3 ms·
Interesting part for me is the hilarious FUD where we got none when DPA came in. A good part of GDPR is already here with EU Data Protection Acts and what cons
by oldcynic 8y ago
Interesting part for me is the hilarious FUD where we got none when DPA came in. A good part of GDPR is already here with EU Data Protection Acts and what constitutes personal data is much the same. Many of the Kafkaesque and corruption scenarios should be possible under DPA and other laws yet haven't been happening.
GDPR increases maximum penalty to be high enough that it could be a penalty to a Google or Facebook for a serious, wilful, breach of regs, in an environment where the tiniest fraction of reported cases get any fine at all (16 of 17,300 reports for 2017 in the UK) let alone the maximum. Internet now certain that one man software companies and hobbyists with non-commercial regex sites will receive £17m fines, every time and it will be used as a stick to beat one's political enemies with or, most comically of all, pay for local infrastructure improvements.
I don't understand why - the regs seem reasonable and not especially difficult to meet unless your business is built on wilful abuse of personal data. Just a reasonable effort to enhance DPA taking into account new techniques and misuses of data. Deletion for everyone, not just a minority - thanks to FB et al feeling it's fine to never delete, and run shadow profiles on all. The highest penalty will be saved for the most offensive cases involving multi-nationals. It will be interesting in a few years to see how many maximum fines have been levied. My bet is none at all, once or twice if there's an especially egregious breach from an Amazon or Google.
I've little doubt that just as I feel more should have attracted fines under DPA I'll feel more should have got GDPR fines.
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y ago>> I don't understand why - the regs seem reasonable and not especially difficult to meet unless your business is built on wilful abuse of personal data. My intuition is that the people who complain are that fraction of developers who actually care about their profits more than their users' privacy.
- oldcynic 8y agoI'm sure that's a big part of it when every app wants to do a data grab. I'm also left thinking US law doesn't really do proportionate after a few of these discussions! :) For us in Europe 20 years of DPA must help - I doubt there's many here would want to go back to pre-data protection.