6 ms·
I think A and B present a difficult challenge for Uber/Lyft. Drivers do not have the freedom to control how to perform their services. They do have some leeway
by gnicholas 9y ago
I think A and B present a difficult challenge for Uber/Lyft. Drivers do not have the freedom to control how to perform their services. They do have some leeway in route, but not total leeway. And there are many guidelines they have to abide regarding the condition of their vehicle and treatment of passengers.
Element B is a little less clear, but I think it would be difficult for Uber/Lyft to overcome. Drivers would argue that the normal workplace is actually the streets. Uber/Lyft could of course argue that it's HQ, but given the number of drives on the street and the number of employees at HQ, this is no slam-dunk for the companies.
Background: I am a (former) lawyer who worked on employee/contractor issues in the realm of tax law (which uses different tests than state law).
- rdiddly 9y agoAlso the drivers aren't supplying a service "outside the business's normal variety." They're supplying the core Uber service. EDIT: They might be able to redefine themselves as purely a software company for the drivers to remain contractors.
- icebraining 9y agoIt says "... or workplace". Uber drivers don't work in Uber's buildings.
- AstralStorm 9y agoThis is not quite an exclusive or. The service is not outside of business standard variety. Other cab companies have client driven matchmaking systems too now... They also employ office workers. The workplace for a cab driver is his car. Therefore, what Uber does would make them a cab company that abuses contractors instead of employing employees. However, the key point here is the test A. If Uber is specifically telling the drivers to pick up specific fares or otherwise forcing them to pick up fares beyond the number and/or time, they are actually employees not contractors. Fudging with scoring system to fire those who do not follow such orders indirectly could be construed as such as well.
- icebraining 9y agoConsidering the actual text posted by jaggederest in another comment, it does seem to be an exclusive or: "the services provided were either outside the usual course of business or performed outside of all the places of business of the enterprise" Regarding other cab companies, most cab drivers have been traditionally classified as contractors. The idea that Uber introduced this practice is propaganda.
- Normal_gaussian 9y agoThat isn't an exclusive or; the English language lets that be interpreted as either an xor or or, and the reasoning of the context shows it to be an or. To iterate; the statement sets out two conditions, either of which are sufficient independent of the other, and claims that each of a number of services met one of those conditions.
- icebraining 9y agoThanks, I'm not a native speaker, and I thought either/or was a xor.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- woqe 9y agoI think there is valid confusion to be had in interpreting this statement. Usually, when a statement of "choose either x or y" is made, then the only valid options are exclusively x or exclusively y (None and Both are not valid). Though, when the statement of "if either x or y then do action" is made, then the action is done with any of three valid options: x, y, or x and y (only None is not valid). To change the second statement to mean the first, you could say "if only x or only y then do action." The "only" cancel Both as being an option.
- kbutler 9y agoNative speaker here. Either-or does imply exclusive-or, but it is often used less formally, so you will sometimes see it made explicit as "either x or y, but not both."
- apendleton 9y agoWell, I suppose Uber would argue that their service isn't the providing if rides, but rather, the matchmaking of independent ride providers to prospective customers, and facilitation of payment. (Not that we should believe them.)
- fauigerzigerk 9y agoThat would be difficult to reconcile with a self-driving car project (unless they didn't own or operate those cars themselves).
- exelius 9y agoI think a distributed ownership model is actually the most likely model for self-driving cars given the capital investment required.
- briandear 9y agoSo are property owners employees of AirBnB?
- pseudalopex 9y agoProperty owners set their own rates and don't get detailed directions from Airbnb for each stay.
- mattmanser 9y agoThey're just providing a free GPS, it's not a core part of the business. Even the rates thing isn't particularly compelling, the drivers can decide which sort of jobs to take, normal, high, etc. it's not like they have set shift patterns or anything.
- s73v3r_ 9y agoI find the rates thing quite compelling. Uber/Lyft are dictating the prices. Drivers have no say in them. And, while you can technically decline rides, the Uber/Lyft algorithms will punish you for doing so.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- hardwaresofton 9y agoI agree with your assessment (you failed to mention leeway with which rides to take, but maybe it doesn't matter) -- Uber/Lyft would definitely not want to lose control on how their drivers perform their services since it's directly counter to part of their value proposition/brand. I pessimistically assume, however, is that assuming the A/B fight is a lost battle for gig economy compnaies, the next step is to limit these employees to being part-time with some kind of <20 hours per week or something rule. Background: I am a spitballing layman
- gnicholas 9y ago> I pessimistically assume, however, is that assuming the A/B fight is a lost battle for gig economy companies, the next step is to limit these employees to being part-time with some kind of <20 hours per week or something rule. How does 20 hrs/week factor in here? I didn't see a reference in the Bloomberg article. Though this is actually a good point — if time spent working isn't a factor, then someone who works for Uber, Lyft, Grubhub, and Google Express could end up as en employee of all of these companies. That seems like kind of a weird result.
- hardwaresofton 9y agoI mentioned that since hours worked is normally a big distinction between a "full time" employee and "part time" employee for traditional roles, which have different employment costs -- It's not mentioned in the article
- e40 9y agoPart-time workers don't usually get benefits, which is the main reason Uber is terrified they'll be classified as employees. Walmart used the part-time distinction to great effect to increase their profits and decrease workers wages. Much has been written about this.
- tlrobinson 9y agoNot a lawyer, but I would think they could require drivers follow a reasonably direct route but not require the specific route offered by the driver’s app. And in general quality issues can be handled by ratings. If a driver takes bad routes or has a dirty car they’re going to get complaints / bad ratings. I’d be surprised if they couldn’t offer drivers “suggestions” on how to receive good ratings.
- geofft 9y agoPlease read the decision re B (starting at page 64 of http://src.bna.com/ypI)—if http://src.bna.com/ypI)—if I'm not misreading it, it has nothing to do with work location and the article is confused. But I am not a lawyer and would appreciate your reading if it :) My guess is that B comes down firmly on the side of Uber/Lyft drivers being employees, unless they can convince a judge that their business is merely "providing an app that lets people find car companies" and not "giving people rides."
- jawns 9y agoYes, "providing an app that lets people find independent contractors who give people rides" is what Uber/Lyft will argue. And there are a host of companies that offer similar services. They derive their value from being able to facilitate business interactions. Angie's List is another example, and I can totally see similar businesses passing the "B" part of the test, because although they may implement some quality-control measures, such as requiring the independent contractors to abide by certain terms or meet certain standards, they are pretty hands-off in terms of HOW the recommended plumber fixes the clogged drain, or HOW the recommended carpet cleaner schedules its appointments. But with Uber/Lyft, the HOW is much more like an employee relationship.
- Retric 9y agoThe problem with that argument is Uber will kick people off the platform. They manage the relationship between customers and drivers instead of simply facilitating communication and payment. By comparison most point of sale (POS) venders just provide hardware and software don't involve themselves in the actual business enough though they may provide phone apps etc. Marketplaces like App stores or Amazon get more involved, but they don't dictate prices.
- sgustard 9y agoBeing an app company and not a company that gives rides is a strange rationale for investing in self-driving cars. Will the robots be considered independent actors too?
- geofft 9y ago
- johan_larson 9y agoI guess the question is whether the companies can allow the drivers enough freedom to make them contractors, while still retaining enough control to maintain service standards. Letting the drivers set their own prices, perhaps through some sort of bidding system, might go a long way.
- Veelox 9y agoI think that Uber/Lyft could pretty easily argue A. The driver has control over the quality/cleanliness of the car, amount of conversation, extra perks provided, and timeliness of arrival. While I agree element B would be difficult for them to overcome I would give it around 50/50 that they can successfully argue the drivers are not a part of the normal workplace.
- s73v3r_ 9y agoGiven that the job is "giving rides to other people in your car," how would B not apply?
- Veelox 9y agoThe normal Uber workplace is the office where the app is developed, drivers never visit so they are not part of the normal work place. That argument or some other one that is equally dumb on it's face but might work in a court of law
- s73v3r_ 9y agoI completely disagree. The normal Uber workplace for developers is the office. How many of the drivers do you think have ever set foot in that office? To put it another way, if you're a plumber who is working for a plumbing company, are you doing your plumbing in the office?
- Veelox 9y ago> That argument or some other one that is equally dumb on it's face but might work in a court of law > equally dumb I was defending why I think there is a 50% shot that Uber could make part B not apply. It seems like you think it is more like a 1% shot which you might be right, I am not a lawyer.
- s73v3r_ 9y agoAgreed. If I work for a plumbing company, where is my normal workplace?
- MR4D 9y agoUber? What about the Post Office?? This is going to create an interesting situation for the supremacy clause.