7 ms·
>if the implication is that nobody should provide their personal data because it can be abused then is it not obvious that the use of personal data should be re
by closeparen 9y ago
>if the implication is that nobody should provide their personal data because it can be abused then is it not obvious that the use of personal data should be regulated?
I honestly thought this kind of reasoning was a right-wing caricature. No, it is not obvious that choices with risks attached should always be regulated away.
Disclosing information in proportion to trust is a basic life skill. I understand that many in the tech community are frustrated to see the general public failing to exercise this discipline, and maybe regulation is the best way to protect them from themselves, but that's not obvious.
>If the majority banks lost your money regularly, would you blame customers of the bank for using banks -- or would you say that banks should have stricter regulations to stop people from being screwed?
False dichotomy. You want a spectrum of financial products that depositors can choose from according to their risk tolerance. It's essential that we have stable, regulated, insured checking accounts. It's also essential that we have self-directed brokerage accounts.
>"just slapp[ing] some Amazon adds on [your] site" is not the correct approach to handling users' personal data.
A site sending your browser Amazon ads does not oblige it to execute or display them. And this isn't some secret backend upload. If someone is willing to use a site with this revenue model, why is that your business?
- cyphar 9y ago> No, it is not obvious that choices with risks attached should always be regulated away. The assumption is that all users are actively making a choice. Many are not aware of the choices they are making, and I think it's wrong to punish them for it -- when companies profit off this lack of literacy and people rush to their defense whenever people start talking about regulation. I don't want companies like Google and Amazon to be able to hoard massive amounts of personal information about a large portion of the world's population, and not have to respect the rights of the people whose information they have acquired. > You want a spectrum of financial products that depositors can choose from according to their risk tolerance. If effectively everyone of importance just uses Amazon (or Google) ads then you don't get a "spectrum" and there's no choice involved. You have an option to either use or not use a majority of the internet. Yes, you can use ad-blockers but that's not a long-term solution. > A site sending your browser Amazon ads does not oblige it to execute or display them. And this isn't some secret backend upload. If someone is willing to use a site with this revenue model, why is that your business? Most users are not aware of how these things work. I agree that if everyone knew how to block those ads and what the actual problems are with them, then things like GDPR might be less necessary (though the right to retract consent is something that should be enforced). But even then, ad-blockers are a defense against an industry that is over-stepping ethical boundaries every day. At which point do you say that companies which inflict systemic violations of ethics on billions of people should be held accountable? Or is it always the fault of the people because they didn't care enough about their personal information?
- stef25 9y agoSeems to come down to having to protect users from their own lack of understanding. What ethical boundaries do you think are being overstepped through advertising?
- Xylakant 9y agoIt’s not advertising itself that is problematic. I’d be fine with an image loaded from the origin serevr. It’s the attached pervasive tracking and monitoring, coupled with the real security risks that come with the current incarnation of advertising technologies.
- mnsc 9y agoThe irony is that if instead of passing legislation to try and "protect users/citizens from their own lack of understanding", a government would instead invest heavily in educating their users/citizens on privacy matters in order to minimize the unknowing populace, i.e. the "fodder" for shady data selling companies (like Facebook/Google). Then you would have companies arguing undue interference with their businesses (I don't know the correct term). And my guess is that's the way big companies prefer it since they can lobby easier when it's not laws but instead "education initiatives" and other fuzzy programs. And they could also counter-invest heavily in another set of "public education programs" where they could try to inform the users/citizens about how valuable they are when they don't understand/care about how their data is monetized. And with the advertising power/know-how these companies wield that match would be easily won against some random government propaganda. I could imagine a major ad campaing where this question is posted all over the city: "What ethical boundaries do you think are being overstepped through advertising? Think for yourselves, don't let the government tell you what to think! Sincerly, your friends the advertising business" That's a hard fucking question for me to answer concisely, so I wont do that. Sry.
- ThomPete 9y agoFacebook don't sell data they sell access to customers based on data. Thats a very important distinction.
- mcguire 9y ago"I honestly thought this kind of reasoning was a right-wing caricature. No, it is not obvious that choices with risks attached should always be regulated away." Speaking of false dichotomies... I think you'll find that self-directed brokerage accounts have more regulations than checking accounts because they provide more opportunity to commit fraud.