3 ms·
The reason we pay news outlets for content is for their editorial function: curating writers, picking and choosing worthwhile topics, polishing the output, etc.
by sanderjd 9y ago
The reason we pay news outlets for content is for their editorial function: curating writers, picking and choosing worthwhile topics, polishing the output, etc. This editorial function has no implicit value, but neither does the content; the value is in the combination of strong content with good editorial technique.
My sense is that Medium isn't doing this, that they are instead just charging for content, which completely misses the point.
- coldtea 9y ago>The reason we pay news outlets for content is for their editorial function: curating writers, picking and choosing worthwhile topics, polishing the output, etc. This editorial function has no implicit value, but neither does the content; the value is in the combination of strong content with good editorial technique. I don't think that's explicitly and consciously the case. Today that everybody can publish on the web, such curation might be especially needed, and payed for (to remove the noise). But back in the day, we paid news outlets because that was how we got articles -- whether they were curated or not was a secondary concern. People couldn't just buy paper and bare printing costs, handle distribution deals etc and distribute their own articles. So if we wanted articles we had to buy them in newspaper/magazine form. Curation came with that -- not as an inherent demand. >My sense is that Medium isn't doing this, that they are instead just charging for content, which completely misses the point. Not really. The whole point of internet distrubution, what was hailed as revolutionary, was the ability to 'skip the gatekeeper', publish directly to everybody, and grow your own audience. Medium is still kind of a middleman, but they're not a gatekeeper, in the sense that the editor in chief of an old news outlet was. Their whole point is giving people direct access to any content writer they like. If someone doesn't care for one, they can read others. No curation necessary, not only because you can discover yourself which authors you like, but also because Medium has infinite space for articles -- not the 100-200 pages of a newspaper/magazine. It's the same deal with independent musicians selling their wares directly.
- sanderjd 9y agoI feel like you said lots of stuff that is true but isn't a response to my point. You said that back in the day we paid for news because of scarcity due to the costs of printing and distribution. That's true, but I'm not talking about back in the day, I'm talking about now. The value in the business model now is in the combination of strong content and editorial. You're saying that Medium is a middle-man but not a gatekeeper. That seems true to me, but what I'm saying is: that model doesn't make much sense. The majority of value provided by content middle-men is in doing gatekeeping well. I'm very interested in direct-to-audience models for creators. But it isn't clear to me that that's what Medium is doing... Maybe it is, but it's not how I think about it (yet), so maybe they need to talk that up more.
- coldtea 9y ago>You said that back in the day we paid for news because of scarcity due to the costs of printing and distribution. That's true, but I'm not talking about back in the day, I'm talking about now. Well, if you're talking about now, then one needs to add that today don't generally pay for most of our news content. We get it for free. Only select outlets managed to make paying work (e.g. Economist, NYT and a few more). We do however, today, have systems for bypassing gatekeepers, curation, and paying content creators directly: from YouTube vloggers and Medium authors, to Patreon comic makers, artists and so on. >that model doesn't make much sense. The majority of value provided by content middle-men is in doing gatekeeping well. Well, the majority of people don't seem to care for those gatekeepers anymore. Medium had millions of viewers without gatekeeping. Facebook has billions of eyeballs hooked on reading whatever crap stories and content is put out there (I mean, aside from personal feed posts). So while there might be value in gatekeepers and curation, that's not really a much better business model than what Medium does.
- coldtea 9y ago>So while there might be value in gatekeepers and curation, that's not really a much better business model than what Medium does. To add to this, this was the misguided idea that news people had, thinking it would allow them to survey. That "Sure, we might now have 10000000 sources of free content, but because of that people will value our curation that separates the wheat from the chuff more, and pay us for that" (or, in a variation of this, our "professionalism" and "knowledgable meta-analysis of news"). Turned out not to be the case. 90% of the people are totally fine with those 10000000 random sources of free news, thank you very much.