4 ms·
I don't understand how this works. Surely you lecturers are going to know your unique voice, your skill level and your opinions and a random essay by someone el
by chrisseaton 9y ago
I don't understand how this works. Surely you lecturers are going to know your unique voice, your skill level and your opinions and a random essay by someone else is not going to be passable as your own. Plus don't you have to discuss in seminars essays that you submit? Won't it become apparent that it's not your work when you can't defend it? Plus where do they find people skilled in the particular curriculums of every school?
- ISL 9y agoMany classes have a student/teacher ratio that makes such individual attention impractical. Furthermore, if someone is ghostwriting for you all semester, the ghostwriter's voice is the voice that the teacher knows.
- sithadmin 9y ago>if someone is ghostwriting for you all semester, the ghostwriter's voice is the voice that the teacher knows. This is also true. My agencies took care to assign repeat clients back to the same writers.
- sithadmin 9y ago>Surely you lecturers are going to know your unique voice, your skill level and your opinions and a random essay by someone else is not going to be passable as your own. In the US, the bulk of cheaters buying academic papers are in huge class sections where a majority of grading is divvied up between graduate assistants. Even if the professor strongly suspects that a student turns in a paper that isn't their own work, it's rarely worth the effort of escalating unless the paper is an obvious and provable case of plagiarism. Plagiarism is a very hard claim to prove when the paper one submits is bespoke.
- Fomite 9y agoIndeed, on occasion TAs are deliberately rotated, which has benefits, but does mean it will take them a long time to learn your "voice".
- openasocket 9y agoI'm guessing the target of this kind of service are large classes where the professor can't practically get to examine each person's essays and internalize that unique voice. Classes like that also tend to not require a lot of in-class participation, again because it isn't practical to do with a large number of students. As for finding people "skilled in the particular cirriculums," I'm guessing this is meant for some of the lower level/introductory classes where the cirriculum is going to be more or less the same everywhere.
- chrisseaton 9y ago> I'm guessing the target of this kind of service are large classes where the professor can't practically get to examine each person's essays and internalize that unique voice. They say they can write your PhD thesis for you. How on earth can that work? You'll have years of intense one-on-one tuition with an expert in the field and they're not going to notice someone wrote the thesis? How are you going to withstand several hours of viva for something you didn't write? How can the EduBird author make an original contribution to the field on demand?
- openasocket 9y agoThey can? I didn't see anything about that in the article. I've got no clue how you would pull that off
- chrisseaton 9y agohttps://uk.edubirdie.com/thesis-writing https://uk.edubirdie.com/thesis-writing
- openasocket 9y agoWow, I have no idea. I skimmed around their little review section and couldn't find anyone who wrote a full dissertation for someone, though I did find one person who apparently wrote a chapter for someone's thesis. That might be achievable, if you give them your outline and partially completed sections and they fill it in? Though it really doesn't seem worth it. I haven't written a thesis, but I imagine most of the work is in doing the actual research and creating something that furthers the state of the art, the writeup seems much easier. Though a sibling comment mentioned that this might be a complete scam, which I wouldn't doubt. Or none of their writers actually accept offers to write an entire thesis, and they just advertise the possibility of someone on their site doing it.
- whatshisface 9y agoThe lecturers don't know your voice if you've been paying a surrogate the whole time! As for the seminars, there are very few classes that involve actually defending your papers. Perhaps you'd find one at a very small school, or at a very senior level in a major with a heavy emphasis on writing. Even then, the cheater might just end up known as someone who can't speak very well but writes passable papers. (Don't just focus entirely on someone paying to fake a position as the brightest student around, that might not even be possible due to the rarity of people like that in any pool including the pool of paper-writers. You've also got to consider that someone who is not remotely qualified might pay to appear barely-competent.)
- DFHippie 9y agoIt isn't sufficient to know that the student is cheating. You have to be able to prove it. Students, particularly the amoral, entitled students who are inclined to cheat, will cause an enormous amount of trouble for the professor/TA who accuses them of cheating without incontrovertible proof. The professor may dock the student's grade in some way, but you can't really fail them if it's clear the essay was written by someone much smarter or more fluent than they are.