3 ms·
A world without natural death would have a very different attitude towards children. There simply wouldn't be room for very many new people on a planet populate
by pavlov 9y ago
A world without natural death would have a very different attitude towards children. There simply wouldn't be room for very many new people on a planet populated by immortal 300-year-olds.
Most people wouldn't be able to start a family. The few who get the opportunity would probably be carefully vetted by governments.
The dragon fable is emotional, but it doesn't address any of the questions of what a "post-dragon" world of inevitable gerontocracy would look like. If bodies don't fail, that doesn't automatically mean brains wouldn't decay. Will the old people in power remain open to new ideas and challenges? Do we really want immortal Bezos and Zuckerberg expanding their empires in perpetuity?
- TeMPOraL 9y ago> Most people wouldn't be able to start a family. The few who get the opportunity would probably be carefully vetted by governments. Maybe. Or maybe there would be a push to engineer deserts to be habitable. To create undersea habitats. To colonize Mars and expand further. This might not happen, but it is a solution. Also, with more and more interesting things to do and without the societal pressure to have children (as we have today), less people would even want to start a family. I believe the problem is manageable, and I don't buy the "we have to die, so that new people can live (and die)" line of reasoning. > If bodies don't fail, that doesn't automatically mean brains wouldn't decay. It would probably happen. But that would be a nice problem to have. > Do we really want immortal Bezos and Zuckerberg expanding their empires in perpetuity? We seem to be managing this problem with wealthy families, so we could probably manage it with individuals as well.
- pavlov 9y ago> Or maybe there would be a push to engineer deserts to be habitable. To create undersea habitats. To colonize Mars and expand further. Would immortals risk themselves in such endeavors? If death came only through bodily harm, it makes sense that people would go to great lengths to protect their bodies. Maybe we can assume that robots would be doing all the dangerous work. But why go to the effort of creating new more dangerous habitats for mankind, when societies could just remove the population growth pressure? I don’t see any reason why a world of immortals wouldn’t eventually evolve into something like planet Solaria in Asimov’s Robot series: static, extremely risk-averse, minimal population to ensure maximum resources for each individual.
- mannykannot 9y agoIt is not technical plausible that these measures would be effective enough to avoid the necessity for the deep social changes that Pavlov outlined. I am disappointed in Bostrom for ending his story just when it gets difficult.
- TeMPOraL 9y agoThe point of Bostrom's story was to get people to even consider aging as a solvable problem. Someone else can (and should) write the "Life in post-dragon world" essay.
- chroma 9y agoThe most common rebuttal to this is that a low birth rate is better than a high death rate. Even if everyone was immortal (not just unaging, as that would only reduce death rates by ≈90%), couples could still have one child each. That would leave the final population at twice the original population. 8 billion people have 4 billion kids, who have 2 billion kids, who have 1 billion kids... etc. > Will the old people in power remain open to new ideas and challenges? Do we really want immortal Bezos and Zuckerberg expanding their empires in perpetuity? Nobody knows. Fixing aging will cause new problems, but those problems will not be as bad as 100,000 people dying every day. Lastly, who thinks aging will never be fixed? Maybe we fix it in 30 years. Maybe it takes 100 years. But unless we destroy our civilization, humanity will invent anti-aging technology. So we have all the problems you worry about, though perhaps not in your lifetime.
- rohit2412 9y agoI think a more realistic dynamic would be a couple having children every hundred years or so. A couple having only a single child over their infinite lifetime sounds unrealistic. We will have a population explosion with immortality.
- eli_gottlieb 9y ago>The dragon fable is emotional, but it doesn't address any of the questions of what a "post-dragon" world of inevitable gerontocracy would look like. If bodies don't fail, that doesn't automatically mean brains wouldn't decay. Will the old people in power remain open to new ideas and challenges? Do we really want immortal Bezos and Zuckerberg expanding their empires in perpetuity? We already have a gerontocracy, and Bezos and Zuckerberg already have empires. Blaming a fantasy of immortality for the problems of real-life capitalism or democratic decay makes no sense. If your house is falling down from mold and termites, you don't blame the future house, you blame the damn mold.
- pavlov 9y agoThe house is mold-ridden and someone proposes that what we really need is to turn it into a tropical spa. That's how useful the dragon parable feels.
- tim333 9y agoAn advantage of the upload your mind scenario is you could live on in VR rather than cluttering the planet with old bodies.