See, the real problem here is that the OP thinks that math and science are distinct. I certainly am of the opinion that they are not, which makes the whole arg

See, the real problem here is that the OP thinks that math and science are distinct. I certainly am of the opinion that they are not, which makes the whole argument very weak, since reason -> logic -> mathematics -> science. [Edit: Perhaps the downvoters have tried to teach quantum mechanics as a subject distinct from mathematics and physics and succeeded, in which case I am most interested in your arguments. Personally I have only managed it as two sides of the same coin]