4 ms·
Also true: Creating the middle class was a deliberate, hard fought policy choice. The USA has done it (massive redistribution of wealth) three times. We're ove
by specialist 9y ago
Also true:
Creating the middle class was a deliberate, hard fought policy choice. The USA has done it (massive redistribution of wealth) three times. We're overdue for the fourth cycle.
Wealth and Democracy: A Political History of the American Rich [2003] http://a.co/6rMyoc1 http://a.co/6rMyoc1
"The Second Gilded Age has been staggering enough in its concentration of wealth to dwarf the original Gilded Age a hundred years earlier. However, the tech crash and then the horrible events of September 11, 2001, pointed out that great riches are as vulnerable as they have ever been. In Wealth and Democracy, Kevin Phillips charts the ongoing American saga of great wealth–how it has been accumulated, its shifting sources, and its ups and downs over more than two centuries. He explores how the rich and politically powerful have frequently worked together to create or perpetuate privilege, often at the expense of the national interest and usually at the expense of the middle and lower classes.
With intriguing chapters on history and bold analysis of present-day America, Phillips illuminates the dangerous politics that go with excessive concentration of wealth. Profiling wealthy Americans–from Astor to Carnegie and Rockefeller to contemporary wealth holders–Phillips provides fascinating details about the peculiarly American ways of becoming and staying a multimillionaire. He exposes the subtle corruption spawned by a money culture and financial power, evident in economic philosophy, tax favoritism, and selective bailouts in the name of free enterprise, economic stimulus, and national security.
Finally, Wealth and Democracy turns to the history of Britain and other leading world economic powers to examine the symptoms that signaled their declines–speculative finance, mounting international debt, record wealth, income polarization, and disgruntled politics–signs that we recognize in America at the start of the twenty-first century. In a time of national crisis, Phillips worries that the growing parallels suggest the tide may already be turning for us all."
- pitaj 9y agoThe middle class was not created via redistribution of wealth. It came about through wealth creation. It existed long before the New Deal and WWII.
- jonathanyc 9y agoIf you’re going to make a drive-by comment whose content is just “the GP is wrong,” you should at least back it up with some evidence, especially when the GP has provided a source.
- nickik 9y agoOr you can look at basic math. The government budget was simply never large enough to redesrbiute the amoutn of wealth the middle class holds.
- splintercell 9y agoIrrespective of whether your comment being correct, the GP has a point regarding the GGP comment being a drive-by. Although I also think that GGGP comment is also a drive-by, it just has a color of 'reasoning'.
- true_religion 9y agoThe "source" is just inane fluff. It reads like a book review. It hints at topics, but never declares what is to be said about them. It was such an imposing wall of text, that I read it thrice hoping to fine anything that I could reply to in argument, but there's simply nothing there. It's not evidence. It's not a source. It's not even an argument. It's a teaser to buy the book and find out if the book has an argument within it.
- specialist 9y agoKevin Phillips is an economist that served multiple administrations and teaches. He has no shortage of published works, interviews, reviews, criticisms. I encourage you start your quest by clicking the handy link provided.
- _Tev 9y agoSeems more like appeal to authority rather than an argument.
- specialist 9y agoHad you read Philips' book, even just the synopsis, you'd find that you're repeating his thesis. So blame me, not the esteemed economist.
- WalterBright 9y ago> Creating the middle class was a deliberate, hard fought policy choice. The middle class appeared in the US right along with industrialization. You can see it in paintings of towns and such before the Civil War. All sorts of businesses and middle class homes. A few years ago a pre-war Mississippi steamboat wreck was dug up and it was stuffed full of trade goods for middle class people.
- specialist 9y agoPhillips gives the https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homestead_Acts https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homestead_Acts as one of three times the US government choose to create a middle class. The alternative proposal was selling the land to raise money directly for the government. Imagine if that had happened. We probably would have had South American style share croppers in toiling in usury and enduring inequity.
- closeparen 9y agoMassacaring and redistributing the assets of another civilization is one way to make your own people wealthy, but depending on how you categorize Native Americans, I’m not sure that the Homestead Act actually increased the number of “middle class” people in North America.
- WalterBright 9y agoAny explanation for the wealth of the US would also have to explain why it didn't happen for S. America. After WW2, the Soviets trucked every asset they could out of Germany to the USSR, but what was left still produced a much wealthier middle class than in the post war USSR. I suggest the historical record is that massacring and seizing doesn't produce a middle class.
- specialist 9y agoI found Hernando de Soto's Mystery of Capital compelling. https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/86154.The_Mystery_of_Capital https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/86154.The_Mystery_of_Cap... Though I haven't kept up on all the subsequent criticisms and refinements, I'm confident his central thesis is solid. At least solid enough to be worth criticizing.