5 ms·
The best defense is being someone too uninteresting to bother. Once you're interesting so some resourceful adversary, it's very hard to avoid devices being hack
by mirimir 9y ago
The best defense is being someone too uninteresting to bother. Once you're interesting so some resourceful adversary, it's very hard to avoid devices being hacked, and virtually impossible to determine if they've been hacked.
- dredmorbius 9y agoIt's effectively feasible to monitor everyone, and to make determinations of interest after the fact. So that's not a particularly viable option.
- mirimir 9y agoMonitor, sure. But I don't believe that anyone has enough resources to backdoor everyone's machines.
- dredmorbius 9y agoThat depends where in the design, manufacture, and provisioning stage this occurs, and by whom. It's quite possible Micah was looking at the wrong signifiers. (Difficult to prove, natch, but possible.)
- mirimir 9y agoSure, it's possible. We know that the NSA intercepts machines for modification. And it's possible that hardware is generally backdoored. Maybe even by Chinese manufacturers. But what can one do, if everything is pwned? It's not practical to build machines from transistors etc. There are dreams of open-source hardware. But how could that even be done securely? The NSA can plant agents anywhere, in theory.
- dredmorbius 9y agoI wasn't addressing this. Only the first of your assumptions, that it is somehow possible to escape surveillance. I'm increasingly of the view that it's not, at least not through individual action. My interest is, for first strokes, painting an accurate picture of the landscape. Which means discarding inaccurate models and frames. Among those: that laying low is possible, or a positive (that's precisely the objective of the Panopticon, and self-censorship abd -reegulation are the most efficient), or that individual rather than collective action is appropriate. It also seems that surveillance itself faces various realities and economies, which can be directly attacked.
- EGreg 9y agoThey have https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dual_EC_DRBG https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dual_EC_DRBG
- mrschwabe 9y agoOr not be a coward and be interesting, speak up, and not back down. If more of us do that than not then they will at least have a very difficult time in tracking us all.
- tomcooks 9y agoWhile I agree with the meaning behind your post, I think that this attitude leads to self destruction in the current timeline. A much smarter approach in my opinion is to live on two separate layers: a secure private underground and an uninteresting public surface. This not only keeps the enemy content, it also keeps tracking low; any open confrontation will necessarily lead to harsher measures, which ultimately means violence. If samizdat worked in the URSS it can work nowadays too.
- mrschwabe 9y agoShould I experience an untimely demise know that it was not self-destruction, I am a martyr.
- mirimir 9y ago> A much smarter approach in my opinion is to live on two separate layers: a secure private underground and an uninteresting public surface. Yes. And never connect layers. Mirimir has no meatspace contacts. Also, one can have more than two layers.
- wglb 9y agoBut you don't exactly know what the motives of the resourceful adversary are. You are likely to be attacked for reasons that you don't anticipate. This is what I call "defense by presumed motive" and is flawed.