5 ms·
The article answers its own question with this bit -- "Yet grant-writing experts universally stress that proposals should be built around hypotheses and warn th
by ChuckMcM 9y ago
The article answers its own question with this bit -- "Yet grant-writing experts universally stress that proposals should be built around hypotheses and warn that those not written this way risk rejection as “fishing expeditions.”
"Fishing Expedition" is code for a project that spends a bunch of money and has no tangible result. Typically that is called wasted money. When you have a patron that wants you go out and follow your curiosity, where ever it might lead, that is great. But if you're spending the tax payer's dollar, the folks who gave it to you have to explain to the congressional budget office why they gave it to you and what they hoped to achieve by giving it to you.
The easiest way to express that value proposition is with a hypothesis statement. Building equipment that is known to work (like the Hubble) doesn't require a hypothesis, it requires a credible statement that it will be able to do something that other equipment cannot. Or that you could not build the same capability in a different more cost effective way.
- gowld 9y agoThe Space Program has CBO-friendly reason for existing (beat the Russkies to the moon), but 99% of its value was unrelated to that reason. AT&T invented huge swaths of technology motivated simply by something valuable would come own of free-range research. PhDs and tenured professors do the same, usually when their research area happens to be inexpensive. Maybe flimflamming and petty rivalries are not the best justification for basic science?
- twblalock 9y ago> Maybe flimflamming and petty rivalries are not the best justification for basic science? Getting value for taxpayer money is not flimflamming, and it's not petty. There are a lot of good things to spend that money on, and if scientists want a piece of it they should provide a convincing justification.
- ThomPete 9y agoBasic research in hard sciences is a justification in itself. Maybe drop doing phds in social sciences and humanities and use only for hard sciences is getting value for taxpayer money?
- forapurpose 9y agoSTEM problems are better defined by their nature, which makes them more appealing - they are easier to see and understand, both the problems and solutions. In business, I find people frequently make the mistake of latching onto well-defined, easy-to-measure distractions, rather than the actual problem at hand which is frustratingly hard to measure and which will never have a clear solution. Social sciences and humanities are hard to measure, but they are often the most important problems: Peace and war; prosperity and opportunity; truth, freedom and justice; politics and policy. I'll observe that the problems of the world today aren't due to a lack of technology - we're doing very well with that - but to the very problems addressed by humanities and social sciences. (And perhaps that's not unrelated to the shift in focus from those fields to technology in recent decades.) Here's an alternative perspective: STEM only allows precisely-measured problems; if you can't measure it, it's not STEM. Arguably, STEM is taking the low-hanging fruit and leaving the hard stuff, the problems you can't measure but which absolutely must be solved, to the other fields. EDIT: Major revision; sorry if you read the first version.
- ThomPete 9y agoThey are "less" valuable in a couple of ways. 1) They often aren't that predictable and highly depending on cultural norms i.e. more or less anything goes for a study or a report and the standards that are in place just doesn't produce as much value to society compared to how much we spend on it IMO. 2) They even more often aren't actually re-producable but are rather pop-scientific studies that are more based on personal interpretation than any reproducible results. 2) They can often be studied on your own without need for guidance that can't be solved in a self study. (We are at a point were I would argue most humanities and social sciences doesn't actually need a university to happen on. Plenty of available knowledge for that today online and in various foras. 3) They don't produce value for society that can be reproduced by society, instead they are used often for political reasons or based on biases we have already that can't be tested. Don't get me wrong, philosophy, social sciences, psychology etc all have an important role to play in society, but they do not need to be PHD's IMO. For the most cases they aren't rigorous enough which amongst other things is because they are more often than not coming from disciplines where the actual scientific rigor that is required to say anything along the lines of "we know". Not sure in what way you think social sciences and humanities help solve those problems. In what way can we rely on those fields (rather than our own independent thinking) to "solve" the problems that you claim we have? Most problems we have are solved (and created) by technology and most problems that technology can't solve neither social sciences nor humanities at large can solve (there are obvious exceptions)
- mannykannot 9y agoIf you are doing research, you cannot, by definition, put a firm value on it beforehand. At best, with applied research, you can estimate a loose upper bound in the case of it being successful. Without exploratory science, we would not even have the basis to make hypotheses.
- rhizome 9y agoBasic research never makes a good case for being a profit center.
- kevhito 9y agoBeing charitable, I think the parent wasn't saying it should be. But even in some fantasy ideal-government world, the budget is finite and zero-sum. By giving money to some fishing expedition with no clear expectation of any result, we are taking it from some other use.
- coffeemug 9y ago> There are a lot of good things to spend that money on, and if scientists want a piece of it they should provide a convincing justification. But that's not the right way to frame it. We have some amount of money to spend, and we need to figure out how to deploy it. We know that in aggregate basic research has resulted in astronomical payoffs over time. Therefore it's in our interest to put money into basic research. It's not the scientists who should provide convincing justification on why they deserve our money. It's us who should provide convincing justification why more people should become scientists.
- maxlybbert 9y agoIf two basic research teams ask for a grant, assuming we only have money to fund one, how do we choose?
- coffeemug 9y agoI don't know, but I think it's an extraordinarily important question.
- perl4ever 9y agoHow can the problem of limited resources to support scientists be improved by increasing the number of scientists?
- coffeemug 9y agoI meant that separately. As in, we should encourage more people to become scientists and increase science funding. But for any given amount of funding we still have to pick how to allocate the money, which seems like a very important problem to solve to me.
- perl4ever 9y agoIf you say "all basic research is good and needs no justification", you can't thereby get rid of the threshold for what gets funded. You're just refusing to talk about what the criteria may be and what they should be.
- paxy 9y agoThe problem with that is that when you propose a hypothesis and someone pays you to prove it, anything other than a positive result is also considered wasted money. This is the reason why we have all the paid-for junk science out there today.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoAt least the grants I am directly aware of there was no pressure to 'confirm' the hypothesis, on the individual researcher they may have felt they wouldn't get a paper out of it if it didn't confirm but the grant was written to the experiment proposal and experimental controls.
- protomyth 9y agoFor the non-STEM (e.g. social) research grants there always seemed to be a bit of a nudge to get the hypothesis confirmed because it was often political (government) or purpose driven (NGO or patron). I sometimes have wondered if the same dynamic had crept into STEM research grants.
- dnautics 9y agoPerhaps we should have more of these: > When you have a patron that wants you go out and follow your curiosity, where ever it might lead, that is great.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoI think it would be really useful. And if the giving pledge is real, it seems plausible that a couple of hundred million might be pledged for "pure science"