to be insured just going by the average income in the US compared to the "assisted pay" discount you get for having a certain bracket of income. I don't even make that much either. I'm in the "typical software developer income" bracket, but I'm self employed so I have no help or matching from an employer. I'm essentially paying both halves with no benefits (health or retirement). And to top it off, if I get into medical trouble I'm left hanging.
- uberduber 9y agoFYI, there's a loophole out of the penalty. Don't know anyone who's tried it, but if you get a disconnect notice from the utility you get three months I think, so just time your payments accordingly.
- waisbrot 9y ago> I'm certainly paying my share. That seems very hard to determine, especially as a business owner. What's the value to you of safe shipping lanes to get raw materials to you? What's the value of employees not worrying about being executed by warlords? What's the value of having US customers who can afford your products? I don't think you can say what your "fair share" is as some limit for what you pay. Rather, the amount the businesses are taxed has to be a matter of pragmatism. > I would bet anything the amount I paid in penalties is more than what most people pay to be insured One would hope so. That is the point of penalties, after all.
- nickjj 9y ago> That seems very hard to determine, especially as a business owner. What's the value to you of safe shipping lanes to get raw materials to you? What's the value of employees not worrying about being executed by warlords? What's the value of having US customers who can afford your products? I am a freelance web developer and online teacher. I have no employees or physical goods. About half of my customers are from the US and I am in a hyper competitive world wide market.