5 ms·
Use a Mikrotik as Your Home Router (2017)
- rhinoceraptor 9y agoI would definitely not use a Mikrotik router, they just recently had an RCE [0]. And apparently they encrypt user passwords! [1] [0] https://nvd.nist.gov/vuln/detail/CVE-2018-7445 https://nvd.nist.gov/vuln/detail/CVE-2018-7445 [1] https://forum.mikrotik.com/viewtopic.php?t=133533#p656301 https://forum.mikrotik.com/viewtopic.php?t=133533#p656301
- Lionsion 9y agoWhat would you use then? I don't think a manufacturer should be judged too harshly based on if they have vulnerabilities or not, since all software does, but rather on how they respond to and patch those vulnerabilities.
- Someone1234 9y agoSo which major vendor hasn't had a RCE on the LAN side? Even my current Asus router had an RCE on the LAN side a couple of years ago... MikroTik fixed both of the issues you referenced, just as Asus fixed the issue I referenced. So I see no specific reason not to use either a MikroTik or a Asus device (and keep both up to date). The only major thing I'd consider is: - Does the manufacturer respond constructively? - Is the device still receiving security updates/has no outstanding holes?
- rhinoceraptor 9y agoConsidering that they can't even get user authentication right, I have pretty big doubts about the rest of their security. Hashing/salting passwords is not a new concept.
- carlhjerpe 9y agoIt's hard to defend something like this, but i think it's important to know that this only affects MikroTik devices with the SMB service enabled (disabled by default). It's very bad, but they responded quickly and resolved the issue. One thing i'd say is worth mentioning is that they're still keeping "all" (all i know off) RouterBoard devices updated. We've had customers with gear many many years old, still updated with feature and security upgrades.
- dibbsonline 9y agoI would definitely not run linux windows macos netgear cisco juniper because they once had a RCE.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- pkd 9y agoI would wholeheartedly recommend Ubiquiti products. I use an EdgeRouter X and Unifi AP Lite and get almost no loss of speeds over WiFi compared to connecting directly to the modem. Also no packet loss or poor reception. Their devices run Linux so you can ssh directly into them if you want to change something. All config options are also available via the command line interface. If you want a consistent UI experience, choose one of their several "lines" and stick with it for all your hardware, i.e. use a Unifi Security Gateway + a Unifi Switch instead of the EdgeRouter X. This will allow you to control all your devices from the same interface. I went with the heterogenuous combination because it suited my needs.
- Lazare 9y agoI've had some very good experiences with Ubiquiti as well.
- JustSomeNobody 9y agoTP-Link EAP series APs are nice as well. I use one with my Edgerouter X and it's a rock stable duo.
- exelius 9y agoI really like the Unifi gear for home use; it’s industrial-grade without completely breaking the bank (can get a good 2 AP setup for $400). PoE is a nice touch that makes it really easy to just snake a cable from a closet and leave a full-power AP in the attic. The remote management tools are really nice if you have multiple sites (parents house, vacation home, etc) to manage. 1% problem for sure, but for a little bit more than a crapbox integrated router you can get an enterprise-grade modular managed solution.
- tbyehl 9y agoUniFi is awesome for managing the extended family's stuff, tho I've been leaning towards AmpliFi Mesh (another Ubiquiti product line) for those who don't have very fast Internet -- the phone app is super friendly and supports remote management. As a geek with more complex networking needs -- multi-WAN, site-to-site VPN tunnels, lots of port forwards -- EdgeRouters are the way to go. UNMS gives me some centralized management and insights into what's happening with my EdgeOS (and AirMax) gear. Rest of my network is UniFi APs and switches.
- dbalan 9y agoThe original seems to be down. Google cache: https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:c9vt2e7hi4AJ:https://blog.ligos.net/2017-02-16/Use-A-Mikrotik-As-Your-Home-Router.html+&cd=1&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=de https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:c9vt2e...
- lukeduff 9y agoI had a buddy that used a Mikrotik router for years. He couldn't shop at Newegg because his router "optimized" his MTU and Newegg blocked connections with non-standard MTU sizes.
- falsedan 9y agoMikrotik sometimes do things differntly to how you might expect[0]… though that was how I found out about them, and have been happily managing a hEX lite for a while now. 0: https://dyn.com/blog/longer-is-not-better/ https://dyn.com/blog/longer-is-not-better/, previous discussion https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=490924 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=490924
- q3k 9y agoThis is definitely a bug (a 'value of out range' for prepend > 255 should have at least been emitted), but IOS devices crashing because of it is noone but Cisco's fault. And then, not having a 'filter out if AS path > 64' config line while being a transit provider is just careless.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- AceJohnny2 9y agoMTU is the most broken thing about the Internet today.
- joeseeder 9y agoI would argue for BGP at the top You never hear about MTU failures in the media :(
- carlhjerpe 9y agoThat's because it doesn't fail globally all at the same time
- 9y ago
- dbalan 9y agoAs a side note, I'd consider trying to flash something openWRT on other routers that anybody owns. There are not really many companies that keeps releasing patches for consumer devices unless there is a major outcry (for e.g KRACK). In most cases your router in a small MIPS box running linux (consumer ones), treat it as you'd treat your other systems and update it often!
- fencepost 9y agoI'd be wary about running a mikrotik as a home router, but mostly because the user interface is not what I would call friendly at all unless you're already a networking person. It's not a terrible idea if you need more capability then a standard home router, but there are other options that also offer more power than home routers without quite so much visible complexity. As an example, OpenWRT on a capable router get you a more familiar command line interface and an awful lot of packages. As far as the RCE, is SMB even enabled by default? It's an important catch and I'm not clear yet how exploitable via JS in a browser, but I can't imagine that SMB is open to the world in any router's default configuration.
- carlhjerpe 9y agoIn the home / office equipment SMB is disabled by default, and there are firewall rules blocking all incoming connections from WAN. Someone over at a MikroTik channel said "if you run SMB on your router and you've got it accessible to the world you deserve to be hacked" I can't say i disagree. The recent bug about being able to download the user database was less cool though. But it was patches very fast after it was discovered. Then again the above bug is only exploitable if you allow incoming connections from WAN on the management port, which isn't good practice (but i and many other people do it anyways because it's simple).
- fencepost 9y agoWe used to allow remote connections to management, but for probably 2-3 years it's been trusted networks only. Same for rdp, and the last customer with an in house mail server should be off it in 2-3 months. These days a blank non responsive void is the only thing that makes sense for an office.
- pjkundert 9y agoI've used MikroTik products pretty extensively over a number of years, and would recommend them -- pretty tough to beat, on a "bang for the buck" basis. No vendor's products won't have RCEs; what's important is turnaround time to deployable fix, and MikroTik's pretty fast.
- blacksmith_tb 9y agoI've been running Mikrotik routers at home for a couple of years, and I have been at least as happy with them as anything else I've used. Yes, they can be a little more awkward to configure (some of which comes down to offering multiple different tools with slightly different capabilities - command line, Webfig[1], Winbox[2], and The Dude[3]). If anyone wants to experiment with them cheaply, they do make a bargain travel router[4]. 1: https://wiki.mikrotik.com/wiki/Manual:Webfig https://wiki.mikrotik.com/wiki/Manual:Webfig 2: https://wiki.mikrotik.com/wiki/Manual:Winbox https://wiki.mikrotik.com/wiki/Manual:Winbox 3: https://wiki.mikrotik.com/wiki/Manual:The_Dude https://wiki.mikrotik.com/wiki/Manual:The_Dude 4: https://mikrotik.com/product/RBmAPL-2nD https://mikrotik.com/product/RBmAPL-2nD
- jopsen 9y agoWhat do you do for wifi?
- blacksmith_tb 9y agoRight now I am using their hAP ac[1] which does b/g/n/ac, though there's a new version[2] of it with a 4-core ARM in it which might be a little better for routing... otherwise I know people like to use Ubiqiti for their AP and choose one of the non-wifi Mikrotik models[3]. 1: https://mikrotik.com/product/RB962UiGS-5HacT2HnT https://mikrotik.com/product/RB962UiGS-5HacT2HnT 2: https://mikrotik.com/product/hap_ac2 https://mikrotik.com/product/hap_ac2 3: https://mikrotik.com/product/RB750Gr3 https://mikrotik.com/product/RB750Gr3
- martin1975 9y agoHad one for a few years. I now have/prefer pcengines apu2 + pfSense. Rock solid, performant and has everything I need and more.
- na85 9y agoWill it do 802.11ac? When I looked into OpenBSD a while ago (2017), there were no ac-compatible drivers available for the apu2.
- martin1975 9y agonot sure - I have an external Ubiquiti AP I use, plugged into the APU2's ethernet port. You want wifi as part of the APU2 or separate?
- na85 9y agoI was planning on using my apu2 with the built-in antennas, just because that's what it has. Would you mind describing your setup/config? Is it just the apu2 plus a ubiquiti AP? Which AP?
- martin1975 9y agonot at all: from pcengines, I got: https://www.pcengines.ch/apu2c4.htm https://www.pcengines.ch/apu2c4.htm https://www.pcengines.ch/case1d2redu.htm https://www.pcengines.ch/case1d2redu.htm https://www.pcengines.ch/msata16f.htm https://www.pcengines.ch/msata16f.htm https://www.pcengines.ch/ac12vus2.htm https://www.pcengines.ch/ac12vus2.htm put that together and installed pfSense per their instructions: http://pcengines.ch/howto.htm#OS_installation http://pcengines.ch/howto.htm#OS_installation You could get their wifi modules: https://www.pcengines.ch/wle200nx.htm https://www.pcengines.ch/wle200nx.htm https://www.pcengines.ch/wle600vx.htm https://www.pcengines.ch/wle600vx.htm but I advise against it if you want to run pfSense, since driver support on pfSense for these might be sketchy/difficult to get working. Linux might be a better choice for a router OS if you're going to get those modules. My personal recommendation is to avoid getting wifi onboard the apu2 and stick with this instead: https://www.ubnt.com/airmax/nanostationm/ https://www.ubnt.com/airmax/nanostationm/ or if you want 802.11ac: https://www.ubnt.com/airmax/nanostation-ac/ https://www.ubnt.com/airmax/nanostation-ac/ and just take up one of the three ports available on the apu2 permanently for your Nanostation. Set this up, and you'll be happy for years. I consider it the ultimate DIY home router setup and I've experimented with many. This one takes the cake. The only thing I wish for is an extra RJ-45 port on the pcengines APU2 for some of the devices that are close by it (e.g. a mac mini I use as HTPC), but since everything or nearly everything has wifi nowadays, you don't get to notice this much. Worst case, if you need extra ports, hit amazon and type only "pfsense" in the box - there's a vendor called ProtectLi (https://protectli.com/ https://protectli.com/) which sells 4 and 6 port boxes similar to the APU2, but with Intel instead of AMD (I'm kind of partial to AMD plus PCEngines is run by Americans/Swiss :). Those will work just as well though you're looking at spending more $$$. If that's no objective, then just get the 4 or 6 port ProtectLi. Reply here let me know how it works out once you've got it setup the way you want.
- _o_ 9y agoI am running mikrotik as home router for... I think 2 years and am perfectly happy with it. It is extremly stable and you can configure it into every detail (to the LEDs and beeper... and I am not joking). Microtik is also very fast with updating vulnerabilities. But I wouldn't recomend it to everyone, for configuring it beyond basic configuration (like QoS), you need to understand networking, it is not a consumer grade product. Bottom line, great routers, packed with features, not simple to configure.
- jascenso 9y agoGreat router ! Very good quality/price. I have used it to teach an introductory course in computer networking and it could perform well many net protocols (DHCP, NAT, etc.) and even some advanced routing configurations (with RIP/OSPF). UI was a little rough on the edges but after a while you get used to.
- jsisto 9y agoI have been using Mikrotik routers for years now. I love the winbox interface.
- carlhjerpe 9y agoIt's quite funny how most people say they hate the WinBox interface. I'm a huge fan of mixing the CLI and the WinBox interface, i also like that the CLI and the GUI management solutions are tightly coupled together and that you can do "everything" (99%) of everything in either of them (some superrare features are only in the CLI).
- dschulz 9y agoMikroTik gear is awesome. Extremely flexible and reliable. I work with different models daily since ~2007.
- q3k 9y agoNote: Mikrotik are violating the GPL (at least in spirit, by having you request sources by mail instead of just publishing them) by shipping RouterBoards/RouterOS without any Linux sources. You might want to take this into consideration before spending money with them. (they even ship their rootfs with proprietary kernel modules that are marked as license: GPL so that they don't taint the kernel, ie for their bandwidth test)
- Hello71 9y agothe "spirit" of GPL is not "everything must be on GitHub". from the start, the GPL allowed distribution on physical media. given that in 1989, the state of the art in file distribution was Usenet, and given that even today, Stallman allegedly still uses his wget contraption, it is safe to say that Stallman did not in fact envision that all software under the GPL must be distributed online.
- theogravity 9y agoI was using Mikrotik for a while until I wanted to optimize bufferbloat issues - my goto algo has been fq_codel, which Mikrotik does not support. I've fiddled around with the other available algos, but nothing comes close to the performance that fq_codel has out of the box. I ended up switching to Opnsense instead. It was a good medium between dd-wrt and Mikrotik in terms of usability / exposed features. Mikrotik is for those who want to do traffic manipulation at very low levels - it's not for the faint of heart if you're not a network pro. I also didn't like that I had to pay for a new license if I had to change the hardware in my box.
- cat199 9y agoBeen home routing for about 15y, first on old PC's with 2x nics, then on more embedded kit (soekris boxes RIP, about to upgrade to PC Engines hardware since my particular soekris boxes, though still running strong, are getting a bit long in the tooth for modern speeds). Strongly suggest just throwing OpenBSD on a flash disk (possibly with the help of flashrd) and going from there. Once you get a taste of the solidness of pf & the openbsd network configuration tools/documentation, you'll miss it every time you use another free OS.