3 ms·
...and then LE also revokes their certificate.
by userbinator 9y ago
...and then LE also revokes their certificate.
- mynewtb 9y agoThat is a really farfetched scenario which I would never imagine happening. LE are not Cloudflare, I am sure they would not ridicule their neutral mission without actual legal force.
- sillysaurus3 9y agoUnfortunately it's not far fetched. I wish it were. It's just an unpleasant thought we've decided not to think about. LE are a US corp, subject to US laws, and at the whim of US court orders. The implications of that are worth gaming out. Our laws are (arguably) mostly fair. But there are cases where they're not. Picture a world where an administration rises to power in the US on a platform that seems insane, but everybody endorses it anyway. And this platform just so happens to be against the sort of thing you're trying to do on the internet. Sci-hub are stealing. We as a community are mostly fine with that. We don't consider it stealing, because the moral good outweighs the bad by a hundred to one. But this isn't about Sci-hub. This is about a world in which we're free to do as we please, because we have the ability to decide what we want to do. If we want to make a site that can make information available, and someone else doesn't like that information or feels that they own it, what do you do? You have no power. And when you blindly put your faith in institutions like Let's Encrypt on their platform of openness and trust, you set yourself up for a shift: One day you wake up and find out you were mistaken, and we were all mistaken to push this centralized model in the name of security and convenience. And of course, that's the fundamental truth, isn't it? Liberties have always been eroded by pushing security and convenience. We should think carefully about who we trust, and why.
- JamesBarney 9y agoSorry this is a pet peeve of mine, but I don't think sci-hub is stealing, it's infringing copyright. And this is one of those instances where I think what words we use to describe what sci-hub is doing matters.
- userbinator 9y agowithout actual legal force. That's precisely the main concern here, given the nature of SciHub.
- gsich 9y agoAt this point you could go back to HTTP. And for LE: close down the company if that happens.
- saagarjha 9y agoBut then you have the issue of browsers marking your website as insecure, ISPs taking it upon themselves to enforce censorship, etc.