2 ms·
>> ...or better yet, got market forces to work on it. This is not an area where market forces can work. Market forces got us to where we are now. There will
by sandworm101 9y ago
>> ...or better yet, got market forces to work on it.
This is not an area where market forces can work. Market forces got us to where we are now. There will never be a healthy free market for carbon sequestration. It is an energy-negative activity. Absent artificial stimulus, it ain't going to happen.
Government is for doing what the market (ie Freedom!) cannot. This is a multi-decade problem for which open markets are ill-equipped. We need massive government intervention. This is an area where we need to take tax dollars and spend them directly on both reducing carbon output (now) and active sequestration once that becomes more efficient than further reductions.
- Tomminn 9y agoIn New Zealand, the government buys drugs from pharmeceutical companies. There is no reason why the US government cannot buy carbon offset from the free market, using the revenue generated from a carbon tax. There will be monitoring/inspection issues, to ensure the carbon is actually being sequestered, but this doesn't make it impossible.
- sandworm101 9y agoBecause carbon offset is a shell game. Paying people to not emit at X so that other people can emit at Y opens too many loopholes. The desire for profit by cutting corners and cheating will creep in. Emissions need to be directly curtailed. W don't need "if you want to burn, pay someone else to not burn." We need "thou shall not burn", or at lease "thou shall burn less tomorrow than thou didst yesterday."
- Tomminn 9y agoIt's not "pay someone else not to burn", it's "pay someone else to eat all the carbon you are spitting out". It would totally work, and it's the only way to get to zero emission.
- iovrthoughtthis 9y agoDoes I matter from where the intervention comes from? We probably can't just do one thing and wait. We probably have to try all the things.