4 ms·
This is nothing to do with censorship. AWS has many clients and does not want its network to be blocked because of a single customer. Tough for Signal but that'
by manigandham 9y ago
This is nothing to do with censorship. AWS has many clients and does not want its network to be blocked because of a single customer. Tough for Signal but that's how it is when dealing with businesses (especially one that so many others rely on).
The same thing just happened with Telegram in Russia which explains the preemptive messages: https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2018/04/in-effort-to-shut-down-telegram-russia-blocks-amazon-google-network-addresses/ https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2018/04/in-ef...
- maxerickson 9y agoCapitulating to foreign censors for business reasons has something to do with censorship.
- s73v3r_ 9y agoNo, it doesn't. This is Amazon saying they don't wish to be a part of this dispute, which is entirely their right. It is not Signal's right to drag Amazon into the dispute against their will.
- maxerickson 9y agoAmazon stepping away is literally the result of censorship working. It's entirely their right of course.
- eganist 9y ago> they don't wish to be a part of this dispute, Right, because of the risk of being blocked. It is their right, but to say it's not motivated by a risk of censorship is pretty disingenuous. (I have no horse in this race. I'm merely contextualizing the debate)
- manigandham 9y agoThey're not capitulating to anything... they're asking one of their customers to not break the terms of their service. Same scenario if someone was running crypto mining or bittorrent on the cloud. It's not a single company here, thousands of businesses rely on AWS and don't want their service disrupted because of Signal.
- mi100hael 9y agoAmazon has a ton of customers, at least a few of which like https://preemptivelove.org/ https://preemptivelove.org/ are also doing good things in these countries. It's not just Amazon that suffers, but Amazon's customers and everyone else downstream.
- keane 9y agoPreemptive Love is one of the most fearless organisations on the planet operating in the most dangerous places on the planet with little regard for their own safety. They constantly surprise me with the risks they are willing to take so that others might love.
- noobermin 9y agoI'm sure Amazon will be ok. They'll probably have enough money even with the loss to run the servers for that site I think.
- mi100hael 9y agoThe point is that Signal isn't the only app being used for good in such countries. Amazon's bottom line will be ok, but the customers & users who live in the censored countries will no longer be able to access other important sites hosted by Amazon.
- glenneroo 9y agoSignal was hiding behind Souq.com which is owned by Amazon.
- bscphil 9y agoI wonder if that means AWS, Google, etc oppose measures like encrypted SNI, since it's more likely to get their entire IP range banned by authoritarian governments.
- toast0 9y agoThey are more likely to oppose encrypted SNI on the grounds it's not really possible. How do you encrypt SNI for cold start? For a future connection, I could see how, but at that point you may as well simply do a resumption.
- tialaramex 9y agohttps://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-ietf-tls-sni-encryption/ https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-ietf-tls-sni-encrypti... ... is the current state of work on this problem. It's true that encryption (within the desirable parameters discussed in that ID) costs us a round trip, but it might be worth it for most of us most of the time. Keep in mind the TLS you're using today for most sites has 2RTT setup, and we put up with that (if you have a modern browser and go to some major sites you end up using TLS 1.3 draft 23 and thus 1RTT)
- toast0 9y agoModern browsers (send ALPN) to sites with decent TLS 1.2 stacks (respond to ALPN, even if it's just to say http/1.1) get a 1RTT handshake on TLS 1.2 with TLS false start. TLS 1.3 is nice, but it's not required to get 1RTT. The doc you sent is titled SNI encryption, but is really about tunneling a client hello through a proxy, and provides for the proxy to not send its own server hello, but only send the origin server's server hello. That's interesting, and should be useful for domain fronting and as a general purpose TLS proxy with fewer layers, but it's not really encrypted SNI.
- tialaramex 9y agoIn TLS False Start the client sends encrypted data to an unknown remote party. It hopes they're the intended recipient, but it won't actually know until it gets a reassuring Finished message which is too late. Now, if it isn't really the intended recipient the remote party doesn't have all the keys it should have. So cross fingers they can't decrypt the data they've been sent. But this is... less than ideal. It's a high price to pay for performance. In TLS 1.3 that 1RTT completes the handshake so as the client we know who we're taking to. That SNI draft is the result of interested parties coming up with a list of desirable properties for SNI encryption. If you have a better idea that satisfies those properties you absolutely should propose it.
- jlund 9y agoThe loss of domain fronting as a viable strategy means that it will be possible to censor Signal in areas where the service was previously working.
- manigandham 9y agoIt's a warning to not break terms of service. The strategy still works, but it's against TOS of most hosts so it was never really viable. Time to look for another option then, like any other technical challenge. I support Signal's work here but unfortunately we can't just enlist every other business to help (otherwise censorship wouldn't be much of a problem in the first place).
- tonyztan 9y ago> "unfortunately we can't just enlist every other business to help" But we should! Telex[1] and other solutions based on collateral freedom[2] have huge potential to disrupt censorship from the outside. [1] https://telex.cc https://telex.cc [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Collateral_freedom https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Collateral_freedom
- manigandham 9y agoPotential sure, but considering that unblocked companies already have access today, they effectively gain nothing by creating more friction, other than short-term disruption. It's not as simple as it sounds.
- jlund 9y ago> Time to look for another option then That's the plan. This is covered briefly in the second-to-last paragraph. > so it was never really viable Signal remained running for more than a year and a half in several countries that were actively trying to censor the service.