6 ms·
The idea that AI will affect employment is very dubious to me: - This stuff was talked about all the time during the industrial revolution. But it turns out th
by legitster 9y ago
The idea that AI will affect employment is very dubious to me:
- This stuff was talked about all the time during the industrial revolution. But it turns out that automation just increased worked productivity and made people more valuable.
- Since ATMs were introduced, the number of bank tellers in the US actually went up.
- Certain industries have actually become deautomated over time. As an example: coffee. It used to be exclusively made by automated machines. Now hand-making coffees is one of the largest businesses in America.
- AI is only as smart as the data you feed it. Even Google's own search rankings have to have human minders because people are too good at gaming their algorithms.
- AI is only good at the thing that human beings are very bad at - making quick, analytics based decisions. Of course this is a threat to middle management and executive functions. But for people who actually make things or solve problems, there's just one more thing to make and solve problems about.
There are some very real concerns about organizations using AI to make decisions about people without human oversight. Imagine an AI tasked with college admissions, bad decisions without possibility of human intervention could hurt people - are we sure it would be that much worse than our current system, often tainted by bias, money, and racism?
My concern is that the leaders in the corporate tech world created huge organizations by automating our lives, and now they want to act as gatekeepers on the kinds of automation that is acceptable.
Edit:
To add to this - a companies stance on AI will probably follow their belief in whether humans are underrated or overrated. Google designs products believing humans are overrated - they think people will be victims of AI. Amazon thinks people are underrated (based on Amazon Turk, customer service, warehouse design) - ironically, they won't think humans will overall be harmed by AI.
- Eeb7ohk0 9y ago>- Since ATMs were introduced, the number of bank tellers in the US actually went up. Counterpoint[0]: > But US bank teller employment actually rose modestly from 500,000 to approximately 550,000 over the 30-year period from 1980 to 2010 (although given the growth in the labor force in this time interval, these numbers do imply that bank tellers declined as a share of overall US employment). [0] http://slatestarcodex.com/2018/02/19/technological-unemployment-much-more-than-you-wanted-to-know/ http://slatestarcodex.com/2018/02/19/technological-unemploym...
- legitster 9y agoVery good point. But the reality that hiring just slowed down and banking became easier also isn't enough to convince me that automation was bad.
- mcbits 9y agoIncremental automation of any specific task isn't bad, especially if it can be introduced at a rate that's in line with the normal turnover/attrition for a job. The doom-and-gloom scenario is when extremely adaptable and productive automation is deployed across many industries without time for the labor market to adapt, causing the world's population of 5-6 billion impoverished people to grow to 6-7 billion. Advancements in defense technology make it impossible for the masses to revolt and seize resources to revert to a pre-automation economy among themselves, so they die off. A few hundred million shareholders and financiers enjoy their abundant luxury goods for a while, but they soon turn their robot armies against each other and also die off.
- noobhacker 9y agoThe argument that AI will take all the job is commonly made, but I agree with you that it's a poor argument. Much more plausible and concerning, however, is that AI will stratify the labor force into 3 groups: highly-paid engineers (who manage the AI), highly-paid services job (i.e. doctors, lawyers, psychiatrist), and poorly-paid services job (i.e. barista). This stratification has already happened as our economy advances (you mentioned baristas---in the past, those workers could have earned middle class manufacturing wages). The wage distribution in the services sector nowadays looks like a dumbbell [1]. Wage stratification can lead to political stratification as poor people don't have the resources to fight for their rights. Political stratification can lead to further wage stratification, continuing the cycle. That's why I believe that it's important to deal with the AI threat, now. [1] https://seii.mit.edu/research/study/how-does-growth-in-the-u-s-service-sector-impact-labor-polarization/ https://seii.mit.edu/research/study/how-does-growth-in-the-u...
- legitster 9y agoI agree that wage stratification has already occurred, but I think AI will do nothing to make it worse than tech already did. It will do nothing to replace service workers or laborers. Again, it's only a threat to managers and decision makers.
- JackFaker 9y agoMany of the middle income jobs in the U.S seem vulnerable to automation. Professions like truck drivers, longshoreman and radiology techs that provide compensation between 40K and 70K could probably be mostly or completely automated in less than the span of a generation.
- root_axis 9y agoThat seems like an arbitrary stratification. By the time AI is sophisticated enough to have significant ripple-effects throughout the economy, the "highly paid engineer" is going to be a tiny fraction of the labor force, akin to the hedge fund manager of today. Also, why do I need to hire a team of engineers when I can just spin up a few AWS AI instances.
- majewsky 9y ago> This stuff was talked about all the time during the industrial revolution. But it turns out that automation just increased worked productivity and made people more valuable. Because a lot of the new jobs were not automatable with the then-current state of technology. Over time, as technology becomes more and more sophisticated, more and more new jobs will be automated from the start. > Since ATMs were introduced, the number of bank tellers in the US actually went up. Would be interesting to know the background here, because this is massively counterintuitive. My guesses would be population growth and the increased complexity of financial products. > AI is only as smart as the data you feed it. Even Google's own search rankings have to have human minders because people are too good at gaming their algorithms. This is true for humans as well. Humans have a headstart here: We have thousands of years of experience in training humans, but only a few decades of experience training computers. > AI is only good at the thing that human beings are very bad at - making quick, analytics based decisions. AI is not the only piece of the puzzle. When combined with mechatronics, AI is good at another thing that human beings are very bad at: performing fast and extremely precise movements. When combined with advanced sensors, AI is good at another thing that human beings are very bad at: transcending human limits of perception (see e.g. LIDAR sensors in automated cars that can see things that a human cannot). And so on. --- I agree with your ending remarks though.
- thesumofall 9y ago>> Since ATMs were introduced, the number of bank tellers in the US actually went up. > Would be interesting to know the background here, because this is massively counterintuitive. My guesses would be population growth and the increased complexity of financial products. With those things being automated, I guess banks had to find new ways to differentiate. Sales and relationship management are one of those domains that are highly difficult to automate and hence have a big potential for differentiation. I see this all the time in related industries where firms are increasingly pushing towards “value added services” because they believe that those are difficult to replicate by competitors through machines (or otherwise). I believe the good news is that this will often indeed lead to higher capabilities and new products / services that people are interested to purchase (banks are maybe a bad example here)
- simias 9y agoAI is kind of vague and catch-all these days, if you're talking about things like Siri/Amazon Echo/Alexa/... or even self-driving cars then I tend to agree with you, the actual "intelligence" of these systems is very limited. It can be very useful in specific applications but as you said they couldn't make you coffee unless you specifically program them to be able to make coffee. If however we're talking about the Singularity where artificial human-level intelligence is produced then I think this will be a more important discovery than fire or agriculture in the history of humankind. That means that we'll have produced machines that are as good or even probably better than humans at basically anything, from making coffee to driving a truck to being a bank teller to being a software developer. If we reach this point where humanity is basically obsolete then what happens? I don't think the Singularity is as close as some people make it to be, I know AI is super hype these days but we've had AI winters in the past and they could happen again. I do believe that it's undoubtedly going to happen sooner or later however, be it in a year, a decade or a century. When it happens what are we going to do? Will it be the beginning of a heavenly post-scarcity world where super-intelligent machines take care of all our needs, freeing us to write poetry and do some soul searching or will it create an incredible amount of instability as all of humanity suddenly realize that whatever they want to do they can ask a machine to do for them and better?
- legitster 9y agoI don't think Sergey was talking about the Singularity. Even if he was talking about the Singularity, I am skeptical of someone talking about a far-off, theoretical doom to discourage investment in competing existing technologies.
- Symmetry 9y agoBoth I think. "Most notably, safety spans a wide range of concerns from the fears of sci-fi style sentience to the more near-term questions such as validating the performance of self-driving cars." I feel like the term "Singularity" is used in too many ways by too many different people to be useful unless you define how you're using it but Brin seems worried about AGI.
- 9y ago
- mac01021 9y ago"Affecting employment" is not the same as reducing the total number of jobs available. And all Brin said was that we need to understand what the likely impacts on employment are. Certainly, if it becomes cost effective to have your fleet of vehicles operated by software instead of humans, a lot of people will have to find new jobs. "Truck driver" is the most commonly held profession in a majority of the fifty states.
- eli_gottlieb 9y ago>- Certain industries have actually become deautomated over time. As an example: coffee. It used to be exclusively made by automated machines. Now hand-making coffees is one of the largest businesses in America. Isn't that a bad thing?
- ihsw2 9y agoThat depends on your perspective. From a job creations perspective it's wonderful, people are willing to open their wallets for labor-intensive products and services. While labor automation can be a boon for some and indirectly increase efficiencies, encouraging consumption of labor-intensive products and services directly incentivizes jobs creation. If this can be done in a safe manner (ie: appropriate workplace health codes and adequate protection against dangerous environmental externalities like pollution) then by all means it can be a good thing. Regardless of your opinions on shifting manufacturing to China, it has lifted tens/hundreds of millions of people out of poverty and transformed the country into a consumer-based economy (from a largely agrarian society). While it has devastated/destroyed local habitats and caused other ugliness, it cannot be disputed that encouraging usage of labor on a massive scale has done a lot of good for the people of China.
- cm2187 9y agoGood list. I would add: - AI relies on data being available. For many professions there is simply no data to train an algorithm on, even when this would be a good fit for AI. An example I have in mind is skin disease diagnosis. We should start having generalist and dermatologists build a database of pictures and metadata of all the patients they see, even (and mostly) those that have nothing but just wanted to double check some suspicious spot. The only sort of database they have right now is collections of photos of the most pathological cases, but without the benign photos they are pretty much useless to build an automated AI diagnosis. Building this database might run against the incentive of the profession to be automated. - AI is only economically viable above a minimum scale. The AI algorithm (and associated system) will not write or maintain itself. So you need to pay a team of software engineers to do that. That may or may not be more economical than paying a few people to do the job. We already hit that limit with software today. There is a lot of mundane office tasks that should have already been replaced with software but haven't. - this one will be less popular here but I think is an important ceiling. There are many fields that software developers are completely uninterested in, and where the underlying business people are not technical enough to develop their own software. Certain areas of banking (outside of markets and retail), complex accounting rules, law, etc. The domain needs to be accessible to developers and that will make many professions very hard to automate even when they should. And the businesses may have no incentive to push for automation themselves (lawyers charge by the hour, they don't want more efficiency!).
- andosa 9y agoYour argument assumes that computers/AI/robots won't be as good as say a median human at any given job. I think that's quite a strong assumption