3 ms·
TFA seems completely contradicted by its penultimate sentence? Or does this mean that the latter study doesn't consider the error possibilities raised by the fo
by jessaustin 9y ago
TFA seems completely contradicted by its penultimate sentence? Or does this mean that the latter study doesn't consider the error possibilities raised by the former?
- harrumphrodite 9y agoI would suggest that the antipenultimate sentence represents a partial ontological quandary. But if you peruse the former, and not the latter, you should be sifficiently convinced of any such probable suppositions.
- SolarNet 9y agoI think it's just the scientific reporting equivalent of FUD, this is news, but it doesn't fit the long term narrative they will need to keep selling scientific reporting. Hence some editor probably stuffed those last bits in there. The fact they are reporting it all is pretty decent for modern journalism.
- SiempreViernes 9y agoUh no, this is actually more like the man plastering the city with "all is well" posters: that the tension between CMB and SN determinations of the Hubble constant will be resolved by fixing some tricky detail in the analysis is the most mainstream expectation out there. The tension has been there for a long time, but its only something like two years ago that the statistical errors got small enough you had to somewhat seriously consider there could be some important reason for the disagreement.
- SiempreViernes 9y agoRight now the absolute calibration is done by matching nearby supernovae with Cepheids and then extrapolating to remote SNs which is where the cosmology lies (essentially). Gaia gives better Cepheid distances, decreasing the total uncertainty somewhat. But the big story is the calibration of the intrinsics supernova brightness (and its variation), so while better Cepheids help, its mostly by further closing a already unlikely avenue of explanation. The big crime of the article is portraying the field as thinking the tension is due to new physics, when in fact the difference between the CMB and SN determinations has been known for something like 20 years and for all that time been mostly viewed as something experimentalists get sorted. For a long time the values agreed within their stated uncertainties, and its only rather recently that they have pushed their statistical errors down enough that the difference can be said to be real. So its a while yet until the difference is truly trusted as something to be explained by new physics rather than some calibration error.
- batbomb 9y agoThe Planck results are really the most problematic, so we will see if that changes over time.