2 ms·
I don't think that a reasonable argument could be made for legalizing meth or heroin, for example. They're just too destructive/deadly. It's like how not wearin
by StavrosK 9y ago
I don't think that a reasonable argument could be made for legalizing meth or heroin, for example. They're just too destructive/deadly. It's like how not wearing a seatbelt while driving is illegal, it's to protect you from yourself.
- nharada 9y agoOne argument would be that by legalizing these drugs, it's much easier to offer treatment and addiction therapy. Users are less likely to get help when their habit is illegal, and the stigma around illegal activities makes citizens less willing to fund social programs that might help because they view it as helping criminals who don't deserve their hard earned tax money.
- StavrosK 9y agoI meant legalizing the sale of the drug, not usage. I don't think addicts should be considered criminals.
- loeg 9y agoCriminalizing the supply chain has disadvantages, too. The government loses sales tax revenue and criminal organizations make large profits. Quality isn't controlled and is often dangerously polluted (e.g., fentanyl being sold as heroin). Also, not all drug users are addicts.
- jMyles 9y ago> I don't think that a reasonable argument could be made for legalizing meth or heroin Do you literally mean this? That all the arguments in favor of legalizing heroin are unreasonable? I'm curious to hear what you think is unreasonable about, for example, Why Our Drug Laws Have Failed and What We Can Do About It by Jim Gray or Drug Crazy by (unrelated) Mike Gray. It's hard for me to understand the position of prohibition of (especially the more dangerous) drugs, but it's very hard for me to imagine how you find these positions unreasonable. Here's a talk advocating legalizing all drugs which I think is something like the definition of reasonableness (15 years old - it feels a little dated now, but still good stuff): https://youtu.be/xEC2IK4piwI?t=5067 https://youtu.be/xEC2IK4piwI?t=5067
- DanBC 9y agoLegalised doesn't necessarily mean "sold in shops". meth and heroin are destructive. But illegal meth and heroin are more destructive than a medically supplied legal form.
- daeken 9y agoMeth is legal. It's a prescription drug in most of the world, e.g. Desoxyn in the US. Heroin is a prescription pain killer in the UK and several other countries. Many of the most notable destructive aspects of drugs come from impure and unknown products, gang/cartel distribution, and treating drug abuse as a crime rather than a disease.
- ryanlol 9y ago>heroin, for example. They're just too destructive/deadly How is heroin inherently destructive/deadly? Most of it's problems seem to stem from its illegality.
- refurb 9y agoNot sure why this is downvoted. Long-term use of heroin produces no long term physician damage beyond chronic constipation. Heroin is destructive because it's illegal. People take drugs of unknown purity and die from overdoses or infections. And people commit crimes to pay for the black market markup. They have heroin replacement programs in Europe where addicts get prescription heroin. Experience shows that an addicts life gets pretty boring on it (boring from the stability). Which causes many of them to actually do something with their life rather than just hustle 24/7 to pay for black market heroin.
- sambull 9y agoSame argument for eating meat, and fast food right?
- LouisSayers 9y agoIf you legalise it you can tax it, you can ensure people don’t go overboard with personal consumption, and ensure the drugs are actually not laced with potentially deadly substances. It makes users more visible, and gives an easy point of contact to help those that want the help. I’d say it comes down to how you deliver the drugs - like you should not sell to people that have never used it, and it should still require something like a mini consultation before you get it - allowing people that really want help to walk away from it. People today are taking harder drugs - so why not put a supportive and regulated context around that. Having it underground causes more problems and makes people judge others when what they really need is help.
- Broken_Hippo 9y agoSeat belts aren't there to protect you from yourself: They are there to make a possibly deadly activity less deadly. And in some drug classes (like heroin), this is what legalisation does. We already have experience with heroin and other opiods because of the medical uses. With legalisation, we can make sure the strength is correct. We can get rid of some impurities. We can make meth in a proper science lab instead of blowing up a neighborhood house. We can be sure of clean needles, clean products, and things like that. If someone starts to come into clinics often, we can suggest treatment early on. We can educate people on signs of addiction and a slew of other things. It won't stop a subset of problems, just makes them a little better.