4 ms·
"I would like to hire more women, but the number of job applications from women were well below 5 percent." Wait, WHY do you want more women? Are they more sk
by wccrawford 16y ago
"I would like to hire more women, but the number of job applications from women were well below 5 percent."
Wait, WHY do you want more women? Are they more skilled somehow? Because if not, that's sexist. You should be hiring the best person for the job, not looking for people that fit a certain concept in your mind.
- sanswork 16y agoA good mix of genders can lead to a healthier office life and better work. All male and all female offices are not ideal for various(and sometimes different) reasons.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoCould you perhaps state those reasons? [edit: sorry for asking. Didn't realize asking a poster to explain their reasoning was frowned upon here. ]
- juliamae 16y agoI'm a female dev who has mostly worked in male-dominated teams. I'm currently working in a female-dominated team. The differences are extreme, with the largest being that the mostly-female team has a really difficult time taking criticism and giving criticism (saying 'no' to bad ideas). They're too optimistic and not realistic enough IMO. But what do I know, I'm just the dev! :\
- dkarl 16y agoI'm not surprised that giving criticism is harder, since women are socialized to give feedback indirectly, through body language and other social signs, and even when speaking about a problem not to do so plainly. Simply saying what you think is treated as a "masculine" trait. I imagine the ways of communicating that are treated as appropriately "feminine" are much less effective in a technical context. Do you consciously model ways to give criticism that your female coworkers will feel comfortable with? Does it help them open up and criticize each other? What works? (This is a subject I have an interest in in a personal context as well, since I sometimes get baffled and frustrated by indirect communication and would like to be better at coaxing women to be more direct, which is hard if the relationship isn't already close.) Also, I'm surprised that women have a hard time taking criticism. I didn't expect that at all. Can you say more?
- sanswork 16y agoBoth genders bring different experiences and perspectives to problem solving. Also having a mix of genders in an office in my experience leads the natural cliques that form in any office to be more interdependent. I'm not a sociologist or claim I can explain it but that has been my experience in working in almost purely female or male environments and working in mixed environments. Having someone in the extreme minority will always make them feel like an outsider.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoIf you are problem solving in a domain where gendered perspectives are irrelevant [1], would you then agree there is little value to having diversity? As for cliques, I don't have much experience with them. Within university departments, I only observed three particular flavors of clique: domain specific (math/physics, number theory), chinese, and women. I suppose you are right - the woman clique did have women from multiple domains in it. As for being in the minority, I don't agree with you there. In all walks of my daily life, I am an extreme (racial) minority. In the past month or two, excluding family, I've had a conversation with perhaps 2-3 people of the same race as me. It isn't an issue at all - right now, I feel like less of an outsider than during past periods where I dealt with lots of people like me. [1] Examples would include every field I've ever worked in: trading stocks, medical imaging, quantum physics.
- sanswork 16y agoI would say getting perspectives from different people is never irrelevant. So no I would not argue against diversity even in those cases you listed. It is possible you just didn't recognize the cliques. They aren't always super obvious even when they are prevalent. I like racial minorities in the workplace are a different concern than gender minorities. Mindless discrimination based on race is very much noticed and looked down on these days. I wouldn't say its the same about gender. If all your co-workers always forgot to invite you to lunch or assumed you wouldn't want to do what they do because of your race you would be right to compare.
- 16y ago
- slantyyz 16y agoNot just that, but a mix of genders, ethnic backgrounds, etc. Diversity is good. It also prevents the office from becoming a chauvinistic sausagefest, where people all of a sudden feel like it's ok to make inappropriate jokes because they're surrounded by guys.
- tptacek 16y agoStop freaking out. He wasn't suggesting setting up quotas. I read him to mean that he likes the idea of hiring women, which makes sense to me because that's how I feel about it too. Any time the gender discussion comes up, a bunch of people suck all the air out of the conversation by burning straw men. Here, let me head some of them off: it's not your fault there aren't many women in tech; no, we shouldn't give less qualified people jobs; yes, there clearly are fewer women then men going to school for engineering and CS.
- pchristensen 16y agoHe is hiring the best people, he just wishes that more of the people he's willing to hire were women.
- mikeryan 16y ago, personally, would like to hire more women. At least that way I wouldn't be tarred by the same brush as those who really do discriminate. Unfortunately I also get a disproportionate amount of resumes skewed male, sheer statistics are going to say I'm going to hire more men. And I'm still going to feel like I'm the asshole when these "not enough women in tech" posts come around.