3 ms·
I want to clarify some details on how the Early Access Program (EAP) works because I'm seeing some confusion here in the comments. EAP is a 7-day period in adv
by CydeWeys 9y ago
I want to clarify some details on how the Early Access Program (EAP) works because I'm seeing some confusion here in the comments.
EAP is a 7-day period in advance of General Availability (GA) during which domains can be registered immediately (not pre-ordered). EAP is a descending price ("Dutch") auction, meaning that prices start off high and then decrease as the auction goes on. The reason for this is to efficiently allocate domains to those who want them the most, rather than allowing desirable ones to be snatched up by those with the intent of reselling them. It's the concert ticket problem in domain name form.
We are currently in the first day of EAP. Each price tier lasts for the entirety of the day, and then ticks over to the next lower tier at precisely 16:00:00.000 Z. There are price drops over the first four transitions, and then the final three days are all at the lowest price tier. EAP is a one-time acquisition fee; you do not pay that on subsequent renewal. Different registrars choose different amounts for EAP tiers just like they choose different rates for base registration. EAP began today at 2018-05-01 16:00:00 Z and ends precisely when GA begins, which is at 2018-05-08 16:00:00 Z.
The confusion around EAP is stemming from the fact that many registrars are offering preorders for specific EAP price tiers (or GA). So while we're not yet in the lowest price tier, you can put in a preorder for the lowest price tier now, and the registrar will then attempt to register the domain for you within the first moments of that price tier once it begins. Whereas if you buy a domain in the current price tier, the registration goes through immediately and there's no element of chance like there is for preorders. Typically preorders that you don't win are refunded, though some registrars may charge non-refundable application fees.
Separately from all of that, there are also premium domains; those prices are orthogonal to EAP and affect renewal prices as well as initial registrations. EAP fees disappear entirely once we hit GA, but premium fees persist. Again, the intent of all of these is efficient domain allocation. You may be asking "why both?", and the answer is that both pricing mechanisms are good at solving different aspects of the problem of efficient allocation.
For a full list of registrars selling .app, see https://get.app https://get.app and https://www.registry.google/about/register.html https://www.registry.google/about/register.html
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- paultopia 9y agoBoth pricing mechanisms are great at: (a) transferring wealth from the secondary market to registrars, and (b) guaranteeing that desirable domain names get allocated purely on economic value terms, thus effectively shutting out non-profit-oriented enterprises from the best domain names. If someone with some quirky desire to name a domain name after their cat would like to grab the domain name and refuse to sell, this pricing scheme guarantees that such sentimental value counts for zero in the "efficient allocation" measure. Both of these seem pretty shitty to me.
- sah2ed 9y agoDesirable domains are by definition scarce -- there is not enough of them to go round to those who desire them. The current approach is essentially saying "if you really desire domain X badly, put your money where your mouth is". Do you have an alternative proposal on how these desirable domains could be allocated more efficiently?
- paultopia 9y ago"Efficiently" is a concept defined only by your target. If your target is economic value, then, sure this kind of auction does a pretty good job at allocating efficiently with respect to it. If your target is something like desire-satisfaction, or promoting novelty/creative use, then it might be worth trying to think about ways to preferentially allocate to people willing to put in more effort too, or, e.g., introduce some kind of lottery system for some domains for non-commercial uses.
- cobbzilla 9y agoIn what units do you measure "desire-satisfaction" and "promoting creative use"? How do you know that an outcome was optimal?
- makmanalp 9y agoOn the other hand this seems like a pretty decent way to prevent mass domain squatting, because screw those guys. I'm sure there are still some people doing complicated cost/benefit analyses and squatting strategically but I think it'll be much less rampant.
- mezod 9y agowhat defines a domain name as premium?
- CydeWeys 9y agoMachine learning. (Not joking.)
- rtkwe 9y agoA couple easy metrics: Existing brand names/trademarks, existing websites on other TLDs, and length of domain with additional weighting for actual words (maybe additional weighting based on word/tuple frequency in say the google books corpus).