3 ms·
B is mis-stated in this article (and therefore in your summary): it's about whether the type of work is part of the type of business, not about the location. Th
by geofft 9y ago
B is mis-stated in this article (and therefore in your summary): it's about whether the type of work is part of the type of business, not about the location. The decision gives an explicit counterexample that a plumber fixing a bathroom in a retail store does not fail test B and still counts as an independent contractor, because even though the plumber is on aite, the retail store isn't engaged in plumbing work.
(B would be a surprising change for consultants and trainers if it were about location, but it seems to avoid that.)
- s73v3r_ 9y agoSee, I was thinking about B from the other side. If I work for a plumbing company, I'm likely not doing my plumbing in the office. So, where would my normal workplace be? I'm framing this as an argument that the plumber could be considered an employee of the plumbing company, not the retail store.
- geofft 9y agoI'm not at all qualified to read this sort of decision, but, it seems to me like if you're clearly an employee of company 2, then you're definitely neither an employee nor an independent contractor of company 1 and this test doesn't even apply. (I'm not sure if/how this breaks down if company 2 exists solely to provide people to work for company 1 and has no meaningful independent existence, which ... is probably the case for many Uber drivers now, so that's a relevant question.)
- s73v3r_ 9y agoI was thinking from the perspective of Uber for Plumbers or Pluber (TM), where there would be a dispute over whether the plumber was an employee of Pluber or not.