3 ms·
The most interesting part: "MADD is heading the opposition, .. arguing that the 21 law has saved more than 20,000 lives. Choose Responsibility disputes that fi
by josefresco 19y ago
The most interesting part:
"MADD is heading the opposition, .. arguing that the 21 law has saved more than 20,000 lives. Choose Responsibility disputes that figure. Other factors, it says, have also contributed to the decline in deaths, and fatalities among under-age drunk drivers have fallen by only 13%."
And those factors are? I'm not saying the 21 law is responsible but what is the debate here?
- jrockway 19y ago> MADD is heading the opposition, .. arguing that the 21 law has saved more than 20,000 lives. I don't think this is a relevant statistic. We could save more lives by completely banning alcohol. We could save even more by not allowing people to leave their house. We could do these things, but we can't solve all our problems by making living life illegal. People die.
- Xichekolas 19y agoIt seems to me the issues of drunk driving and drinking age are orthogonal. There were just as many kids driving drunk (under 21) when I was in HS as there were driving drunk (over 21) when I was in college. Age had nothing to do with it, and legal access to alcohol didn't either. MADD's argument is fallacious, but it's the same line of reasoning that those advocating banning of firearms take. Somehow making guns illegal will cut down on gun-related-deaths. Nevermind that the people that tend to shoot other people don't really care if they have to get a gun illegally, just like kids that drink underage don't really care that they are getting alcohol illegally. In a perfect world, you could just remove all guns at once and perfectly enforce the alcohol age limit every time (and there would be no black market), but that isn't reality. If MADD was really interested in cutting down on drunk driving, they'd campaign for stiffer penalties and education. And, like someone else here pointed out, they'd campaign for public transportation. When the car is the only option to get home, your choices are either "don't drink" or "drive drunk."
- eat_my_shorts 19y agoA better approach is to have excellent public transportation. Then people can get around without driving everywhere. Japan has a business culture predicated on drinking, but they have trains and mini-hotel rooms in case you miss them.
- ardit33 19y agoMadd has been saying this for years, but it ignores the fact that in Canada, even though the drinking age didn't change, deaths related to alcohol decresed about the same amount (percentage wise). Madd was started for a good cause, but right now it is just a right wing, prohibistic organization, hell bent on stoping drinking whatsover, and of course it's memembers have self interest to keep their campains (and their salaries) going on. Even their first founder doesn't want to do anything with them anymore.