3 ms·
Nice but I wish the author had called out the impact of globalization a bit more strongly. The structure of a Mall or Walmart takes economic output of an area a
by ChuckMcM 9y ago
Nice but I wish the author had called out the impact of globalization a bit more strongly. The structure of a Mall or Walmart takes economic output of an area and sends it somewhere else. That mechanism is that people buy stuff for cheap at the department store, a fraction of that money stays in the form of salaries and taxes, and the bulk goes far way to distribution houses and factories somewhere else. If you don't have something pumping money in, it eventually all drains out.
When you collapse the entire flow locally so a local factory/tailor making clothes being sold by a local merchant. Then there is a more immediate return of the economic product. Customer buys a suit, that was sold by a store that bought it from a manufacturer, that bought the fabric from a local textile mill, all of which use machines and staff and other factories and tool shops.
I am not sure how you balance this sort of thing out.
- URSpider94 9y agoThat’s nice in principle. In practice, the reason we have the system we have is that it delivers goods to customers much more efficiently than ever. Back when every small town had its own clothing store, customers were paying enough for the clothes that the shopkeeper and his/her staff could lead middle-class lives off of their profits, not to mention all of the people in the nearby factories who made them. We can go back to those times, but consumers will have to decide that they are happy having fewer clothing items, keeping them for much longer, dressing their children in hand-me-downs, and probably still spending a larger portion of their income on clothing than they do now.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoAs I read what you wrote, it seems you restate the author’s point (which I agree with). Globalization brought lower prices and greater selection at the cost of the health of the community. Sort of like eating sweetened thing tastes great but you have to watch what it does to your health over time.
- isostatic 9y ago> probably still spending a larger portion of their income on clothing than they do now. As we have spent less of our income on things like food, clothing, etc, and increased our household income dramatically. In 1971 median household income was c. £270/week. In 2001 £420/week, in 2011 £460/week. (figures adjusted for inflation to 2013 levels) In 1971 housing costs were £20/week, in 2001 is was £90 a week, in 2011 £120 a week. Half of that extra money went in housing costs. The big changes in income (especially in normalisation of a second income) from the 70s onwards were swept up in housing. Increase everyone's wages, and we just spend it on the same houses we had before. On the flip side, decrease everyone's wages and the amount we spend on houses will reduce. That benefits everyone apart from wealthy landowners.