5 ms·
Bonobo and chimpanzee gestures overlap extensively in meaning
- sunstone 9y agoIt's quite possible that human language started as body/gesture language and then migrated to primarily voice.
- ThrustVectoring 9y agoIMO it's still primarily a body/gesture language. Oh, sure, it has some abstract symbolic representation stuff built on top of more primal human communication channels. However, when the new stuff conflicts with body language and paralinguistic signals, it typically gets disregarded.
- mratzloff 9y agoHe said on a global network where communication is primarily text-based.
- dghf 9y agoYes, but when I read that I imagine your eyes rolling.
- mjburgess 9y agoAnd infamous for its vitriol.
- ThrustVectoring 9y agoWell, yeah, I like the textual/narrative stuff too. It's a fun game. It's just a minority of my experience.
- brazzy 9y ago> IMO it's still primarily a body/gesture language. Nonsense. The vast majority of what we communicate nowadays cannot be represented adequately or at all by your "more primal human communication channels".
- ben_w 9y agoI believe a single emoji — ponder or similar — is genuinely an appropriate response here, however they are automatically stripped. A policy I agree with, but they are surprisingly capable despite their simplicity and (in many cases) direct mapping onto body states.
- brazzy 9y agoNow try expressing the concepts of "automatically stripped", or "policy I agree with", or "surprisingly capable" in emoji or body language.
- xj9 9y agoemoji don't help you express precise rational statements. they add something that text lacks: the subtext that people normally express with tone and body language. emoji aren't a replacement for your day to day unicode symbols, they are something you can add to make your messages more expressive. technically you can express all of the same things without emoji, but there's a limit to how subtle you can be. by adding an emotional cue using an emoji i can completely change the meaning of a statement by adding contextual subtext.
- brazzy 9y agoThat's a very different thing than the claim that human language is "still primarily a body/gesture language", which is what I was arguing against.
- ben_w 9y agoThere are many interesting things which cannot be expressed by body language, one of which is what is meant by “primarily”. Maslow's hierarchy? Body language is primary, it comes first. By number of bits required to describe the typical change to synaptic weights? No idea. By number of raw bits? If I had to bet, I’d give 10:1 that body language beats words with reasonable compression for both audio and video streams, much stronger certainty for uncompressed.
- ramblerman 9y ago> Oh, sure, it has some abstract symbolic representation stuff built on top Some??? You mean concepts like Money, God, the State, Law, debt, marriage, responsibility :)
- drb91 9y agoSo what is crying then? You’re being hugely reductive for no discernable benefit.
- simiones 9y agoIt's also very possible that human language started as a purely internal thinking mechanism, and only later became adopted for communicating with other humans. This seems very counter-intuitive initially, but makes more sense when you think about how much of your use of language is addressed to other people, and how much is used simply for thinking to yourself.
- yosito 9y agoI'm multi-lingual and very few of my thoughts are in any "language" unless I'm intending to communicate them with others. When I only spoke English, I don't think my thoughts were in English either, but it was harder to be aware of that fact until I could ask myself which language I was thinking in. The same is true of my dreams. I don't dream in any particular language, other than an occasional word here or there.
- simiones 9y agoInteresting! Myself, I have a native language and I'm also fluent in English, and basically all of my thoughts are expressed conversationally (I also have conversations in most of my dreams, though of course they have many other components). I'm curious - if you don't think in language, do you have any way of explaining how you think about abstract concepts?
- dreyfiz 9y agoThe idea that bonobos and chimpanzees can speak the same language is absolutely thrilling. Even though bonobos are chimps, I always saw the two species as very distinct; this discovery really resets my worldview on multiple levels.
- jerrre 9y agoI'm not an expert by far, but aren't many animal "gestures" shared by multiple species: lying down to surrender, standing on hind legs to threaten, showing teeth, etc...?
- wallace_f 9y agoAlso not an expert, but I suppose at some point there can be a distinction made between body language and sign language?
- firmgently 9y agobonobos aren't chimps, they're separate species https://knowledgenuts.com/2013/08/18/the-difference-between-chimps-and-bonobos/ https://knowledgenuts.com/2013/08/18/the-difference-between-... "an endangered great ape and one of the two species making up the genus Pan; the other is Pan troglodytes, or the common chimpanzee." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bonobo https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bonobo
- dghf 9y agoThe sentence you quote from Wikipedia starts like this: > The bonobo (/bə.ˈnoʊ.boʊ/ or /ˈbɒ.nə.boʊ/; Pan paniscus), formerly called the pygmy chimpanzee and less often, the dwarf or gracile chimpanzee Also see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chimpanzee https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chimpanzee: > The taxonomical genus Pan (often referred to as chimpanzees or chimps) consists of two extant species: the common chimpanzee and the bonobo. It's like "crow", which can refer to a particular species (e.g., in England a crow, unqualified, usually means a carrion crow), or to the genus Corvus, which includes e.g. ravens and rooks.
- fallingfrog 9y agoKind of funny how much of their vocabulary consists of various ways of saying "get over here, you sexy beast.."
- pvaldes 9y agoEven more interesting, If staying bipedal means 'lets make sex' for bonobos, I wonder if human observers could change the behaviour of studied bonobos increasing the sexual encounters (just because we are standing there shouting 'lets make sex' with our bodies all the time). Wouldn't be crazy if we repeat the research with robots and remote cameras to find that they are not so promiscuous as we thought? We must be a particularly foul-mouthed species for them. And we share also the 'stop what you were doing' grab/slap.