8 ms·
When I delete an article from my blog, it's because I don't want anyone to be able to read it anymore. Be it shame, inaccuracy, change of mood, etc... I think t
by baby 9y ago
When I delete an article from my blog, it's because I don't want anyone to be able to read it anymore. Be it shame, inaccuracy, change of mood, etc... I think there is something fundamentally wrong with wanting to have EVERYTHING backed up at all time against the creators' will.
- zeth___ 9y agoA simple solution: don't publish things you don't want people to read. This is no different to burning books that the authors no longer support the views in.
- baby 9y agoSo you're incentivizing people not to write. That's bad, we should encourage people to write. It's OK to make mistakes. I see this problem as an even bigger problem with kids. Kids put everything they do online, and they will probably be ashamed of a lot of these things later in life. Comparing that to Facebook: I guess I shouldn't upload pictures on Facebook because it's against my right to want to see one of my old picture disappear later?
- zeth___ 9y agoIf no one can read an a book what good is it? You are purposefully muddying the issue of access. If you upload your pictures on a password protected ftp server no one will know or care when you delete them. If you upload them on a publicly accessible website, despite what outdated laws on copyright say, you won't be able to withdraw them and that's a feature. Facebook is a monstrosity that pretends to be a password protected server but leaks your data by design. Do not try to equate someone unpublishing a work after they wrote, uploaded and publicized it with someone removing a drunken status update that should have never been public in the first place.
- baby 9y agoof course, but you shouldn't be stopped by people who want to backup your content at all cost against your will.
- csydas 9y ago> If no one can read an a book what good is it? Plenty of good. As a writer myself, sometimes just having these thoughts put out into form is a very gratifying process. When the inspiration hits you, nothing feels worse than not being able to express these thoughts and feelings in a way that feels appropriate. Likewise, sometimes people write dumb things in a fit of passion. They write something that is a blemish on their otherwise fine history or that no longer reflects what they believe anymore. While I'm on the side of the Internet Archive here, I can definitely appreciate that it's not an open and shut case. Sometimes the yearning for information to be free is at odds with our want for privacy. Tools like Medium, Twitter, Facebook, and other social media are like the gun in the house to someone suicidal (to use a very bad analogy) - an easy and convenient tool that allows for a very bad spur of the moment decision to be made. I know I've done stupid things on games and on message boards in the past, and I'm only so lucky that this data likely isn't available anymore. Some of it was me being a dumb kid. Some of it was me just being an angry kid, but I am 100% grateful that this information is only remember by myself and a handful of others. A very different past me had a very stringent set of beliefs which I now have come to accept were very bad beliefs, and I did bad things in general as a result of them. Is it really fair that I have the benefit that time forgot all these dumb things I've done simply because I was born before a time when Twitter/Facebook were common place? Before data permanence was really possible on a global scale? I'm open to the idea of some review on archiving data like this; I want the Internet Archive to be able to archive this stuff, but it would be really nice if there was a way to vault it for a reasonable period of time as well by request. Otherwise, you end up in a position where no one wants to write or produce or do anything in a fit of passion as a result of knowing that everything is permanently preserved. I don't have an answer aside from "vaulting" the data, and I don't think that's a good answer. But I also don't think it's black and white like you're trying to make it.
- iamnothere 9y agoI agree with the sentiment, but I'm not sure what can be done about it. Anyone can archive things privately. If you take away public archives, this means that only obsessive lunatics and the wealthy will be able to wield archived material as an instrument of power. Our culture definitely needs to evolve a little and become more forgiving of youthful ignorance. That's really the only long-term solution. Perhaps this is also a good use case for services like Hermit[1], which allows limited sharing among friends and other writers. The notion of "trying out" an idea on a platform with enormous public reach seems foolish at best. Comics test their new material in hole-in-the-wall dive bars for a good reason! [1] https://gethermit.com https://gethermit.com
- baby 9y agoI wrote a book and never published it, the only person who's read it is me.
- andai 9y ago> deleting something from the internet
- LiveOverflow 9y agoI think a difference can be made about the individual "right to be forgotten" and the transparency/accountability of a public company.
- baby 9y agopeople like you and I can write on Medium.
- Freak_NL 9y agoPeople should be encouraged to create, but with the knowledge that anything published may be retained by others, and that it can have consequences. No technological measure will prevent people from making personal backups or gaining access to data published under the presumption of secrecy or time-limited availability — even if all the layers of DRM work, the analogue hole will always be there. Rather, invest in teaching kids how to safely publish under pseudonyms or anonymously if they wish to publish their angst-ridden teenage vampire poetry. You can always abandon your connection to that work that way — even if the work lives on for all the world to see. > Comparing that to Facebook: […] You should indeed never upload anything that you might wish to expunge at a later date. You have the right to see an old picture gone from Facebook, but you don't have the means to enforce removing it from your cousin's private backup on their own computer.
- fasj82 9y ago>It's OK to make mistakes. We should punish mistakes. Especially stupid mistakes.
- parenthephobia 9y ago> It's OK to make mistakes. A sentiment that is harder to sell if people erase all evidence of their mistakes.
- azeotropic 9y agoWriting is not the same as publishing.
- PurpleBoxDragon 9y ago>So you're incentivizing people not to write. That's bad, we should encourage people to write. The publicizing of things said by then Presidential candidate Donald Trump leading up to the 2016 election would incentivize people to not talk in private. Should we have banned any details about the incident from being spread if the one who said it didn't agree with knowledge of what was said spreading? If being able to undo what you wrote so that it won't be held against you is a good thing, why wouldn't being able to undo what you said so that it won't be held against you also be a good thing?
- tothepixel 9y agoMore like incentivizing people to accept responsibility for their actions.
- khedoros1 9y ago> I guess I shouldn't upload pictures on Facebook because it's against my right to want to see one of my old picture disappear later? If think that you will ever want real control over the pictures, then yes, you should avoid posting them to Facebook. I'd think that that's fairly obvious.
- bachmeier 9y agoThat's actually pretty different. If you purchase a book, you pay for a copy with the expectation of both parties that you own that copy. Putting someone else's work on a different website and serving it to others would be similar to printing copies of someone else's books. If the author changes his views, it wouldn't be acceptable for someone else to print new copies of the book. Making a copy of a website for your own personal use would be much closer. I don't think anyone disagrees that you should be able to do that.
- zeth___ 9y ago>If the author changes his views, it wouldn't be acceptable for someone else to print new copies of the book. When the author burns their own book and forbids new ones from being made is the only time that it's acceptable to print new copies. Need I remind you of the purpose of copyright? >To promote the progress of science and useful arts, by securing for limited times to authors and inventors the exclusive right to their respective writings and discoveries.
- foldr 9y ago>When the author burns their own book and forbids new ones from being made is the only time that it's acceptable to print new copies. Do you mean acceptable from a legal point of view? Because I seriously doubt that it is.
- OrganicMSG 9y agoWithout that view, we wouldn't have most of the works by Kafka.
- foldr 9y agoNo, the only issue raised by Kafka's request to burn his papers is whether or not the copyright passed to someone else on his death. All works eventually become public domain, regardless of the author's wishes, since people die and copyright has a time limit.
- pmlnr 9y agoI both agree and disagree. Yes, definitely think before publishing, even if it's meant to be "private", say a self-destructing private message, because anything can be saved somehow. On the other side, we change. Things that were relevant to me, things I genuinely thought to be true 16-18 years ago (I had a blog for a while now), I see a bit differently today, and I might like my current, tuned back views to be read, not the ancient ones from a disappointed teenager.
- gnode 9y agoAs I mentioned in a top-level comment, you can use robots.txt to disable Internet Archive's (Wayback Machine) archiving of your site. If you dislike your site being archived, I suggest you do this. Their intention is not to be a monster of the Internet who embarrass creators against their will.
- fiddlerwoaroof 9y agoThis is a major issue with the internet archive because it allows subsequent owners of a domain to blackhole the previous content.
- gnode 9y agoOne solution to this might be to maintain separate archives when a domain changes ownership, based on WHOIS information. Previous owners could still request deletion via email as is currently possible.
- djsumdog 9y agoI really like this post: http://archive.li/fi5Xn http://archive.li/fi5Xn It's been deleted by its author and archive sites are the only places where I can find copies. I've saved a copy for myself just in case. If you use an article like this as a source, it'd be nice if there were a copy somewhere. This is one of my favourite independent movies: https://www.imdb.com/title/tt1527628 https://www.imdb.com/title/tt1527628 I bought a DRM-free copy from the writer/director back when they offered it on their website. The main website is still there, but the whole purchase/download system is broken and those domain seem to have expired/been purchased by someone else. I almost lost my copy of this movie, but luckily I found it on one of my off-site backups. People talk about how much content there is being created, but there's an incredibly amount of content that's being lost forever. Even if it's still out there, search monoculture (today we have Google/Bing/DDG where once we had Lycos, Hotbot, Altavisa, etc. etc.) can effectively keep content from being accessible. There might be something nice about the ephemeral nature of that content, but there's also something sad there as well. To go back to your point, if someone publishes an article, it is nice to be able to see it again in the future. If they don't want it backed up, there are procedures like DMCA (if the author didn't publish the content to the public domain and the archiver is based in the US). As a side note, we've already seen on here that the Right to be Forgotten is more about censorship than anything else. Eventually we'll all go extinct, our sun will burn out, and everything that ever was and is will be lost. So preservation efforts really only go so far, and this brings up some more deep philosophical ideals about the ephemeral nature of what we produce more than anything else.
- tempodox 9y agoThank you for the article link. If anything, it has only become more relevant by now. Do you know why the original has been deleted?
- nbeleski 9y agoThis is an interesting article, if you liked I would reccomend heavily taking a look at Nick Bostrom's Superintelligence. Even though the book has it's own share of problems, it is an interesting approach to Artificial General Intelligence. On the other points, I would believe this is related to the fact I personally (and I take most here) have spent way too much time on the internet on the past decade(s). I find it amusing the number of times I remember something I've seen or read in the past and how hard it can be to find it again. Or the number of broken links among old blog posts and articles. Lastly, our lives are way too goddamn short. Thinking that far into the future is hardly productive in my opinion, even if you consider it can be very enlightening.
- bufferoverflow 9y agoWhen you published your article though, you wanted people to read it. You can't blame the people around you for changing your mind. And "nothing gets deleted on the internet".
- baby 9y agoI won't blame people for storing a private copy, but I will blame people for sharing such copy if it is against my will, especially if they're claiming it is their right and thus my integrity has to suffer.
- monoch 9y agoYou are breaking the social contract of copyright when trying to use it as a tool of censorship. The whole underlying rationale for modern copyright was spelled out in the first country to adopt it: >To promote the progress of science and useful arts, by securing for limited times to authors and inventors the exclusive right to their respective writings and discoveries. We, the people, trade our natural right of copying and selling anything we see for the benefit of increased dissemination of art and science. Your integrity is kept perfectly pristine if your work only stays in your draw. The second you publish your work it is no longer yours.
- sgwilliams 9y agoWhat social contract? Technically, archive.org is in violation of copyright. It does not matter if robots.txt allows it or not. Pointing people to "content" like a search engine is fine. Displaying "content" on another website is not. Even worse is nyud.net, which essentially steals credit.
- OrganicMSG 9y agoIt is the right of all librarians.
- pavel_lishin 9y ago> and thus my integrity has to suffer. What sort of integrity is it, that can be adjusted by erasing your past actions, to hide the mistakes you've made and only present the successes?
- swebs 9y agoYes, I think that's pretty obvious. This is an issue of the public's interest vs the author's interest. Of course anyone would like to rewrite history to suit themselves. It does a disservice to everyone else however. "We were always at war with East Asia" and all that.
- sarabande 9y agoSounds like you need the GDPR's "Right to be Forgotten" clause to be in effect.
- drchaos 9y agoThe GDPR only cares about personally identifying information. So you might be able to ask me to remove your name from the archived blog post, but not the post itself (as long as it does not contain other PII). This is very important, as otherwise someone could vandalize Wikipedia or Github by requiring them to delete all his edits/commits.
- OrganicMSG 9y agoAnything you have ever published is no longer entirely yours and the act of doing so is also a relinquishment of control. Only secrets can ever really be regarded as possessions. Archivists should not require permission to store that which has been put out into the world.
- chx 9y ago> Anything you have ever published is no longer entirely yours and the act of doing so is also a relinquishment of control. This is an incredibly bold and huge presumption which absolutely does not mesh with the Berne Convention to begin with.
- OrganicMSG 9y agoIt meshes well with reality though.
- emddudley 9y agoIt meshes perfectly fine. You don't give up all control but you do give up a lot of control. When you publish and sell a book, you no longer control who that book is later given or sold to. You retain only rights over the ability to make copies, and even then, you can't block people from making copies for personal use.
- ekianjo 9y ago> When I delete an article from my blog It's not yours anymore once it's public. It's like saying "when I do something crazy in public I want to be able to make everyone forget about it later on". That's not how things are supposed to work. > I don't want anyone to be able to read it anymore People can still have local copies so you have absolutely NO CONTROL.
- a3_nm 9y ago> People can still have local copies Yes, but under current copyright laws they are not allowed to distribute them without your consent.
- ekianjo 9y agoThat's not the point. The OP mentioned he wanted to make sure nobody can read it anymore. Private copies prevent that scenario.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- djsumdog 9y agoDepending on the license. If you have a CC-BY-SA or public domain at the bottom, then you're allowing people a legal right to keep a copy. In practice, the nature of the web allows everyone to keep copies of everything if they want. But if someone republishes it, then you need to use the DMCA process (for American websites) to take that content down if it violates copyright. Going back to print, what if you print something you don't want out there anymore? Well if people have already bought your book or magazine, they have bought a right to that physical copy. They can even sell the book or magazine to anyone else (granted that the content isn't illegal).
- danso 9y agoBut they can't make copies of their bought copy and distribute those, which is akin to what the Internet Archive does.
- waydowntogo 9y agoMainly problem with any services is privacy. There's no privacy on internet. If you have a blog you have to count with fact that an article will be on internet forever. My advice is this - write an article today but publish it tomorrow (you'll have time for thinking about an article).
- coldacid 9y agoAnd I'd add to that advice: Never be afraid to add corrections and show them.
- paulie_a 9y agoSuck it up. Once you go out of your way to make something public...it will remain public
- logfromblammo 9y agoI'm not sure you understand that putting something on an http server is publication. It is legally no different than standing on a street corner handing out flyers. You are suggesting that the author of a flyer should be able to demand that everyone who took one burn it immediately, and have the force of law to ensure it happens. That is not how copyright works. Copyright is intended to encourage the creation of new works, by granting for a limited time the exclusive right for an author to reproduce and copy their own works. Once those copies exist, and pass out of the author's possession, copyright does not grant any further control of them, other than to forbid those copies to be used to produce additional copies. This, of course, raises the question of whether serving a digital document on an http archive server is violating the author's copyrights. A library may keep a copy of a pamphlet and allow patrons to view it without violating copyright. But web servers work by stamping out a perfect copy of the document and sending it out over the network. There is no physical embodiment of the document. If the archive were to display the document on a monitor, and then serve a video from a camera, pointed at that monitor, that would be analogous to viewing the physical copy of the pamphlet, but then that pointless fiction could be dispensed with by removing the monitor and camera and transmitting the digital rendering. So we have to fall back on the intent of the copyright act. Clearly, the copyright act is intended to expand the amount of available works, by granting a temporarily profitable monopoly. Does the prevention of archiving further this purpose? Hell no. Archiving is essential for those works to eventually enter the public domain. When the original creator of a work has abandoned their attempt to monetize their efforts, to the point where they are now trying to destroy their work, it should escheat to the public domain immediately. If you didn't want it out there, the only remedy would have been to never publish it. You cannot erase prior publications by abusing copyrights. The law should not protect book-burners.
- chipotle_coyote 9y ago> It is legally no different than standing on a street corner handing out flyers. It's not legally different, but it's still different, which is something that I think people on both sides of this debate sometimes selectively forget. Before the web, those "street flyers" were pretty unlikely to go viral and be seen by millions of people. They were pretty unlikely to get, well, much farther than that street corner. And there certainly wasn't a widely-known and shared infrastructure dedicated to capturing copies of the flyer and preserving them indefinitely. I don't know that there should be a "right to forget," but in the pre-digital era, things had limited circulation. They went out of print. You couldn't control what happened to copies after they were printed, no, but nobody could say, "You know what, I don't want this thing to go out of print, so I'm going to put it back into print whether the author likes it or not." To use your flyer example: I can't legally demand people who have my flyer burn it, but I can legally demand that people don't make copies of my flyer and hand it out on street corners of their choice for the next thirty years. The closest thing the web has to the concept of "out of print" is, well, taking things offline. And a lot of things that go offline undoubtedly should be preserved. I use the Internet Archive all the time. But at the same time, I'm not convinced that the answer to someone saying, "Hey, this thing I put online 20 years ago and took down 10 years ago is something I'd really like to keep out of print" must always and forever be, "well, you should never put anything online that you'll ever reconsider at any point in your entire life, you fool."
- seiferteric 9y agoWhy not publish a retraction and list the reasons why you no longer think the post is correct instead of trying to hide from it? Maybe someone will learn something that way...
- baby 9y agoWhy not just erase it.