3 ms·
You're not the only one. I hypothesised about this before in previous SciHub discussions, and SciHub isn't the only site that is/will be affected. Security is t
by userbinator 9y ago
You're not the only one. I hypothesised about this before in previous SciHub discussions, and SciHub isn't the only site that is/will be affected. Security is the ostensible benefit, and it's the one they advertise the most; easier censorship and centralised access control is the other---something which a lot of the pro-(traditional)-HTTPS advocates don't advertise. Make HTTPS mandatory (so no more HTTP), make it near impossible to bypass in browsers, and you have created a very effective censorship system controlled by the CAs and whatever interests they serve.
Slowly ostracising and forcing "compliance" of those who don't toe the line is easier than before. They want you to be obedient sheep, living in an illusion of security and safety while continuing to mindlessly consume under their control.
I will resist the urge to post that memorable Franklin quote.
- x0x0 9y agoLet's not pretend the real reason google isn't so gung-ho about https everywhere is to prevent the ISPs from muscling into their businesses: * ads on page * seeing all internet traffic to enhance targeting
- dagenix 9y agoYou make it sound like this is a bad thing. Regardless of if it also benefits Google's business model, both of these things benefit users and website owners. The only thing that benefits from injecting ads into a page or deeper ISP tracking is some ISP executive's bonus.
- dagenix 9y agoChallenge: Next person that downvotes me, also leave a comment explaining why.
- saagarjha 9y agoBut then you have the other issue of your ISP having the ability to meddle with what it's sending you and silently injecting or removing content from the page. Really, I don't see a great solution either way.
- dagenix 9y agoThis reads like a conspiracy theory. Who are the pro HTTPS everywhere people that are _also_ secretly trying to further censorship? This would have to be a fairly vast conspiracy, but, you don't provide any evidence.
- posterboy 9y agoIt's a simple fact. It doesn't need to be planned or conspirated. The fact that root CAs are at the top, modulo self signed certs exchanged person to person IRL, is certainly no secret. The conspiracy would be that they might use the fact to censor or listen, whoever they are. The conspiracy would be not to tell anyone beforehand, because otherwise it wouldn't be a conspiracy anymore. What kind of exhaustive evidence do you expect for the claim that they are not saying something? And maybe you are right, this is extremely hypothetical, they would never take action to invalidate certs... Hey, wait a second!!! The real conspiracy would be to know a better system and not tell anyone. Which is like sponsoring scientific discoveries and then hiding those behind a pay wall. Oh wait again.
- dagenix 9y agoWho are "they"? Google? Mozilla? Microsoft? Apple? The 100s of CAs? And, are they all working together? And there hasn't been a single whistleblower to expose this? What do you mean "listen"? CAs can invalidate certs at will, but, they have no mechanism to listen on communications (unless you give them your private key, but, then anyone you give your private key to can eavesdrop). The CA system has lots of issues. It would be a pretty big conspiracy if there were thousands of people that knew of something better and said nothing. But, there is absolutely no proof that anyone has any idea how to do better than the CA system. Do you know of such a system or have any evidence that someone else does? Google, despite their flaws w.r.t. privacy, has done quite a bit of work to improve the CA situation - Certificate Transparency, for example.
- posterboy 9y ago> Who are "they"? A court seizing a domain thereby invalidating a cert. > What do you mean "listen"? If I accept a custom cert, but don't validate the key, I might as well use none, basically. That's the extent of my knowledge, I don't know what Certificate Transparency is doing, for example. > The CA system has lots of issues. It would be a pretty big conspiracy if there were thousands of people that knew of something better and said nothing. But, there is absolutely no proof that anyone has any idea how to do better than the CA system. Do you know of such a system or have any evidence that someone else does? > It would be a pretty big conspiracy Exactly, so why do you expect that twitter sized post could it explain it convincingly? > if there were thousands of people that knew of something better and said nothing Ironically, it might be the ability to censor communication to suppress such voices, however hypothetical that is, that triggered the GP. > But, there is absolutely no proof that anyone has any idea how to do better than the CA system. PGP is used with key exchange in real live. I'm not using it, just arguing for the sake of the argument. It has problems, too, but "better" is not a binary value , except in the limited scope of the specific problem. PGP doesn't need root CAs.