5 ms·
Jaron Lanier Interview on What Went Wrong with the Internet
- psyc 9y agoWhile reading this article, I imagined an Eternal September writ large across the whole industry. Maybe in the beginning it was a few idealistic visionaries, who attracted other idealists who could get behind the vision. Then it succeeded wildly, and attracted everyone and thus became merely human. A mix of the worst and the best, and probably in proportion closer to 80/20 than 50/50. The vision became a game, one that need only be stable, but not optimal or humanist in its value system.
- smacktoward 9y agoI would argue that it's even worse than that. The Eternal September scenario would at least let us off the hook, morally speaking -- it's not that the thing we built is bad, it's that people are bad, and so as people piled on to the thing we built it eventually became just as bad as they are. Which would be depressing, but at least not blameworthy. But while people have their faults, I think it's closer to the truth here to say that we built something that took those bad people and made them worse. Chasing engagement and clicks, we built systems that rewarded bad behavior, with the inevitable result that the people who found the most success in our systems were the ones who behaved the worst. And since everybody wants to be successful in whatever environment they find themselves in, that drove people to be worse than they otherwise would have been as they chased after the same success for themselves.
- cvwright 9y agoI think the 2016 election was another Eternal September. Everything feels much more hostile and obnoxious since about the time of the last US presidential conventions. I'm not sure what to call this phenomenon. Eternal 2016? Eternal November?
- rhizome 9y agoWhile reading this article, I imagined an Eternal September writ large across the whole industry. That may be a side-effect to Lanier's singing the same song since around that time.
- walterbell 9y agoWhile the interview articulates several problems in need of solutions, it's not clear that Netflix-DRM-style TV business models are the answer.
- Animats 9y agoIt helps to know that Lanier is a part-time musician. He's from the era when musicians were a Big Deal. It bugs him that now they're just content generators for Spotify, SFX, and Ticketmaster.
- johnvanommen 9y agoHe's managed to keep a high profile for a loooong time. I remember reading an article about him in 1983, about a game he made for the Commodore 64. The article spent more time talking about Lanier than talking about the game. This seemed a bit odd, because at that time, programmers frequently weren't even credited for their work.
- yarrel 9y agoYes the solutions Lanier proposes will make the Internet worse, by his own measure. And people still won't pay for his music.
- petermcneeley 9y ago"So you wanna be both a socialist and a libertarian at the same time, and it’s absurd." "But in fact, we’re in a period of time of extreme concentration of wealth and power, and it’s precisely around those who run the biggest computers. So the truth and the effect is just the opposite of what the rhetoric is and the immediate experience." "My feeling is that if the theory is correct that we got into this by trying to be socialist and libertarian at the same time, and getting the worst of both worlds, then we have to choose." "The other option is to monetize it (facebook). And that’s the one that I’m personally more interested in. And what that would look like is, we’d ask those who can afford to — which would be a lot of people in the world, certainly most people in the West — to start paying for it. And then we’d also pay people who provide data into it that’s exceptionally valuable to the network, and it would become a source of economic growth. And we would outlaw advertising on it. There would no longer be third parties paying to influence you." Sounds like Jaron has Chosen poorly.
- adam 9y agoIf you prefer your Jaron Lanier in audio form, this was a very similar interview he did for Ezra Klein's podcast: https://www.vox.com/2018/1/16/16897738/jaron-lanier-interview https://www.vox.com/2018/1/16/16897738/jaron-lanier-intervie...
- originalsimba 9y agoThe short-sighted arrogance of the headline really turns me off the article itself. Nothing "went wrong" with the internet. The internet is fine. The culture of first world nations however, is completely fubar, has been since before all of us were born, and will probably continue to be long after we're all dead. (second and third world nations are also completely broken, but we expect that.) It's the same kind of nonsense when people say "We've destroyed the planet!" No we haven't, we destroyed our own survivability in our own habitat, but the planet _is fine_, and will shake us all off some day without so much as a thought about it. The internet is equally indifferent and unaffected by our stupid capitalism problems.
- pavlov 9y agoI'm curious what you mean by "second world nations". The original Cold War definition was countries aligned with the Soviet Union. What's the second world today?
- originalsimba 9y agoWell, third world countries are nations which are significantly behind the "First World" nations in terms of social, economic, and political development or progress. For example, much of the middle east still believes that an imaginary sky-fairy has given them the authority and permission to murder women with rocks anytime the men get upset about something, and they think simply being men gives them the right to rape women. These things basically makes them cave-men. So "second world" countries are those which are not quite stone-age savage, but are still noticably behind. So an example of a "Second world" nation would be the United Kingdom, which enjoys many of the modern luxuries of the first world, and much of the social freedoms and progress, and yet still suffers under a completely irrational monarchy and lacks essential freedoms such as the right to self defense. As citizens of the United Kingdom are completely forbidden from keeping arms for the sole purpose of defense of self, family, and property, they are essentially servants of the state. Such a nation cannot then be justly described as "first world", as real first world nations such as the United States have enjoyed these additional freedoms for many generations now. If my definition is not "official" then I apologize, nobody ever really explained the meaning of the phrases to me and my understanding is simply based on 3 decades of contextual usage. The implication is that there is a single path of progress which all nations are basically following. The first world is setting the example, and the rest are following our lead. ('that we still have such a long way to go is one of the reasons it's so amazing we haven't nuked ourselves to extinction yet :)')
- jstewartmobile 9y agoProbably should have been titled "What Went Wrong with the Web". Aside from NAT, the network itself works as well as it ever did. The clusterfuck we send across it is another story.
- dredmorbius 9y agoLayers 8 & 9 are exhibiting troubling symptoms.
- lsh 9y agoThank you https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Layer_8 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Layer_8
- pnathan 9y agoWhat he calls "Digital Maoism" is an excellent critique and worth the read. The loss of voice is a substantial problem; the single voice being arbitrated by a for-profit cadre is worse. I've followed his online works off and on for a while - he had some interesting ideas about coding and adaptive computations about 10+ years ago that I'd like to see followed up on. He seems to specialize in sort of being a public critic now (above interview seems to rehash his usual points well) & advocate for paid everything & DRM.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]