4 ms·
> While the researchers were certain the disembodied brains did not regain consciousness I'm curious how they were able to verify this. I am under the (perhap
by colordrops 9y ago
> While the researchers were certain the disembodied brains did not regain consciousness
I'm curious how they were able to verify this. I am under the (perhaps incorrect?) impression that consciousness is neither well defined nor a binary function.
- newshorts 9y agoAgreed. It may not be observing itself but there was obviously some brain function. This is fascinating research.
- staticassertion 9y ago"the scientists concluded they were producing a flat brain wave comparable with someone in a comatose state."
- herpderperator 9y agoI was also curious, but as I kept reading it seems they may have answered that. > After initially shocking results indicating the brains were partially conscious – which later turned out to be mistaken – the scientists concluded they were producing a flat brain wave comparable with someone in a comatose state. > “That animal brain is not aware of anything, I am very confident of that,” said Dr Sestan.
- krona 9y agoSimply that certain brain waves correlate with some definition of awareness of your surroundings. I'd imagine its pretty hard to be certain that a brain-dead person can't perceive his or her surroundings, however.
- TomMckenny 9y agoBut someone with far less brain activity than, for example, an unconscious patient on an operating table is not going to be more conscious.
- Waterluvian 9y agoIts a rational, intuitive assumption. But we learn new things all the time.
- zipwitch 9y agoGiven that there are people walking around living perfectly normal lives who have only a small fraction of normal brain mass, I'm always skeptical of definitive pronouncements regarding conciousness.
- logicallee 9y ago>Given that there are people walking around living perfectly normal lives who have only a small fraction of normal brain mass, Could you find a link perhaps? I Googled the end of what I just quoted but didn't find anything...
- monkpit 9y agoHow would a disembodied brain even be capable of being “aware of its surroundings” without any sensory information?
- Razengan 9y agoSome sense of touch/pressure/temperature as the skin does, perhaps? Consider how we can feel physical sensations in dreams without any physical source, or “phantom limbs” that amputees are sometimes said to feel.
- digi_owl 9y agoThat is not being aware, that is the brain making stuff up from noise.
- swiley 9y agoHuman brains can’t sense any of that, idk about pig brains.
- ghkbrew 9y agoFun fact: the retina and optic nerve are outgrowths of the developing brain, and commonly considered part of it. So technically a bare brain can see.
- swebs 9y agoThey measured brain waves via an electroencephalogram. The lack of brain waves reflects a lack of brain activity. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neural_oscillation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neural_oscillation
- Karlozkiller 9y agoIt's not well defined, but we can compare a dead brain to a brain in comatose to a fully awake and perceptive brain. I assume, given what they say in the article, that the pig brain activity in the experiment was somewhere close to the activity of a dead brain or a brain in a coma. They also explained that the blood-replacement they used contain a lot of inhibitive substances probably preventing the brains from being active even if they could.
- blueprint 9y agoHow do you define consciousness such that pigs have actual consciousness on their own (without having spent some significant amount of time with humans)?
- cmrdporcupine 9y agoYou have to wonder if the evidence of lack of consciousness could just as easily be a result of the lack of any sensory input whatsoever. I mean what does a brain do with absolutely no external stimulus at all?
- rocqua 9y agoHow would we stimulate such a brain? Would you put electrodes on nerves going into the brain-stem?
- Baeocystin 9y agoIt hallucinates its own patterns. the tl;dr is that a healthy brain produces a significant amount of activity, even absent of sensory stimulation. https://www.quora.com/What-happens-in-the-brain-during-sensory-deprivation https://www.quora.com/What-happens-in-the-brain-during-senso...
- Razengan 9y ago> what does a brain do with absolutely no external stimulus at all? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dream https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dream