2 ms·
(I don't think he should have got prison time for this crime.) It's useful to read the emails from the defendant. He's not just burning re-installation DVDs.
by DanBC 9y ago
(I don't think he should have got prison time for this crime.)
It's useful to read the emails from the defendant.
He's not just burning re-installation DVDs. He's going out of his way to burn re-installation DVDs that are identical to MS / Dell supplied discs, even down to holograms in the disc.
Customers were rejecting the discs because they were "counterfeit". He was saying things like "tell him the product is guaranteed to be real". "Customs can't tell the difference and therefore is not legally allowed to hold them hehe"
https://blogs.microsoft.com/uploads/prod/sites/5/2018/04/2LUNDGREN6.pdf https://blogs.microsoft.com/uploads/prod/sites/5/2018/04/2LU...
But that document also shows people test installing the OSs onto different computers, and it shows them using the licence sticker on the machine to activate one of the OSs. I'm not sure that was made clear to the judge: the machines are licenced, and if the machines aren't licenced the supplied discs won't activate. So, I wonder how the discs were being sold. "These discs are licenced, and you won't have problems with activation" would be bad.
EDIT: in general, when you're ending emails to people describing how you're going to evade customs you're probably doing something wrong, and know that you're doing something wrong.
- SiempreViernes 9y agoThe copyright infringement on the packaging is blatant, but valuing recovery disks as full operating system installers is an equally blatant lie.
- DanBC 9y agoMS valued them at $20 each. He attempted to sell some of them for more than that.
- facetube 9y agoMS values replacement disks for Win 7 Pro at twice that.
- DanBC 9y agoIn this case MS put a value of $20 per disc. The prosecution put a value of $25 per disc - that's the cost to refurbishers of the MS supplied discs. The defence tried to claim that the discs are worthless without the licence, and should be valued at either nothing or $3 each. That defence failed because he spent $80,000 creating the counterfeit product, and you don't spend that much money on worthless items.
- jaycroft 9y agoPeople spend money on "worthless" things all the time, and as a person who wants to reduce e-waste Eric would have plenty reason to spend something like $80000 to further his goal (whether his belief is justified or not). He made 28,000 disks for $80000. That is $2.85 per disk. $3 is a perfectly reasonable value.