6 ms·
"Cronin’s YouTube channel was up to about 22,000 subscribers when he received a notice from YouTube about one of his videos, “Relax and Improve Your Sleep with
by jerf 9y ago
"Cronin’s YouTube channel was up to about 22,000 subscribers when he received a notice from YouTube about one of his videos, “Relax and Improve Your Sleep with Natural Calm Magnesium.” The notice said the video had been removed for violating YouTube’s community guidelines, but didn’t specify further."
Magnesium isn't even a nootropic. That is, while it may have some ability to boost cognition, it isn't a substance primarily ingested for that reason. It is a substance primarily ingested so that the person ingesting it will stay alive.
A quick cruise around Duck Duck Go suggests that while science isn't saying you should use magnesium for sleep per se, it isn't necessarily a crazy idea in desperate need of being censored. Certainly the idea that magnesium is generally deficient is widespread, with estimates around 50% not meeting the US RDA for magnesium in the US, and while magnesium may not be a good solution for insomnia qua insomnia, it can be a good solution for many things that may be causing you to be "unable to sleep"[1], whether or not that is "insomnia".
[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnesium_deficiency_(medicine)#Signs_and_symptoms https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnesium_deficiency_(medicine...
- jrhurst 9y agoProblem is medical claims are highly regulated in the West. So there is a likely legal liability for youtube in the US and in the UK. In fact, they might have already had pressure from regulators.
- jerf 9y agoThat would make sense. It would help if YouTube would say so. I'm not sure Google's usual total opacity is going to play to their favor here. As I said in another comment, I personally see no reason to trust their judgment in these matters, but if they said "Hey, we're getting regulatory pressure from X about Y and we need to remove your stuff" that would be a step in the direction of restoring my trust. (I've got other reasons I'm very unlikely to ever trust them very much overall, but I am capable of nuance, so I have no problem saying I would at least trust them more.)
- vertexFarm 9y ago“Nothing illegal, no medical advice offered, I've always been incredibly careful about this.” The article then goes on to name several videos with titles like "increase energy," "improve concentration and memory," "improve sleep," etc. Are there any lawyers around who know of a legal definition for "medical advice" or "medical claims?" Because these videos sound a lot like medical advice despite his insistence that they aren't. Youtube censorship sucks sometimes, but this guy experimenting on himself is not nearly rigorous enough to figure out what's really happening when he is taking these supplements. When a person sets out to improve themselves with drugs, test the process on themselves, and interpret and analyze those results themselves, it's a viper's pit of biases. Obviously the experimenter has a huge personal stake in the experiment (arguably the largest; his person is the experiment!) and that generally is great for motivation but bad for science. I like playing with nootropics but I'm also relatively healthy and I can't imagine how damaging it might be for a seriously ill person who is taking advice from youtube in a desperate and futile attempt to improve their condition and survive. The ethics are pretty complex, above my pay grade for sure.
- stevecronin 9y agoWhile I disagree that the titles are medical advice, I do see your point. It's funny because actually my YouTube mentor suggested use titles like that so people who didn't know what the products were could get an idea for what they were used for. I still made disclaimers in my videos.
- Bartweiss 9y ago> a legal definition for "medical advice" If you're talking about the FDA, the basic rule is that you can't claim a product treats or cures any diagnosable condition it hasn't been certified for. Claims like "improve concentration" and "improve sleep" are generally permissible, where specific statements like "helps with ADD" and "cures insomnia" are not. Based on those video titles, I don't see anything which constitutes medical advice in the narrow sense. Someone could well have decided the overall effect was tacit medical advice, but these titles in isolation aren't clear violations.
- driverdan 9y ago
- swirepe 9y agoDid you know that Pepsi is made from dead babies? I didn't, before YouTube [1]. It turns out you can say almost anything you want on video without it being a legal issue. I don't think regulators care about this small-time stuff. [1]: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=d72KsFEenz8 https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=d72KsFEenz8
- warent 9y agoAbsolutely bogus. I just spent 30 minutes verifying this claim. They used HEK 293 cells combined with taste receptors as a tool in the development of a totally unrelated molecule by Senomyx called Sweetmyx. Sweetmyx has zero embryo cells in it. The embryo cells were used to test how the human taste receptors would respond to Sweetmyx. https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/senomyxed-messages/ https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/senomyxed-messages/
- swirepe 9y agoYes, it is bogus. That's the point, actually. You can just say whatever bogus stuff you want on YouTube.
- haZard_OS 9y agogroan I actually had to address that claim during a lecture once. Ridiculous. For the record, I think anyone peddling pseudoscience regarding medical conditions should be shutdown hard and fast. People who suffer from chronic pain or incurable illness can become desperate and turn to charlatans whose snake-oil can produce terrible effects. It isn't harmless to prey on such insecurities. http://whatstheharm.net/ http://whatstheharm.net/
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- zxcmx 9y agoI think this is tricky because as soon as you shut down the obvious stuff (ok, dead babies...) you will quickly arrive at barely or non provable stuff, acai berry level things, and medical claims (fructose intolerance! real thing btw!) which you are going to need a phd to sort out. I am not sure how youtube or any general content site could realistically be expected to have a policy on all these things. You can't eradicate the nonsense you can just change its nature. In some ways I think having complete nonsense out there is healthy in terms of promoting skepticism amongst normal people.
- dghughes 9y agoMeanwhile MontrealHealthyGirls' YouTube channel is far worse. Her cancer and diabetes "cures" she's downright dangerous, and nuts.
- corobo 9y agoHave you reported the channel?
- dghughes 9y agoYes, often. And the same for Twitter. I don't understand how she keeps escaping being shutdown or even arrested. The Canadian government just banned a Naturopath product with actual rabies saliva in it which was used to treat children. At least there's progress.
- serf 9y ago>Problem is medical claims are highly regulated in the West. so highly regulated that I can buy a one-time dose vial of mystery liquid at my local liquor store that promises harder erections and improved cognition, without the active ingredients printed anywhere. If this was triggered by pressure from any group like the FDA, i'd sure be curious why they decided to start regulating medical woo-woo at the YouTube level, and not at the "homeopath that can cure any cancer" level, which is totally prevalent in the U.S. When I had a commute I used to count the car windshield banner stickers that advertised the sale of miracle juices, berrys, extracts, whatever. Those 'Avon-esque' pyramid schemes are dangerous from both sides -- both for suckers that get pulled in as sellers , and for the folks consuming the stuff hoping to cure colon cancer, but that stuff is still as prevalent as ever.. When, exactly, does western medical regulation kick in? It seems to be when you're making lots of money on-shore.
- stevecronin 9y agoI always made it very clear not to make medical claims.
- dbasedweeb 9y agoRelax and Improve Your Sleep with Natural Calm Magnesium If that’s your version of very clear, maybe you shouldn’t be giving people advice.
- stevecronin 9y agoSo does adding a question mark at the end of the title fit your position? It's a title and you did not watch the video, it's the same when you buy that product at whole foods and the label says something, then you turn it over to see it's not medical advice.
- jmcqk6 9y agoHere is how you can state it without ambiguity: Learn how magnesium may relax and improve your sleep
- girvo 9y agoY’know, he’s right: that’s technically not a medical claim, it’s a “non-functional” claim. Of course, I also get what you mean; to you and I, that looks exactly like a medical claim! The regulations for all this are slightly mental, which is why things like homeopathy and those bullshit “skinny tea” pyramid schemes survive
- chillingeffect 9y agoreally? https://duckduckgo.com/?q=magnesium+sleep+research&t=ffsb&ia=web https://duckduckgo.com/?q=magnesium+sleep+research&t=ffsb&ia... First result: The effect of magnesium supplementation on primary insomnia in elderly: A double-blind placebo-controlled clinical trial. CONCLUSION: Supplementation of magnesium appears to improve subjective measures of insomnia such as ISI score, sleep efficiency, sleep time and sleep onset latency, early morning awakening, and likewise, insomnia objective measures such as concentration of serum renin, melatonin, and serum cortisol, in elderly people. btw I was a fan of Steve Cronin's channel and of reddit's nootropics subreddit. Steve's stuff was hardly experimental. Lots of this stuff is heavily researched. Youtube probably has input from Big Pharma. What's next, eliminating smoothy and juicing videos? Vegan recipes? Will they let themselves become a perfect shady of the corporate lifestyle?
- PaulHoule 9y agoI've found that magnesium helps my sleep, particularly the cheaper forms. The more expensive chelated forms seem to do less for me.
- ebbv 9y agoThe placebo effect is a real effect
- girvo 9y agoIndeed, and I find my zinc/magnesium tablets an excellent way to induce it. I also find my 3000IU of vitamin D excellent in the other direction, for waking me up. Quite probably they’re both placebo, but it works, is safe in the amounts I take, and is cheap :)
- stevecronin 9y agoThank you
- chillingeffect 9y ago
- otakucode 9y agoYouTube isn't going after 'crazy idea[s] in need of being censored.' They're going after anything they can to shut down as many small channels as they can. Their end goal is a situation akin to traditional TV networks. Far less variety, very much walled off from participation, and much more centralized. This will enable Eric Schmidt and his colleagues to exercise much more control over human culture. He explained that Google has a responsibility to manipulate human culture in his book "The New Digital Age." They are rich, and as such, better. As far as he is concerned, protecting the masses from themselves is his duty and responsibility.
- JackCh 9y agoI think this may be a case where the truth is difficult for the general public to believe because it sounds too "conspiratorial".
- AnimalMuppet 9y agoNo, I don't believe it because it sounds like a really stupid idea. YouTube isn't going to have much less variety, because YouTube makes money by selling ads to viewers, and they're going to have a significant number fewer viewers if they try to do that. And I suspect that they want to make money even more than they want to reshape the culture into the image of what they think it should be...
- serf 9y agoI don't believe this idea, but allow me to play devil's advocate. >And I suspect that they want to make money even more than they want to reshape the culture into the image of what they think it should be... Groups often do this to secure future profits at the cost of current profits. It would be to the advantage of YT to reduce costs by funneling as many users as they can to the same result, allowing for the reduction of dynamic elements within their structure. It could be that they are juggling total lost customers with a total cost of operation and trying to achieve a more profitable ratio with cheaper/easier to substantiate channels/results tl;dr : Google would be cheaper to run if there were only 20 results. Google would be #1 if they could keep their current audience happy with that style of operation, due to the disparity in income versus outward expenses. Maybe some group of psychologists is discussing what channels to bar next that won't hurt the bottom line... (but, like I said in the beginning , I doubt it very much -- it's just a fun exercise to imagine why they would want to destroy content)
- Barrin92 9y ago>while science isn't saying you should use magnesium for sleep per se, it isn't necessarily a crazy idea taking nutritional supplements without any evidence that they accomplish anything useful and without a physician's advice is generally a bad idea (the default mode is not 'take until suggested otherwise' but 'only take if necessary'), and trying to make money off it by marketing them on youtube is even more miserable. I'm very much in favour of youtube taking a proactive stance here. As a related note on nootropics, most of the products advertised under that label don't actually do anything at all. There's two very well known nootropics, caffeine and nicotine. So the next time someone tries to sell you weird nutrition supplements, just get a good old cup of coffee.
- stevecronin 9y agoIt was really just my intent to share my experience, and I wasn't selling the magnesium.
- walshemj 9y agoExactly last Autumn I was in a renal clinic recovering from surgery. One of the patents on my ward was an OAP who had been taking a lot of Zinc which reacted with the meds he was on and it Totally shut down his Kidneys FFS.
- thenergo 9y agotherefore consuming a lot zinc totally shuts down your kidneys... or maybe you have a sample size of one?
- walshemj 9y agoIt was recklessly consuming vast amounts of "supplements" that did it. You want to try risking total renal failure go ahead - or are you a pusher with no concern for your punters health. Btw they put you on the transplant list way before you get to this point which this person did to himself.
- jimrandomh 9y ago
- stevecronin 9y agoThanks for sharing this article. I was shocked when they removed my channel for things like this.
- ebbv 9y agoIt’s not censoring of ideas. It’s removing video ads for quackery that is probably illegal under strict reading of US law. YouTube is on borrowed time (as is all social media) in skirting regulations that normally were enforced on TV and radio. It will catch up with YouTube, Instagram, etc and they are realizing it and trying to prepare.
- himom 9y agoHeck, my mother and I both independently were recommended to supplement with extra magnesium. Most people are also deficient. It’s also useful for cognitive and GI function.
- gaius 9y agowhile science isn't saying you should use magnesium for sleep per se In the fitness community ZMA is widely considered a sleep aid. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/ZMA_(supplement) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/ZMA_(supplement)
- friesen 9y agoFirst, there is nothing in that wiki page that suggests that ZMA is a sleep aid. Second, the fitness community is prone to quackery.