3 ms·
Wellness programs and similar initiatives are so repellent to me that I'm pretty sympathetic to everyone fooling them.
by emodendroket 9y ago
Wellness programs and similar initiatives are so repellent to me that I'm pretty sympathetic to everyone fooling them.
- darkstar999 9y agoWhy?
- emodendroket 9y agoBecause I dislike the idea of insurance companies nosing in on my private life and telling me how to spend my time. I'm sure someone will object that participation is voluntary, but I expect it to go along the familiar voluntary with perks -> penalties if not participating -> outright mandatory progression.
- acdha 9y agoI also expect that ratchet effect where the goals will increase over time without considering other factors such as whether people are paid enough to afford to have reasonable commute times, access to healthy food, etc. Software engineers have higher pay and greater ability to walk if management gets too patronizing; a lot of other people are going to get this as the alternative to big insurance increases but not, say, getting a more flexible schedule or paid enough to spend an hour less commuting or be able to afford healthier food at inner city markets where vegetables cost more than at the Whole Foods further out.
- logfromblammo 9y agoI also have a stubbornness gene in me that encourages me to spitefully resist all attempts to meddle in my lifestyle by sanctimonious blowhards that couldn't care less about my actual well being. The last contact I had with such a voluntary insurance program, it consisted entirely of the insured calling in to a call center, to have someone nag them to create health goals and then nag more to make progress. No thanks; I'm already married. I could have just blathed my way through to collect the cash reward at the end, but I decided I didn't want to feed that system with my attention, and opted out. Later iterations haven't seemed any better, and I too fear the "voluntary" -> "economically enforced" -> "mandatory" progression. If you want me to walk 10k steps every day, the cash reward might be enough to reflect the lower claims paid out to frequent walkers, but it won't even begin to cover the excess cortisol, expressed because I can't stand the thought of my insurance company electronically monitoring my every move and judging me based on how much I can manage. (Genealogical anecdotes suggest the stubbornness is Scottish in origin. The "go boil your head" temperament is strongly associated with a specific family name, traceable back to Edinburgh.)
- Jill_the_Pill 9y agoOh, I thought that gene was Irish. Best way to get me to do something is to forbid it. I started flossing the day they stopped recommending it.
- logfromblammo 9y agoCould be both. I have some Irish ancestors, too, and in the same subtree as the Scots. I have a reverse psychology detector, though, so if you forbid something in an attempt to get me to do it, I'm then more likely to be stubbornly obedient in whatever way I have determined would punish you most for attempting to deceive me. Nagging me about something I was already planning to do is the worst, though, because that means I have to delay doing it until it is apparent I'm not doing it just because you told me to.
- ryandrake 9y agoI don’t have much to add but I’d like to point out that you can see that "voluntary" -> "economically enforced" -> "mandatory" progression pattern in other areas too, not just in insurance. Look at those electronic toll tags that used to be voluntary. Then you got a “discount“ for using them. Now there are lanes you can’t use without them. Credit cards are going down this path, with the big push towards a “cashless” society. Introduce some thing that not everyone wants, then incentivize it’s use, then punish it’s non-use.
- gascan 9y agoTurn it around- perhaps the low risk individuals find subsidizing the high risk individuals equally repellent. Wellness programs allow those individuals to recover some of their premiums.
- mplewis 9y agoLow-risk individuals subsidizing high-risk individuals? We just call that "insurance."
- baddox 9y agoThat’s not a trait inherent to insurance. Premiums can be adjusted based on risk so that everyone “subsidizes” everyone else by the same amount on average.
- emodendroket 9y agoIn this case the people who most need insurance cannot afford it.
- dv_dt 9y agoAnd after all the accounting of minuitae is done, after we pay for layers of actuaries, account administrators, and executives that rebalance all the groups and variable, we end up paying a risk and profit optimized system price that is, on average, double other modern nations bills. And for the privilege of paying more than any other modern nation, we die earlier, exclude the poorest, and subject even those with that optimized insurance to bankruptcy should they need to exercise their benefit in a major medical episode.
- gascan 9y agoIt tends to start out that way, yes. But eventually as you can better model risk, you can better customize premiums to each individual, until you eventually approach charging each individual their expected risk (loss * probability) plus overhead. Which, I believe, is how insurance is ideally supposed to behave according to economists.
- 9y ago
- entee 9y agoThey don't even work: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-01-26/workplace-wellness-programs-really-don-t-work https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-01-26/workplace...
- emodendroket 9y agoYou have to wonder if there is some ulterior motive at work or else just some sort of mass psychosis where some eggheads think employees want their bosses to tell them what to eat and how to exercise.
- entee 9y agoI think more simply ask how many people make a substantial, durable change in health status in the general population. My sense is quite few, it’s really hard to change your lifestyle or get more exercise. I doubt a small workplace incentive is going to tip the balance for all but a few people, and those were likely already close to making a change. It’s also labor intensive to measure workplace wellness in a verifiable fashion. You basically need to collect vital signs on your employees, otherwise you’re open to being gamed in the way described in the OP.
- dv_dt 9y agoA fitbit wellness program similar to this is attributed to one of the ignition points of the West Virginia teachers strike. The gamification program was added in conjunction with a health insurance cost increase and in the context of already very low pay. https://www.thenation.com/article/the-west-virginia-teachers-strike-shows-that-winning-big-requires-creating-a-crisis/ https://www.thenation.com/article/the-west-virginia-teachers... Our healthcare costs are insanely high, with the fundamental performance of the system the worst in the modern nations of the world, our life expectancy being the only one in the group actually dropping. Instead of addressing fundamental issues, our employer benefit systems are experimenting with behaviour modification via gamification programs like some sort of bizzare black mirror dystopia.
- ryandrake 9y agoPlus, these kind of schemes are never implemented as discounts for participating in gamification. It’s always a price increase for non-participants.